Compare

AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcare vs Aetna Medicare Supplement

Two Medigap lines for people on Original Medicare: UnitedHealthcare's AARP-branded plans and Aetna's. Same standardized letters; membership and size differ.

Both products are Medicare Supplement (Medigap) insurance, private policies that pay part of what Original Medicare leaves to the patient. Because plan letters are standardized, a Plan G from one company covers the same benefits as a Plan G from the other in most states. The comparison is about membership rules, size, rating and service, not about what a letter pays.

Verdict

Neither profile gives a reason to rank one above the other. The AARP-branded program is the larger: a May 2026 report prepared for UnitedHealthcare counted about 4.27 million members, 29.7% of the Medigap market at the end of 2025. That figure is the insurer-supplied version of public filing data. Aetna's profile gives no membership figure because the source charts could not be read. The practical gap is that the AARP plans require AARP membership, while Aetna's profile mentions no such requirement. Neither profile quotes a premium, and prices vary by plan letter, age, state and rating method, so a quote from each is the only fair comparison. A State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) counselor can explain the options for free.

Choose AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcare if

  • You are, or are willing to become, an AARP member. The plan page says non-members can join for $20 a year.
  • You want a plan from the largest Medigap program by enrollment.
  • You qualify for Plan K or L, which the AARP page lists and Aetna's profile does not.
  • You are weighing the arrangement in which AARP receives royalties on premiums, which KFF Health News reported in 2022, and you are comfortable with it.

Choose Aetna Medicare Supplement if

  • You want to buy without an AARP membership requirement.
  • You want a company that, according to its own state pages, issues policies through Aetna Health and Life Insurance Company and links an outline of coverage for each state.
  • You want a Plan D, which Aetna's profile lists and the AARP page does not.
  • You live in a state where Aetna sells; its own page links 30 states, so confirm yours.

Key differences

AARP Medicare Supplement (UnitedHealthcare) Aetna Medicare Supplement
Parent company UnitedHealth Group CVS Health
Headquarters Minnetonka, Minnesota Hartford, Connecticut
Membership requirement AARP membership None stated
Letters listed A, B, G, K, L, N; C and F for people eligible before 2020 A, B, C, D, F, G, N; high-deductible F and G where offered
Provider network None; any provider accepting Medicare None; any provider accepting Medicare
Enrollment stated 4.27 million members, 29.7% share (December 2025) No figure given
States Not listed; not all plans in all states Company page links 30 states
Phone 1-833-591-5020 (apply; TTY 711) 888-624-6290 (member services)

Both companies say that during the six-month Medigap open enrollment period they must accept you, and that after it most states allow medical underwriting. See medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue and Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N. Complaints about either insurer go to your state insurance department.

Side by side

AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcare Aetna Medicare Supplement
Type Medigap and senior market carriers Medigap and senior market carriers
Member services — 888-624-6290
New members and sales 1-833-591-5020 (apply by phone; TTY 711) —
Website aarpmedicareplans.com aetna.com
Headquarters Minnetonka, Minnesota Hartford, Connecticut
Founded — 1853
Ownership Owned by UnitedHealth Group (NYSE: UNH); marketed under licence from AARP Investor-owned (subsidiary of CVS Health, NYSE: CVS)
Parent company UnitedHealth Group CVS Health Corporation
Stock ticker UNH —
Where it sells Plans offered depend on where you live; the company says not all plans are available in all states Many states; the company's own state page links to Medicare Supplement pages for 30 states, and third-party reviews count more, so check the state before relying on any list
Plan types Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plans A, B, G, K, L and N, plus C and F for people first eligible for Medicare before 2020; state-specific plans in Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plans A, B, C, D, F, G and N, with high-deductible versions of F and G where offered
Network types — None (any provider that accepts Medicare)
Members 4.27 million Medigap members, 29.7% of the market (December 2025, Mark Farrah Associates) —
Best suited to People on Original Medicare who are AARP members and want a standardized Medigap plan from a large national insurer. People who have Original Medicare and want a standardized policy to cover part of what Medicare leaves unpaid, with no provider network.
Plans and products
  • Medigap Plans A
  • B
  • G
  • K
  • L
  • N
  • C
  • F
  • high-deductible options in some states
  • Medicare Supplement Plan A
  • Medicare Supplement Plan G
  • Medicare Supplement Plan N
  • high-deductible Plan G
Brands and plan names
  • AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans
  • Aetna Medicare Supplement

Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Latest news on both companies