Compare
Geisinger Health Plan vs Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield
Geisinger Health Plan, owned by a Pennsylvania health system, compared with Highmark, the regional Blue plan across four states, using their profiles.
Verdict
Both are nonprofit Pennsylvania insurers connected to health systems, which sets them apart from many insurers. Geisinger Health Plan belongs to the Geisinger system, now part of Risant Health. Highmark is part of Highmark Health, which also owns Allegheny Health Network in western Pennsylvania.
The differences are footprint and licensing. Highmark is an independent licensee of the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association in Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia and parts of New York, and members get Blue network access when traveling. Geisinger sells only in Pennsylvania and works best near its own facilities. The profiles do not rank them, and each plan has its own service area.
Choose Geisinger Health Plan if
- You live in or near Geisinger's care area in central and northeastern Pennsylvania and want a plan tied to its doctors and hospitals.
- You are eligible for Medicaid, CHIP or Medicare and want those lines from the same organization.
- You are comfortable that the network is strongest near Geisinger's facilities.
Choose Highmark if
- You live in a Highmark license area: Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia, or western and northeastern New York.
- You want a Blue plan with a large regional network, including the affiliated Allegheny Health Network in western Pennsylvania.
- You want a full range of lines, from employer plans to Medigap, Medicaid and dental, under one name.
- You understand that its individual plans exist only in its license areas, since other Blue companies hold parts of Pennsylvania.
Key differences
| Item | Geisinger Health Plan | Highmark |
|---|---|---|
| Headquarters | Danville, Pennsylvania | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania |
| Ownership | Nonprofit; Geisinger, owned by Risant Health | Nonprofit; part of Highmark Health |
| Where it sells | Pennsylvania | Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia, western and northeastern New York |
| Blue Cross Blue Shield licensee | Not stated | Independent licensee |
| Members | Over 550,000 (company statement) | Nearly 8 million across six states, including Blue KC (2026) |
| Network designs | HMO, PPO | HMO, PPO, EPO |
| Medicare lines | Medicare Advantage, dual special needs | Medicare Advantage, Medigap, dual special needs |
| Medicaid and CHIP | Yes | Yes |
| Self-funded administration | Not listed | Yes |
Where to check
Pennie, Pennsylvania's marketplace, and each insurer's provider search show which plans serve a county and which doctors are in network.
Side by side
| Geisinger Health Plan | Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Regional and provider-owned plans | Blue Cross Blue Shield companies |
| Member services | — | 800-241-5704 |
| Website | geisinger.org/health-plan | highmark.com |
| Headquarters | Danville, Pennsylvania | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania |
| Founded | — | 1996 |
| Ownership | Nonprofit, part of Geisinger, which is owned by Risant Health (created by Kaiser Permanente) | Nonprofit; part of Highmark Health, which also owns Allegheny Health Network |
| Parent company | Risant Health | Highmark Health |
| Where it sells | Pennsylvania | Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia, and western and northeastern New York; an affiliation with Blue KC (Missouri and Kansas) was approved in March 2026 |
| Plan types | ACA marketplace plans, employer group plans, Medicare Advantage, dual-eligible special needs plan, Medicaid (Medical Assistance), CHIP | ACA marketplace plans, employer plans, Medicare Advantage, Medigap, dual special needs plans, Medicaid managed care, CHIP, dental, vision |
| Network types | HMO, PPO | HMO, PPO, EPO |
| Members | Over 550,000 members across Pennsylvania (company statement) | Nearly 8 million across six states, including Blue KC (Highmark, 2026) |
| Revenue | — | $32.4 billion (Highmark Health, 2025) |
| Best suited to | Pennsylvanians who live in or near Geisinger's care area and want a plan tied to its doctors and hospitals, or who are eligible for Medicaid, CHIP or Medicare. | People and employers in Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia and parts of New York who want a Blue plan with a large regional network. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026