Compare
AARP MedicareRx Plans (UnitedHealthcare) vs SilverScript
Two stand-alone Medicare Part D drug plan families, one from UnitedHealthcare under the AARP name and one from CVS Health, compared from their profiles.
Verdict
Both companies sell stand-alone Medicare Part D plans, the kind you add to Original Medicare for prescription drug coverage. Neither is a medical plan. The two differ mainly in who stands behind them, how many plan designs each offers and where each will sell in 2027. Which one suits a reader depends on that reader's region, drugs and pharmacy, and neither profile supports naming a winner.
The biggest difference for plan year 2027 is geography. According to KFF, as summarized in the SilverScript profile, CVS Health is ending its SilverScript Choice plan in 13 of Medicare's 34 drug plan regions. The AARP plans, per KFF, are offered in every state. Premiums and formularies change every year for both, so the Medicare plan finder, not either profile, gives the current answer for a ZIP code.
Choose AARP MedicareRx Plans (UnitedHealthcare) if
- You want a choice between two plan designs, AARP Medicare Rx Preferred and AARP Medicare Rx Saver, from one insurer.
- You live somewhere that a plan withdrawal could affect you, since the profile says the AARP plans are offered in every state.
- You are comfortable comparing premiums and formularies each fall; the profile notes that people who stay in a plan without comparing can face larger increases.
- You understand that UnitedHealthcare, not AARP, is the insurer, and that AARP membership is not required.
Choose SilverScript (CVS Health) if
- You live in a region where SilverScript Choice is still offered for 2027, which the Medicare plan finder will show.
- You value a pharmacy network that includes CVS, Walgreens, Walmart and many grocery chains, with mail-order delivery through CVS Caremark.
- You want a plan with a $0 Tier 1 copay feature for eligible members, as the profile describes it.
- You are not in one of the 13 regions where the plan is ending after December 31, 2026.
Key differences
| Item | AARP MedicareRx Plans | SilverScript |
|---|---|---|
| Company behind the plan | UnitedHealthcare, part of UnitedHealth Group | CVS Health |
| Brand | AARP Medicare Rx, under an AARP name license | Sold under the Aetna Medicare name |
| Plan versions | Preferred and Saver | SilverScript Choice |
| Type of coverage | Stand-alone Part D | Stand-alone Part D |
| Availability | All 50 states and D.C. | Most of the 34 Part D regions in 2026; withdrawn from 13 for 2027 |
| Pharmacy network | Preferred and standard pharmacies | CVS, Walgreens, Walmart and many grocers; CVS Caremark mail order |
| Members (CMS, November 2026, by contract) | 3,705,409 in UnitedHealth Group stand-alone Part D contracts | 3,858,783 in the contract listed under Aetna Medicare |
The member counts are by contract, not by plan, so they are not a measure of how many people use each plan design.
Where to check the current answer
Plans and premiums for 2027 are on the Medicare plan finder at Medicare.gov. A State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor or 1-800-MEDICARE can give individual, non-sales help during the Annual Enrollment Period, which runs October 15 to December 7, 2026.
Side by side
| AARP MedicareRx Plans (UnitedHealthcare) | SilverScript | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Medicare Advantage and Medicare specialists | Medicare Advantage and Medicare specialists |
| Member services | — | 844-588-0041 |
| New members and sales | — | 844-631-3766 |
| Website | aarpmedicareplans.com | aetna.com/medicare/compare-plans-enroll/… |
| Headquarters | Minnetonka, Minnesota (UnitedHealth Group headquarters) | Woonsocket, Rhode Island (CVS Health headquarters) |
| Founded | — | 2005 |
| Ownership | Owned by UnitedHealth Group (NYSE: UNH); AARP-branded under a license for which UnitedHealthcare says it pays royalties | Owned by CVS Health Corporation (NYSE: CVS) |
| Parent company | UnitedHealth Group, Inc. | CVS Health Corporation |
| Stock ticker | UNH | CVS |
| Where it sells | All 50 states and D.C. (KFF reports Preferred premium increases in all 50 states and D.C. for 2027) | Most of the 34 Part D regions in plan year 2026; withdrawn from 13 regions for 2027 (check the Medicare plan finder for your ZIP code) |
| Plan types | Stand-alone Medicare Part D prescription drug plans (AARP Medicare Rx Preferred, AARP Medicare Rx Saver) | Stand-alone Medicare Part D prescription drug plan (SilverScript Choice) |
| Network types | Pharmacy network with preferred and standard pharmacies | Pharmacy network (CVS, Walgreens, Walmart and many grocery chains); CVS Caremark mail order |
| Members | 3,705,409 members in UnitedHealth Group stand-alone Part D contracts (CMS monthly enrollment by contract, November 2026; counted by contract, not by plan) | 3,858,783 members in the stand-alone Part D contract listed under the Aetna Medicare name (CMS monthly enrollment by contract, November 2026; counted by contract, not by plan) |
| Best suited to | People who keep Original Medicare, want a separate drug plan from a large national insurer, and are comfortable comparing premiums and formularies each fall. | Medicare beneficiaries who keep Original Medicare and want a separate drug plan, in regions where SilverScript Choice is still offered for 2027. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026