Compare

Florida Blue vs Oscar Health

Florida Blue, the statewide Blue licensee, versus Oscar Health, an app-based marketplace specialist selling in about 20 states, for Florida ACA shoppers.

Verdict

Florida Blue and Oscar Health both sell ACA marketplace plans in Florida, but they are different kinds of company. Florida Blue is the Blue Cross and Blue Shield licensee for Florida, owned by the policyholder-owned mutual holding company GuideWell, and says it is the only insurer serving all 67 counties. Oscar is a publicly traded, technology-focused insurer that sells mainly on the marketplaces in about 20 states.

Florida Blue offers a wider product range, including employer plans and Medicare. Oscar concentrates on individual marketplace coverage and small-business arrangements. For a Florida shopper, the useful comparison is by county: which plans and networks each sells where you live, and whether your doctors are in network. Both profiles say their current ratings could not be confirmed, so check the agencies. Premiums are not compared here; HealthCare.gov shows the plan-year prices, and tax credits depend on income.

Choose Florida Blue if

  • You want an insurer with a statewide footprint, and a Blue network that works outside Florida.
  • You may need employer plans or Medicare (Medicare Advantage, Part D, Medigap, special needs plans) from the same company.
  • You prefer a policyholder-owned parent.
  • You want a choice of HMO, PPO, EPO or POS plans, including some smaller networks.

Choose Oscar Health if

  • You shop on the individual marketplace and want an app-based insurer with a care team assigned to members.
  • You want one of its condition-focused plans, built around conditions such as diabetes or asthma. Oscar's savings claims are company figures for a specific comparison, not general prices.
  • You are a small employer interested in an allowance arrangement that employees use toward individual coverage (an ICHRA).
  • You are comfortable that Oscar sells only in its states and counties, and that footprints change yearly.

Key differences

Topic Florida Blue Oscar Health
Ownership GuideWell, a not-for-profit, policyholder-owned mutual holding company Investor-owned (NYSE: OSCR)
Headquarters Jacksonville, Florida New York, New York
Founded 1944 (roots, per the company) 2012
Where it sells Florida, all 67 counties About 20 states for 2026; 21 states for 2027
Members About 6 million (2026) 2,691,885 effectuated members (September 30, 2026)
Marketplace Bronze, Silver, Gold on HealthCare.gov Bronze, Silver, Gold
Employer plans Small, mid-sized and large Small business and ICHRA offerings
Medicare Advantage, Part D, Medigap, special needs, veterans plans Advantage launched in 2020 per its site; availability to confirm
Network types HMO, PPO, EPO, POS Varies by state and plan, such as HMO or EPO
Rating Not confirmed Not confirmed

See Florida for the state's marketplace and other insurers.

Side by side

Florida Blue Oscar Health
Type Blue Cross Blue Shield companies National health insurers
Member services 800-352-2583 855-672-2755
New members and sales 855-897-4002 855-951-1159
Website floridablue.com hioscar.com
Shop or enroll consumer.websales.floridablue.com —
Headquarters Jacksonville, Florida New York, New York
Founded 1944 2012
Ownership Owned by GuideWell, a not-for-profit, policyholder-owned mutual holding company Investor-owned (NYSE: OSCR)
Parent company GuideWell —
Stock ticker — OSCR
Where it sells Florida (all 67 counties) ACA individual market in about 20 states for plan year 2026 and 21 states (713 counties) for 2027
Plan types ACA marketplace plans, employer plans, Medicare Advantage, Medigap, Part D, chronic special needs plans, veterans plans, dental, life and disability ACA marketplace plans (Bronze, Silver, Gold), condition-focused plans, small-business and ICHRA offerings, vision and dental
Network types HMO, PPO, EPO, POS —
ACA metal levels — Bronze, Silver, Gold
Members About 6 million (Florida Blue, 2026) 2,691,885 effectuated members (September 30, 2026)
Revenue — $11.7 billion (2025)
Best suited to Floridians in any county who want an insurer with a statewide footprint and individual, employer and Medicare lines. Marketplace shoppers in its states who want an app-based insurer with condition-focused plan options, and small employers using an individual-coverage arrangement.
Plans and products
  • Individual and family plans
  • Employer group plans
  • Medicare Advantage
  • Medicare Supplement
  • Part D
  • Dental
  • Life
  • Disability
  • ACA marketplace plans
  • HelloMeno
  • RetireEase
  • CHOICE Arrangement
  • Oscar Vision and Dental
Brands and plan names
  • Florida Blue
  • Florida Blue HMO
  • Florida Blue Medicare
  • Florida Combined Life
  • Oscar Insurance Company
  • Oscar Insurance Company of Texas
  • Oscar Health Plan of California

Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Latest news on both companies