Compare

EyeMed Vision Care vs VSP Vision Care

EyeMed (EssilorLuxottica group) and VSP (doctor-founded, not-for-profit) both sell stand-alone vision benefits through employers and to individuals.

Verdict

Both companies sell vision benefits: a routine eye exam plus an allowance toward glasses or contact lenses, separate from medical and dental coverage. Both work mainly through employers and groups, both use networks, and neither profile quotes copays or allowances because those are set by the employer's plan.

They differ in ownership and in who stands behind the benefit. EyeMed is part of the EssilorLuxottica eyewear group and its plans are usually insured by Fidelity Security Life. VSP describes itself as a not-for-profit started by optometrists. The best way to decide is to check whether your eye doctor is in the network of the plan you can actually get, and what your own certificate says about frequency and allowances.

Choose EyeMed if

  • Your employer offers EyeMed; plan designs differ by employer, such as Eye360 or Sight and Sound.
  • You want a network that includes retail chains, independent optometrists and online providers. EyeMed calls its network Insight.
  • You may want laser vision correction or hearing discounts, which EyeMed notes are not insurance.
  • You are comfortable that the group owns retail eyewear brands; the profile reports commentary about that combined ownership and no regulatory action against EyeMed in its sources.

Choose VSP if

  • Your employer or group offers VSP, which the Government Accountability Office found was the largest group vision insurer in 28 states in 2024.
  • You want a network of independent doctors, with Visionworks and Eyemart Express stores also in network; VSP reports more than 42,000 doctors.
  • You want to view plan details in a member account, including a Vision Benefit Statement.
  • You are aware that individual VSP plans are sold separately, and this site could not confirm which are offered in your state.

Key differences

Topic EyeMed VSP
Headquarters Cincinnati, Ohio Rancho Cordova, California
Ownership Part of EssilorLuxottica Not-for-profit (self-described)
Founded Not stated 1955
Insurer Usually Fidelity Security Life Not stated
Network Insight network More than 42,000 doctors plus retail locations
Group plans Yes Yes
Individual plans Yes, via EyeMed Individual Listed; confirm on vsp.com
GAO 2024 finding Fidelity Security Life largest group vision insurer in 13 states VSP largest in 28 states
Out-of-network Claim form; reimbursement depends on plan Usually pays more; some plans have no benefit

Guardian and others also use the VSP network for some vision plans. See Vision insurance for how these plans work in general.

Side by side

EyeMed Vision Care VSP Vision Care
Type Dental and vision insurers Dental and vision insurers
Member services 866-939-3633 800-877-7195
Website eyemed.com vsp.com
Headquarters Cincinnati, Ohio Rancho Cordova, California
Founded — 1955
Ownership Part of the EssilorLuxottica eyewear group (managed vision care arm of Luxottica) Not-for-profit company (self-described)
Parent company EssilorLuxottica —
Where it sells Nationwide; individual and family vision plans and employer group plans Nationwide; GAO found VSP the largest group vision insurer in 28 states in 2024
Plan types Group vision benefits, individual and family vision plans Group vision benefits, vision plans for individuals and families
Network types Insight network of independent optometrists, retail chains and online providers Doctor network of more than 42,000 doctors, plus retail locations
Plans and products
  • Group vision benefits
  • Individual and family vision plans
  • Laser vision correction discounts
  • Hearing benefits
  • Group vision benefits
  • Individual vision plans
  • Eye exams
  • Eyeglass lenses and frames
  • Contact lenses
Brands and plan names
  • EyeMed Individual
  • Insight network
  • Eye360
  • Sight and Sound
  • First American Administrators
  • VSP Individual Vision Plans
  • Eyefinity
  • Visionworks
  • Eyemart Express
  • Marchon Eyewear

Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Latest news on both companies