Blog
Medicare and Medicaid together: how a dual special needs plan works day to day
Three hypothetical households show who pays which bill in a dual special needs plan, how extras and care coordination work, and when to call the state.
A dual-eligible special needs plan, or D-SNP, is a Medicare Advantage plan built for people who have both Medicare and some form of Medicaid. What it does for you depends on how much Medicaid you have, and that is why two neighbors in the same plan can have very different months. The three households below are hypothetical, with round invented numbers, so you can see the pattern of who pays what rather than a price list.
The short version before the households
Medicare is the primary payer for Medicare-covered care. Medicaid (medicaid), run by your state, is the payer of last resort: it picks up some or all of what Medicare leaves behind, and it covers things Medicare does not, such as long-term custodial care. A D-SNP (see Dual-eligible special needs plan) is the private plan that sits on top of both. It must cover everything Original Medicare covers, it has a contract with your state Medicaid agency, and it is supposed to coordinate the two programs so you are not the one carrying paperwork between them.
How much Medicaid you have sets your category, and your category drives almost everything else:
| Category | What Medicaid typically does | What it means in a D-SNP |
|---|---|---|
| Full-benefit dual | Covers Medicaid services (such as long-term care at home or in a facility, in many states) and usually pays Medicare cost sharing | Most Medicare cost sharing is covered by Medicaid, so the plan charges little or nothing; Medicaid services may be coordinated or combined |
| Qualified Medicare Beneficiary (QMB) only | Pays the Medicare Part B premium and Medicare deductibles, copays and coinsurance, but not other Medicaid benefits | Providers may not bill you for Medicare cost sharing; the plan coordinates but you have no full Medicaid benefits |
| Other partial duals (SLMB, QI) | Pays the Part B premium only | Cost sharing is often not covered, so the plan's copays can apply to you |
The names and income limits come from the Medicare Savings Programs and from your state's Medicaid rules, and the limits are adjusted each year. The state Medicaid office, or a SHIP counselor, tells you which category you are in. Nobody else can reliably do it from a plan brochure.
Household one: Ruth, full dual
Say Ruth is 74, has Medicare and full Medicaid, and lives on a small Social Security check. Her state's Medicaid program pays her Part B premium and covers her Medicare deductibles and coinsurance. She joined a D-SNP last year.
Here is what a hospital stay looks like in this illustration. A standard Medicare Advantage plan might charge a hypothetical $300 per day for days 1 through 5. On that plan, five days would cost $300 x 5 = $1,500. In Ruth's D-SNP, the state Medicaid program is responsible for her Medicare cost sharing, so her share for those five days is $0. The money does not vanish: the plan or the state pays the facility. Ruth should simply never see a bill.
Her other monthly experience:
- Premium. The plan's own premium is often $0 for dual members, and Medicaid pays her Part B premium, so the Social Security check is not reduced for it. Whether the Part B premium shows up as a deduction depends on her category, which is exactly the sort of thing that goes wrong during an enrollment change.
- Drugs. People with full Medicaid are generally treated as qualifying for Extra Help, the federal program that lowers Part D premiums and copays. She pays a small, capped copay per prescription, set by Extra Help rules each year.
- Extras. Her plan includes an allowance each month for over-the-counter items and a ride benefit to appointments. These vary by plan and county, are written in the plan's Evidence of Coverage, and often expire if unused.
- Long-term care. If Ruth needed help at home, that would come through Medicaid, not through the Medicare side of the plan. In some states one plan runs both (see the integrated types below); in others, the Medicaid long-term services come from a separate Medicaid plan or the state itself.
Ruth's job is small: keep her Medicaid active. The plan is only a D-SNP for her as long as the state says she is a dual. A Medicaid renewal packet that goes unanswered can unwind her whole arrangement, so she opens the state's mail on the day it comes.
Household two: Walter, QMB only
Say Walter is 71, has Medicare, and qualifies for the Qualified Medicare Beneficiary program but not for full Medicaid. His income is above the limit for full benefits in his state but low enough for QMB. Medicaid pays his Part B premium and his Medicare cost sharing. It does not cover long-term care or other Medicaid-only services.
This household shows why the QMB protection matters. Federal law bars providers who accept Medicare from billing a QMB for Medicare deductibles, coinsurance or copays. The state Medicaid agency, not Walter, is responsible for those amounts, up to what Medicaid pays for the service. The provider can bill the state. The protection holds whether Walter is in Original Medicare or in a D-SNP.
An example with round numbers. Walter sees a specialist and the Medicare-approved amount is $200. Under Original Medicare, with the Part B deductible met, he would owe 20% coinsurance, or $200 x 0.20 = $40. As a QMB he owes $0. If a billing office sends him a statement for that $40, the statement is wrong on its face. He should not pay it. He should call the provider's billing office, tell them he has QMB, and ask them to bill Medicaid. If it keeps arriving, his plan's member services and the state Medicaid office can both help, and so can a SHIP counselor.
His D-SNP adds care coordination and extras. Walter chose it mostly because it also gives him a drug plan and a monthly allowance. But he should check two things before relying on it:
- Whether his doctors are in the plan's network. A D-SNP is a managed plan; many are HMOs or similar, so out-of-network care is limited to emergencies and urgent needs.
- Whether his state lets D-SNPs coordinate his Medicaid benefits at all. For a QMB-only member there may be little Medicaid to coordinate, so the plan's value is mainly the Medicare benefits it adds.
Households like Walter's are also where the other partial categories show up. Someone who qualifies only for SLMB or QI gets the Part B premium paid and is not protected from billing for cost sharing. Her plan's copays apply as written. If you are not sure which of these categories you are in, find out before you compare plans, because the answer changes what is worth paying attention to.
Household three: Priya, just qualified
Say Priya, 68, has been in a regular Medicare Advantage plan for two years. In October her income dropped when she stopped work, she applied to the state's Medicaid program, and in November she was approved for full Medicaid. She now has a dual status she did not have when she picked her plan.
Three things happen next, and she should not leave them to chance:
- Her current plan has to be told, and she may have new choices. People who gain Medicaid or Extra Help have special enrollment opportunities that other people do not. The rules about when and how often dual and low-income members can change plans have been adjusted in recent years, in part to steer people toward plans that integrate Medicare and Medicaid, so ask a SHIP counselor or 1-800-MEDICARE what applies this month. Do not rely on a plan salesperson alone, since the plan with the strongest sales pitch is not always the one that suits your situation.
- Her Medicaid start date matters. Her new status takes effect on a date the state sets. Medicaid can sometimes cover bills from before approval, depending on state rules; some Medicare Savings Program coverage starts the month after approval. Priya should ask the state office for her exact effective dates in writing, and ask whether any recent bills may be covered back to an earlier date.
- Her plan's cost sharing changes. In her old plan she had a $40 specialist copay. Now that her Medicaid pays her cost sharing, her providers should bill the state for it. If her plan has not updated her record, she may still be charged. She asks member services to confirm her dual status is on file and to describe what she should owe for common services.
Priya also has a decision. Her old plan may not be a D-SNP at all, so the extras she now qualifies for may not apply. She can compare her current plan, a D-SNP in her county, and Original Medicare with a separate drug plan. That decision is covered in more detail in As a dual eligible, should I pick Original Medicare or a D-SNP?, and the drug side of the picture is in Medicare and Medicaid both: who pays for my prescriptions?.
How care coordination works
Federal rules require every D-SNP to run a model of care, which is a written description of how the plan coordinates services for its members. What members actually notice:
- A health risk assessment when they join and at least once a year afterward: a questionnaire, often by phone, about health conditions, medicines, mobility and home situation.
- An individualized care plan built from that assessment, which the member can ask to see and discuss.
- A named care coordinator or care team, who is the first call when something goes wrong: a denied ride, a prescription that is not on the plan's list, a referral that has not come through.
- Transitions support. If you are in the hospital, the plan is expected to be in touch about discharge, follow-up visits and any services you will need at home.
Integrated plans go further. Some D-SNPs are what the rules call highly integrated or fully integrated: the same company, or an affiliated one, covers the Medicare benefits and some or all of the Medicaid benefits, and there is a single appeals process and a single member card in the best versions. Coordination-only plans do not cover Medicaid benefits; they share information with the state and coordinate but your Medicaid benefits come from the state or another plan. Which type you have is in the plan's description. It matters a great deal for long-term care at home, because that is where the gap between two separate systems usually causes trouble.
When a bill arrives that should not have
If you are a QMB or a full dual whose Medicaid covers Medicare cost sharing and a provider bills you, work through this order:
- Do not pay it yet, and do not ignore it. Write the date you received the bill on it.
- Call the provider's billing office and say, "I have Medicare and Medicaid with the QMB program (or full Medicaid). Please bill Medicaid and send me a corrected statement." Ask them to note your account.
- Check the plan's explanation of benefits for the claim. It states what the plan paid and what, if anything, it says you owe.
- Call your plan's member services, ask for your care coordinator if the plan assigns one, and request that your dual status be confirmed on the claim.
- Call the state Medicaid office if the provider still insists. The state is the payer in those cases and can say what it covers and whether the provider is enrolled with Medicaid.
- Call a SHIP counselor if you are stuck. For problems with a plan itself, the plan's grievance or appeal process applies, and the Medicare complaint line, 1-800-MEDICARE, takes complaints about billing a protected person.
Keep every statement, the date and time of each call and the name of the person you spoke to.
When to check with the state Medicaid office
Several things belong to the state, not to the plan, so a plan representative cannot settle them:
- Your category. Whether you are full Medicaid, QMB, SLMB or QI, and when it started.
- Renewal. The renewal date, the documents the state wants, and whether you must respond by a deadline. If you lose Medicaid, your plan may give you a grace period to regain it before moving you out of the D-SNP, but the length is set by Medicare rules and the plan's notice, so read the notice.
- Which services Medicaid covers for you, especially long-term care at home or in a facility, and how to apply for them.
- Which plans your state lets you pick, since some states require dual members to join a particular type of managed plan for Medicaid services.
- Estate recovery and asset questions, which are Medicaid rules and not part of the Medicare plan at all; see Paying for long-term care with Medicaid: income and asset rules.
Keep the state's phone number and your case number in the same place as your plan card. A SHIP counselor can help you find the right office and can tell you which questions go where.
Key takeaways
- A D-SNP covers what Original Medicare covers, plus coordination with Medicaid; how much of your cost sharing Medicaid covers depends on your category, not on the plan.
- QMB members, and full duals whose Medicaid covers Medicare cost sharing, should not be billed for it by Medicare providers; a statement for a copay is a reason to call, not to pay.
- The plan's extras and its coordinator help with the day-to-day; only the state decides your Medicaid status, start date and renewal.
- People who newly qualify for Medicaid or Extra Help should ask a SHIP counselor or 1-800-MEDICARE about the special enrollment options available to them right now, since the rules have been changing.
- Keep your Medicaid renewal on time: losing it can change what the plan owes you.