Compare
Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield vs UPMC Health Plan
Two Pittsburgh insurers tied to rival health systems: Highmark, a Blue licensee owned with Allegheny Health Network, and UPMC Health Plan, owned by UPMC.
Verdict
Highmark and UPMC Health Plan are both Pittsburgh-based, both are linked to a hospital system, and both sell marketplace, employer, Medicare and Medicaid coverage. Highmark is a Blue Cross Blue Shield licensee in Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia and parts of New York, and its parent also owns Allegheny Health Network. UPMC Health Plan is owned by the nonprofit UPMC health system and is strongest in western Pennsylvania.
Because each is tied to its own system, the network question matters most. A doctor or hospital that is in network for one plan may not be for the other, and may differ between plans from the same company. Check the directory for the exact plan before you enroll. Neither profile confirms a current AM Best, NCQA or CMS rating. Rate figures for 2027 are filed averages before subsidies, not prices.
Choose Highmark if
- You want a Blue plan with access to Blue Cross Blue Shield arrangements when traveling.
- You live in Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia, or western or northeastern New York, where it holds licenses.
- You want a plan connected to the affiliated Allegheny Health Network in western Pennsylvania.
- You want Medigap, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid (through Highmark Wholecare) and CHIP (Highmark Healthy Kids) from one company.
Choose UPMC Health Plan if
- You live in western Pennsylvania and use UPMC doctors and hospitals.
- You want a plan tied closely to UPMC's care system, which the profile says owns many of the doctors.
- You are looking for products such as UPMC for You (Medical Assistance), UPMC for Life (Medicare Advantage), UPMC for Kids or Community HealthChoices.
- You want consumer-directed plans paired with health savings or reimbursement accounts.
Key differences
| Topic | Highmark | UPMC Health Plan |
|---|---|---|
| Parent | Highmark Health (also owns Allegheny Health Network) | UPMC, a nonprofit health system |
| Headquarters | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania |
| Where it sells | Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia, parts of New York; affiliation with Blue KC approved March 2026 | Pennsylvania, largest in western Pennsylvania |
| Blue license | Yes | No |
| Members | Nearly 8 million across six states, including Blue KC (2026) | More than 4 million in UPMC's Insurance Services Division (2026) |
| Marketplace | Pennie, HealthCare.gov, New York State of Health | Pennie |
| Medicare | Medicare Advantage, dual special needs, Medigap | Medicare Advantage, special needs plans |
| Network types | HMO, PPO, EPO | HMO, PPO |
| Reported 2025 financials | Insurance division had a $609 million operating loss; Allegheny Health Network had $90 million in operating income | Not stated |
| Pennsylvania 2027 approved individual increases | 14.5% for Highmark Inc.; 19.7% for Highmark Benefits Group | 13.5% (healthinsurance.org) |
| Statewide weighted average | 15.97% (Pennsylvania Insurance Department) | About 16% (healthinsurance.org) |
See Pennsylvania for how the state marketplace works.
Side by side
| Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield | UPMC Health Plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Blue Cross Blue Shield companies | Regional and provider-owned plans |
| Member services | 800-241-5704 | — |
| Website | highmark.com | upmchealthplan.com |
| Headquarters | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania |
| Founded | 1996 | — |
| Ownership | Nonprofit; part of Highmark Health, which also owns Allegheny Health Network | Owned by UPMC, a nonprofit health system |
| Parent company | Highmark Health | UPMC |
| Where it sells | Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia, and western and northeastern New York; an affiliation with Blue KC (Missouri and Kansas) was approved in March 2026 | Pennsylvania (largest in western Pennsylvania) |
| Plan types | ACA marketplace plans, employer plans, Medicare Advantage, Medigap, dual special needs plans, Medicaid managed care, CHIP, dental, vision | ACA marketplace plans, employer plans, Medicare Advantage, special needs plans, Medicaid (Medical Assistance), CHIP, consumer-directed plans |
| Network types | HMO, PPO, EPO | HMO, PPO |
| HSA-eligible plans | — | Yes |
| Members | Nearly 8 million across six states, including Blue KC (Highmark, 2026) | More than 4 million members in UPMC's Insurance Services Division (UPMC, 2026; the division also runs products beyond the health plan) |
| Revenue | $32.4 billion (Highmark Health, 2025) | — |
| Best suited to | People and employers in Pennsylvania, Delaware, West Virginia and parts of New York who want a Blue plan with a large regional network. | People in western Pennsylvania who want a plan tied to UPMC's doctors and hospitals, or who are eligible for Medicare, Medicaid or CHIP. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026