Compare
CDPHP (Capital District Physicians' Health Plan) vs MVP Health Care
Two upstate New York regional plans: physician-founded CDPHP, merging with Excellus, and MVP Health Care, affiliating with Independent Health.
Verdict
CDPHP and MVP Health Care are regional plans with similar product lines: individual coverage, the Essential Plan, employer plans, Medicare Advantage and Medicaid-type programs. Both are in the middle of a corporate change. CDPHP says it filed in late 2025 to merge with Excellus Health Plan, planned for early 2027 and subject to state approval. MVP announced an affiliation with Independent Health in November 2025, and its own pages describe it as both pending and complete without reconciling the two.
The main contrast is footprint. CDPHP is centered on the Capital Region around Albany, in 29 New York counties. MVP sells in New York and Vermont. Both profiles say they could not confirm a current AM Best, NCQA or CMS star rating, so ratings are a gap in this comparison. Check county availability, networks and the status of each corporate change before choosing.
Choose CDPHP if
- You live in the Albany-area Capital Region or one of the other 29 counties it lists.
- You want a choice of HMO, PPO or EPO designs; its Universal Benefits plans use PPO or EPO structures.
- You value in-person help at its Customer Connect locations and in-house pharmacy and care management.
- You are prepared for 2027 changes if the merger proceeds: new ID cards and subscriber numbers, Express Scripts as pharmacy benefit manager and new claims rules.
Choose MVP Health Care if
- You live in New York or Vermont and want a plan that spans both states.
- You want a not-for-profit plan with virtual care through the Gia by MVP app.
- You are looking for dual-eligible special needs plans, dental and vision from the same company, alongside Medicare Advantage and Medicaid.
- You are comfortable that the Independent Health affiliation may bring changes later, and that the profile found few public details on its networks.
Key differences
| Topic | CDPHP | MVP Health Care |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | Nonprofit, physician-founded | Not-for-profit regional plan |
| Headquarters | Latham, New York | Not stated in the profile |
| Where it sells | 29 New York counties, centered on the Capital Region | New York and Vermont |
| Pending deal | Merger with Excellus Health Plan, planned for early 2027 | Affiliation with Independent Health; status unclear on its site |
| Network types | HMO, PPO, EPO, POS | Varies by product; a single description was not found |
| Medicare | Medicare Advantage HMO and PPO; Medicare Supplement | Medicare Advantage; dual special needs plans |
| Medicaid and children | Medicaid, Child Health Plus, Essential Plan | Medicaid, Child Health Plus, Essential Plan |
| Employer coverage | Fully insured plus self-funded administration | Large and small group |
| Provider network size | More than 10,000 providers (company) | Not stated |
| Ratings | J.D. Power and NCQA claims on its site, without years; none confirmed | None confirmed |
See New York for the marketplace and regulator, and Excellus BlueCross BlueShield for the merger partner.
Side by side
| CDPHP (Capital District Physicians' Health Plan) | MVP Health Care | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Regional and provider-owned plans | Regional and provider-owned plans |
| Member services | 888-258-0477 | 888-687-6277 |
| Website | cdphp.com | mvphealthcare.com |
| Headquarters | Latham, New York | — |
| Ownership | Nonprofit, physician-founded | Not-for-profit regional health plan |
| Where it sells | 29 New York counties, centered on the Capital Region | New York and Vermont |
| Plan types | Individual plans, Essential Plan, employer plans, self-funded administration, Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, Medicaid managed care, Child Health Plus | Individual and family plans, Essential Plan, employer plans, Medicare Advantage, dual-eligible special needs plans, Medicaid, Child Health Plus, dental and vision |
| Network types | HMO, PPO, EPO, POS | — |
| Members | — | Nearly 1 million combined with Independent Health if the affiliation is approved (MVP, 2026) |
| Revenue | — | About $7 billion combined with Independent Health (MVP, 2026) |
| Best suited to | Residents of the Albany-area Capital Region and surrounding New York counties who want a regional plan with its own in-house pharmacy and care management. | New York and Vermont residents and employers who want a regional not-for-profit plan with individual, Medicare and Medicaid options. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026