Compare

Aflac vs Colonial Life

Two supplemental insurers that pay fixed cash benefits, often through employers, compared on products, size and how each sells, using their profiles.

Verdict

Aflac and Colonial Life sell the same kind of coverage: voluntary, fixed-benefit insurance that pays cash directly to you on top of a major medical plan. Neither is health insurance, and neither has a provider network. Both profiles describe workplace enrollment with payroll deduction, so for many readers the deciding question is which one their employer offers, not which company is preferable.

The profiles give little to separate them on quality, and this page does not rank them. Benefit schedules, waiting periods, exclusions and riders differ by policy and state, so the policy documents are what to compare.

Choose Aflac if

  • Your employer offers Aflac, or you want to shop for a policy yourself through its individual page.
  • You want a broad menu: accident, cancer, critical illness, hospital indemnity, dental, vision, life and disability coverage.
  • You value a financial strength rating on the record; the profile reports an A+ (Superior) from AM Best as of October 2026 for its principal U.S. insurer.
  • You are in New York, where policies are handled through a separate New York service center.

Choose Colonial Life if

  • Your employer offers Colonial Life through workplace enrollment, in person, virtually, by phone or online self-service.
  • You work in the public sector or a school; the company says it protects more than 600,000 public sector employees in 40 states.
  • You want a similar range of fixed-benefit and income-protection products from a subsidiary of Unum Group.
  • You are comfortable that availability depends on your employer, since it sells mainly through employers, brokers and independent agents.

Key differences

Item Aflac Colonial Life
Headquarters Columbus, Georgia Columbia, South Carolina
Founded 1955 1937
Ownership Aflac Incorporated (NYSE: AFL) Subsidiary of Unum Group (NYSE: UNM)
Products Accident, cancer, critical illness, hospital indemnity, dental, vision, life, disability Accident, cancer, critical illness, hospital indemnity, disability, life, dental, vision
How it sells Agents, brokers, employer enrollment and online quoting Employers, brokers and independent agents
Availability Nationwide, with a separate New York service center Most states
Provider network None None
AM Best rating in profile A+ (Superior), October 2026 Not stated

What both share

Benefits are fixed and are often small next to a serious illness. Exclusions, waiting periods and pre-existing condition limits can apply. See the guide on supplemental health insurance before treating either product as a substitute for a health plan.

Side by side

Aflac Colonial Life
Type Short-term and supplemental carriers Short-term and supplemental carriers
Member services 800-992-3522 800-325-4368
Website aflac.com coloniallife.com
Shop or enroll aflac.com/individuals —
Headquarters Columbus, Georgia Columbia, South Carolina
Founded 1955 1937
Ownership Investor-owned (NYSE: AFL) Subsidiary of Unum Group (NYSE: UNM)
Parent company Aflac Incorporated Unum Group
Stock ticker AFL —
Where it sells Nationwide; New York policies are handled through a separate New York service center Sold through employers, brokers and independent agents in most states
Plan types Accident, cancer, critical illness, hospital indemnity, dental, vision, life and disability coverage; mostly supplemental to major medical Voluntary workplace benefits: accident, cancer, critical illness, hospital indemnity, disability, life, dental, vision
Revenue About $17.2 billion total revenue, 2025 (Wikipedia summary of company results) —
AM Best financial strength A+ (Superior), financial strength of American Family Life Assurance Company of Columbus —
Best suited to People who already have major medical coverage and want fixed cash benefits for accidents, serious illness or hospital stays, often through an employer. Employees whose employer offers payroll-deducted voluntary benefits and who want fixed cash benefits on top of a major medical plan.
Plans and products
  • accident insurance
  • cancer insurance
  • critical illness insurance
  • hospital indemnity insurance
  • dental insurance
  • vision insurance
  • short-term disability
  • life insurance
  • accident insurance
  • cancer insurance
  • critical illness insurance
  • hospital indemnity insurance
  • disability insurance
  • life insurance
  • dental insurance
  • vision insurance
Brands and plan names
  • Aflac Group Insurance
  • Aflac Individual
  • Aflac Dental and Vision
  • Aflac Tier One
  • Colonial Life
  • Gathr

Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Latest news on both companies