Compare

Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey vs Oxford Health Plans (UnitedHealthcare)

New Jersey's Blue plan, Horizon, compared with UnitedHealthcare's Oxford brand for individual and employer shoppers, using both thin profiles.

Verdict

Both profiles are thinner than most, because each company's website could not be read during research. That limits what can be compared, and this page says only what both profiles support.

Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey is the Blue Cross and Blue Shield licensee for New Jersey and sells individual, employer and Medicare coverage, with Horizon NJ Health serving Medicaid members. Oxford Health Plans is a brand of UnitedHealthcare, best known in the New York, New Jersey and Connecticut area, with commercial plans in Connecticut and New Jersey and Oxford Metro marketplace plans in New Jersey. For a New Jersey shopper, Horizon has the wider set of product lines in the profiles, while Oxford offers the backing of a national insurer. Neither profile supports naming a winner.

Choose Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey if

  • You want a Blue plan that sells only in New Jersey and covers individuals, employers and Medicare beneficiaries.
  • You want Medicaid managed care, Medigap or Medicare Advantage options from the same company.
  • You value access to the Blue Cross Blue Shield system's provider arrangements outside New Jersey; the profile advises confirming this for your plan.
  • You are comfortable that plan details change yearly and that the profile says the company faces financial pressure and cut jobs in 2026.

Choose Oxford Health Plans if

  • Your employer or broker offers an Oxford plan, since the profile says availability depends on the employer and county.
  • You want a regional brand that has operated in the tri-state area since the 1980s and is part of UnitedHealthcare.
  • You are shopping for an Oxford Metro marketplace plan in New Jersey.
  • You are comfortable that the profile could not verify current plan details, networks or ratings.

Key differences

Item Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of NJ Oxford Health Plans
Parent Horizon Healthcare Services UnitedHealth Group (acquired 2004)
Headquarters Newark, New Jersey Trumbull, Connecticut
Where it sells New Jersey Connecticut and New Jersey
Blue Cross Blue Shield licensee Yes Not stated
Members About 3.8 million New Jersey residents, roughly 40% of the state (local news, February 2026) Not stated
Product lines ACA, employer, Medicare Advantage, Medigap, Medicaid, dental Employer plans; ACA marketplace plans (Oxford Metro, New Jersey)
Medicare and Medicaid Yes Not listed
Network designs Depend on plan (HMO or PPO) Not stated

Where to check

The New Jersey Department of Banking and Insurance and the state marketplace list who sells where. A plan's summary of benefits shows the network type.

Side by side

Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey Oxford Health Plans (UnitedHealthcare)
Type Blue Cross Blue Shield companies Regional and provider-owned plans
Website horizonblue.com oxfordhealth.com
Headquarters Newark, New Jersey Trumbull, Connecticut
Founded — 1984
Ownership — Investor-owned; subsidiary of UnitedHealth Group (acquired 2004)
Parent company Horizon Healthcare Services UnitedHealth Group
Where it sells New Jersey Connecticut and New Jersey
Plan types ACA marketplace plans, employer plans, Medicare Advantage, Medigap, Medicaid managed care, dental Commercial employer plans, ACA marketplace plans (Oxford Metro in New Jersey)
Members About 3.8 million New Jersey residents, roughly 40% of the state's population (as reported by local news, February 2026) —
Best suited to — Employers and individuals in the New York metropolitan area who are choosing among UnitedHealthcare's regional brands.
Plans and products
  • Individual and family plans
  • Employer group plans
  • Medicare Advantage
  • Medicare Supplement
  • Medicaid managed care
  • Dental
  • Commercial employer plans
  • ACA marketplace plans
Brands and plan names
  • Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey
  • Horizon NJ Health
  • Horizon Healthcare Services
  • Oxford Freedom
  • Oxford Liberty
  • Oxford Metro

Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Latest news on both companies