Guides
COBRA or a marketplace plan after a job loss: how to compare
COBRA keeps your old plan and deductible progress at full price; a marketplace plan may cost less after a tax credit but starts fresh. Compare on five points.
COBRA is usually the better fit when you want to keep your doctors, drugs and the deductible you have already paid down, and the marketplace is usually the better fit when cost is the main concern and your income qualifies you for a tax credit. Neither is cheaper for everyone. The honest comparison covers five things: the monthly price, the network, the deductible credit, subsidy eligibility and how the 60-day windows interact.
1. The monthly price
COBRA charges the whole premium, up to 102% of the plan's total cost, as explained in How COBRA works: eligibility, cost and how long it lasts. You pay the share your employer used to cover on top of your own.
A marketplace plan is priced by the insurer, then reduced by any premium tax credit you qualify for. The credit is based on your expected income for the whole year and the cost of a benchmark plan in your area. For plan year 2026, the original credit schedule applies, with a required contribution of 2.10% to 9.96% of income and no credit above 400% of the federal poverty level. For plan year 2027 the range is 2.15% to 10.22% of income (IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-25 and 2026-26). Because the credit depends on a whole year's income, someone who earned wages for part of the year and then lost the job often has a higher income than their current paycheck suggests. That can lower or remove the credit. The ACA subsidy estimator shows what your numbers could produce, and How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share explains the method.
2. The network and the drug list
COBRA gives you exactly the plan you had: the same network, the same formulary, the same prior authorizations in progress. If you are in the middle of treatment, pregnant, or seeing specialists you do not want to change, that continuity is real and worth money.
Marketplace plans come with new networks, and they vary by insurer, plan and county. Look up each doctor, hospital and drug before choosing, and call the provider's billing office to confirm they accept the specific plan, because online directories are not always current.
3. The deductible you already paid
Your deductible and out-of-pocket spending for the year carry over under COBRA, because it is the same plan. A new marketplace plan starts at zero. This difference grows the later in the plan year you lose your job, and it all but vanishes if you lose coverage in January.
Here is a labeled hypothetical. Say you leave on September 30, with $2,000 of a $3,000 deductible already met, and your COBRA premium is $714 a month. A marketplace plan after the credit costs $300 a month with a $4,000 deductible and 20% coinsurance. Assume both plans use 20% coinsurance after the deductible and that the plans' out-of-pocket limits are not reached.
| Item (October to December) | COBRA | Marketplace plan |
|---|---|---|
| Premiums, 3 months | $714 x 3 = $2,142 | $300 x 3 = $900 |
| If you have no care | $2,142 | $900 |
| If you have a $5,000 procedure: deductible left | $1,000 | $4,000 |
| Coinsurance on the rest of the bill | 20% x $4,000 = $800 | 20% x $1,000 = $200 |
| Total with the procedure | $2,142 + $1,000 + $800 = $3,942 | $900 + $4,000 + $200 = $5,100 |
With no care, the marketplace plan is $1,242 cheaper. With the $5,000 procedure, COBRA is $1,158 cheaper. The point is not that one wins; it is that the answer depends on how much care you expect. Use the COBRA cost and deadline calculator to test your own figures.
4. Tax credits and cost-sharing help
If you elect and stay in COBRA, you cannot get a premium tax credit for those months, because COBRA counts as job-based coverage you are enrolled in. Simply being eligible for COBRA does not stop you from getting a credit on a marketplace plan.
Lower-income households may also qualify for cost-sharing reduction plans, which are silver plans with smaller deductibles and copays, only on the marketplace. Credits paid in advance that exceed what you qualify for at tax time must be repaid in full starting with tax year 2026, so an honest income estimate matters.
5. How the windows interact
A job loss opens a 60-day special enrollment period to join a marketplace plan, and the window starts before the loss as well as after. COBRA gives you at least 60 days from the later of the notice or the loss to elect, then at least 45 days to make the first payment.
The timing can differ by days or weeks, so build the calendar from your own dates. Two notes:
- Electing COBRA first and then dropping it voluntarily generally does not open a new marketplace window. Marketplace rules may differ in your state exchange, so ask.
- Because COBRA is retroactive to the day coverage ended, some people let the election period run and elect only if they need care. It carries risk: a claim during the wait is uncovered if you do not elect and pay in time.
What a short COBRA bridge looks like
Some people use COBRA for a few months, for example until a new employer's waiting period ends or until a surgery is done, and then switch at open enrollment or when a new plan begins. A COBRA plan that is a high-deductible plan can still allow health savings account contributions, while bronze and catastrophic marketplace plans are treated as HSA-compatible beginning in 2026 under a 2025 law and IRS Notice 2026-5; confirm any specific plan with the insurer.
A decision checklist
- List your doctors, hospitals and prescriptions and check each against both options.
- Write down your deductible and out-of-pocket progress so far this year.
- Estimate the whole year's income, including severance and unemployment benefits.
- Get the COBRA premium in writing and a marketplace price after any credit.
- Put every deadline on one calendar, starting from the day coverage ends.
- Ask a marketplace navigator, a licensed broker or your benefits administrator about anything specific to your situation.
Key takeaways
- COBRA preserves your network and your deductible progress but charges the full premium plus up to 2%.
- A marketplace plan may cost much less after a tax credit, but its network and deductible start over.
- Your credit depends on the whole year's income, not just the months after the layoff.
- You cannot take a credit while enrolled in COBRA, though being eligible for COBRA does not block one.
- The right choice depends on how much care you expect, so run both options with your own numbers.