Compare

Two at a time: the facts side by side, then a plain verdict on who should choose which.

AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcare vs Aetna Medicare Supplement Two Medigap lines for people on Original Medicare: UnitedHealthcare's AARP-branded plans and Aetna's. Same standardized letters; membership and size differ. AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcare vs Mutual of Omaha Two large Medigap sellers: AARP-branded plans from UnitedHealthcare, and a policyholder-owned Nebraska insurer that also sells dental and other add-ons. AARP MedicareRx Plans (UnitedHealthcare) vs SilverScript Two stand-alone Medicare Part D drug plan families, one from UnitedHealthcare under the AARP name and one from CVS Health, compared from their profiles. Aetna (CVS Health) vs Cigna Healthcare (The Cigna Group) Aetna and Cigna Healthcare both sell mainly through employers, but Aetna sells Medicare and Cigna does not; neither sells ACA plans for 2027. Aetna (CVS Health) vs Humana Aetna, CVS Health's employer-plus-Medicare insurer, beside Humana, a Louisville insurer centered on Medicare Advantage. Neither sells ACA marketplace plans. Aetna (CVS Health) vs UnitedHealthcare Aetna (CVS Health) and UnitedHealthcare compared on size, ownership, ACA marketplace footprint and plan mix across employer, Medicare and Medicaid lines. Aflac vs Colonial Life Two supplemental insurers that pay fixed cash benefits, often through employers, compared on products, size and how each sells, using their profiles. AvMed vs Florida Blue AvMed is a South Florida nonprofit HMO and POS plan; Florida Blue is the statewide Blue plan with individual, employer and Medicare lines. Baylor Scott & White Health Plan vs Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas A health-system-owned Texas plan leaving the ACA and Medicaid after 2026, beside the state's customer-owned Blue licensee that sells in all 254 counties. Blue Cross and Blue Shield Federal Employee Program vs GEHA (Government Employees Health Association) Two nationwide FEHB options for federal employees and retirees: the Blue Cross Blue Shield Federal Employee Program and GEHA, compared from their profiles. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Minnesota vs HealthPartners Minnesota's Blue Cross licensee and HealthPartners, a nonprofit that both runs clinics and sells coverage, compared on markets, networks and product lines. Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Texas vs UnitedHealthcare Texas's customer-owned Blue plan versus UnitedHealthcare, the largest national insurer, on ownership, footprint and product lines. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massachusetts vs Harvard Pilgrim Health Care Massachusetts-only Blue plan with Medicare Advantage versus a four-state New England nonprofit that ended its Medicare Advantage plans in 2025. Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan vs Priority Health Michigan's largest insurer, a nonprofit Blue licensee, beside Priority Health, owned by Corewell Health. Both sell individual, employer and Medicare plans. Blue Shield of California vs Elevance Health (Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Wellpoint) Blue Shield of California, a statewide nonprofit, compared with Elevance Health, the investor-owned parent of Anthem Blue Cross, using their profiles. Blue Shield of California vs Kaiser Permanente (Kaiser Foundation Health Plan) A California nonprofit with HMO and PPO networks and all major lines, versus Kaiser's integrated model where one organization insures and delivers care. CareFirst BlueCross BlueShield vs Kaiser Permanente Mid-Atlantic States The Blue licensee for Maryland, D.C. and Northern Virginia beside Kaiser Permanente's Mid-Atlantic plan, which combines coverage and care in one organization. CDPHP (Capital District Physicians' Health Plan) vs MVP Health Care Two upstate New York regional plans: physician-founded CDPHP, merging with Excellus, and MVP Health Care, affiliating with Independent Health. Centene (Ambetter Health, Wellcare, Health Net) vs Molina Healthcare Two publicly traded insurers built around Medicaid and marketplace plans, compared on footprint, scale and 2027 changes using their profiles. Centene (Ambetter Health, Wellcare, Health Net) vs Oscar Health Centene (Ambetter) is a Medicaid-heavy insurer with Medicare and marketplace lines; Oscar is a marketplace specialist with an app and condition-focused plans. Cigna Healthcare (The Cigna Group) vs Delta Dental Plans Association Cigna Healthcare, an employer-focused insurer that also sells dental, beside Delta Dental, an association of 39 independent dental companies in every state. Cigna Healthcare (The Cigna Group) vs Elevance Health (Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Wellpoint) Cigna Healthcare, employer-focused and leaving the ACA individual market after 2026, versus Elevance Health, the Anthem Blue Cross licensee. Cigna Healthcare (The Cigna Group) vs UnitedHealthcare Cigna Healthcare, focused on employer plans, compared with UnitedHealthcare, which also sells Medicare, Medicaid and marketplace plans, from their profiles. Delta Dental Plans Association vs Guardian Delta Dental is an association of 39 independent dental companies; Guardian is a New York mutual insurer selling dental and vision, but no medical plans. Delta Dental Plans Association vs MetLife Delta Dental, an association of 39 independent dental companies, beside MetLife, a life insurer selling dental and vision mostly through employers. Devoted Health vs Humana Devoted Health, a young Medicare Advantage-only insurer, compared with Humana, an established Medicare-centered insurer, on footprint, size and products. Elevance Health (Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Wellpoint) vs Kaiser Permanente (Kaiser Foundation Health Plan) Elevance Health's Anthem plans, which pay outside doctors, compared with Kaiser Permanente's integrated model of one organization for coverage and care. Elevance Health (Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Wellpoint) vs Medical Mutual of Ohio Elevance runs Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in Ohio and 13 other states; Medical Mutual is an Ohio-only mutual insurer that left the Blue system in 1997. Elevance Health (Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Wellpoint) vs UnitedHealthcare Elevance Health, the Blue Cross licensee in 14 states under Anthem names, beside UnitedHealthcare, the largest U.S. health insurer by medical members. EmblemHealth vs Healthfirst Two New York City nonprofit plans compared: EmblemHealth, with its own medical practices and Connecticut subsidiary, and hospital-sponsored Healthfirst. Excellus BlueCross BlueShield vs Independent Health Excellus BlueCross BlueShield, serving 31 upstate New York counties, compared with Western New York's Independent Health, using their profiles. EyeMed Vision Care vs VSP Vision Care EyeMed (EssilorLuxottica group) and VSP (doctor-founded, not-for-profit) both sell stand-alone vision benefits through employers and to individuals. Florida Blue vs Humana Florida Blue, the Florida-only Blue licensee in all 67 counties, beside Humana, a national insurer centered on Medicare Advantage. A Florida Medicare view. Florida Blue vs Oscar Health Florida Blue, the statewide Blue licensee, versus Oscar Health, an app-based marketplace specialist selling in about 20 states, for Florida ACA shoppers. Geisinger Health Plan vs Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield Geisinger Health Plan, owned by a Pennsylvania health system, compared with Highmark, the regional Blue plan across four states, using their profiles. Golden Rule Insurance Company (UnitedHealthcare) vs Medi-Share (Christian Care Ministry) Golden Rule sells underwritten short-term insurance; Medi-Share is a Christian sharing ministry that is not insurance. Neither is an ACA plan. Golden Rule Insurance Company (UnitedHealthcare) vs National General Accident and Health Two short-term medical carriers: Golden Rule, behind UnitedHealthOne, and National General, marketed as Allstate Health Solutions. Neither is ACA coverage. Golden Rule Insurance Company (UnitedHealthcare) vs Pivot Health Golden Rule, a UnitedHealth Group insurer behind UnitedHealthOne short-term plans, versus Pivot Health, a distributor that markets partner carriers' plans. Health Alliance Plan (HAP) vs Priority Health Two Michigan provider-owned plans, Health Alliance Plan (Henry Ford Health) and Priority Health (Corewell Health), compared from their profiles. HealthPartners vs Medica Two Minnesota nonprofits: HealthPartners both delivers care and insures; Medica is a health plan that absorbed UCare's Medicaid and individual plans in 2026. Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield vs Independence Blue Cross Two Pennsylvania Blue companies: Highmark, a multi-state Blue with a hospital-system parent, and Independence Blue Cross, the Philadelphia-area Blue plan. Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield vs UPMC Health Plan Two Pittsburgh insurers tied to rival health systems: Highmark, a Blue licensee owned with Allegheny Health Network, and UPMC Health Plan, owned by UPMC. Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey vs Oxford Health Plans (UnitedHealthcare) New Jersey's Blue plan, Horizon, compared with UnitedHealthcare's Oxford brand for individual and employer shoppers, using both thin profiles. Humana vs UnitedHealthcare Humana is built around Medicare Advantage and sells no ACA or broad employer plans; UnitedHealthcare covers employer, Medicare, Medicaid and ACA lines. Humana vs Wellcare Two Medicare-heavy brands: Humana, a Louisville insurer centered on Medicare Advantage, and Wellcare, Centene's Medicare brand with special needs and Part D. Independence Blue Cross vs Jefferson Health Plans Philadelphia's Blue Cross licensee versus Jefferson Health Plans, the Jefferson Health-owned nonprofit formerly called Health Partners Plans. Kaiser Permanente (Kaiser Foundation Health Plan) vs Sutter Health Plus Kaiser Permanente's integrated model compared with Sutter Health Plus, an HMO built on Sutter Health's Northern California hospitals, from their profiles. Medi-Share (Christian Care Ministry) vs Oscar Health Medi-Share is a Christian sharing ministry that is not insurance; Oscar is a marketplace insurer whose ACA plans carry federal protections. Medi-Share (Christian Care Ministry) vs Samaritan Ministries International Two Christian health care sharing ministries. Neither is insurance, and sharing is not guaranteed. They differ in how members send money and in provider choice. Mutual of Omaha vs Physicians Mutual Two Omaha-based, policyholder-owned insurers selling Medicare Supplement (Medigap) and add-on coverage, compared on size, states and products. Premera Blue Cross vs Regence (Cambia Health Solutions) Premera Blue Cross, in Washington and Alaska, compared with the four-state Regence family of Blue plans in the Northwest, using their profiles. UnitedHealthcare vs Wellcare UnitedHealthcare sells AARP-branded Medicare plus employer and ACA lines; Wellcare is Centene's Medicare brand: Advantage, special needs and Part D.