Blog
A year-by-year income plan for a 60-year-old retiree on a marketplace plan
A five-year timeline for a hypothetical early retiree shows how withdrawals, conversions, gains and Social Security timing move income against the credit.
A person who retires at 60 and buys a marketplace plan has something most working people do not: control over the income number that decides the premium tax credit. Wages are fixed by an employer. Retirement income is partly a choice, because money can come from a bank account, a Roth account, a traditional IRA, the sale of investments or Social Security, and those sources count very differently.
This post lays out a five-year timeline for a hypothetical retiree, from age 60 to 64, showing the levers each year and what each moves. It is a map of cause and effect, not a recommendation about what anyone should do. The credit is one input among taxes, investment returns, Social Security benefits and Medicare costs, and a tax professional who can see the whole picture is the right person for a real plan. All numbers are round and invented.
What counts as income for the credit
The credit uses modified adjusted gross income, or MAGI (modified adjusted gross income): your adjusted gross income plus tax-exempt interest and the nontaxable part of Social Security, plus a few other items. The practical result is that some sources raise countable income dollar for dollar and others do not touch it.
| Source | Effect on countable income |
|---|---|
| Cash from a savings account (the principal) | None. The interest counts. |
| Selling investments in a taxable account | Only the gain counts, not the part that returns what you paid. Dividends and interest count. |
| Withdrawals from a traditional IRA or 401(k) | The full amount counts. |
| Withdrawals of contributions from a Roth IRA | None. |
| Qualified Roth withdrawals of earnings, after age 59 and a half and the five-year rule | None. |
| Converting traditional money to Roth | The converted amount counts in the year of the conversion. |
| Qualified withdrawals from a health savings account | None. |
| Social Security benefits | All of it counts, taxable or not. |
| Part-time wages, pension, tax-exempt bond interest | Counted. |
Rules on Roth accounts, conversions and penalties have details and exceptions, so verify yours. At 60, our retiree is past age 59 and a half, which removes the extra 10% tax on most early IRA withdrawals. A retiree who stops work earlier faces a different set of rules.
The hypothetical retiree and the yardsticks
Pat is single, turns 60, and stops working on January 1. Pat has savings in cash, a taxable investment account, a traditional IRA, a Roth IRA and no retiree health plan, so Pat will buy marketplace coverage until Medicare at 65. That gives five marketplace years, at ages 60 through 64. See Health insurance for early retirees before Medicare at 65 for the bridging options.
The assumptions, all invented:
- The benchmark premium for Pat's age is $1,000 a month, $12,000 a year, in every year.
- To keep the arithmetic exact, the expected contribution is a flat 8% of countable income. The real schedule rises through each band, ranging from 2.15% to 10.22% for plan year 2027, so a real credit falls faster as income climbs. The flat 8% is a simplification.
- The upper line for a single person is $63,840 for 2027 coverage, which is 400% of the 2026 poverty guideline of $15,960. Above it, there is no credit as of November 2026, because the enhanced credits expired after 2025. The line changes yearly, so a plan for later years should use the line for that year, not this one.
- The lower line: in a state that expanded Medicaid, an adult with income below 138% of poverty, about $22,000 for one person, generally qualifies for Medicaid and not for credits. In a state that did not, income below 100% of poverty leaves a gap. Pat's lowest-income year in this example is above these lines.
The plan, year by year
| Year, age | Moves | Countable income | Credit at 8% of income |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1, 60 | $25,000 IRA withdrawal, $5,000 interest and dividends, the rest of spending from cash | $30,000 | $9,600 |
| Year 2, 61 | Same, plus a $20,000 Roth conversion | $50,000 | $8,000 |
| Year 3, 62 | Same as year 1, plus $30,000 of investment gains | $60,000 | $7,200 |
| Year 4, 63 | Same as year 1, Social Security not yet claimed | $30,000 | $9,600 |
| Year 5, 64 | Same as year 1 | $30,000 | $9,600 |
The credit in each year is $12,000 minus 8% of the countable income. Check year 1: 8% × $30,000 = $2,400, and $12,000 minus $2,400 = $9,600. Year 2: 8% × $50,000 = $4,000, and $12,000 minus $4,000 = $8,000. Year 3: 8% × $60,000 = $4,800, and $12,000 minus $4,800 = $7,200. Over the five years the credits add up to $44,000.
Year 1, age 60: a low base
Pat spends $48,000 in the first year. Of that, $25,000 comes from the traditional IRA and $5,000 arrives as interest and dividends, which are income, and the remaining $18,000 is drawn from cash and returns of what Pat paid for investments, which are not. Countable income is $30,000, or about 188% of the poverty level. The credit covers $9,600 of the $12,000 benchmark premium, so Pat's own share is $2,400.
Choosing where the $48,000 comes from is the main lever of every year. Taking more from savings and basis lowers income and raises the credit. Taking more from the IRA does the opposite. Neither is free: money left in a traditional IRA grows and eventually comes out as taxable income, which is a reason some people use low-income years to move it earlier.
Year 2, age 61: a Roth conversion
Say Pat converts $20,000 from the traditional IRA to the Roth IRA. The conversion is taxable income in the year it happens, so countable income rises from $30,000 to $50,000. The credit falls from $9,600 to $8,000. The cost of the conversion in lost credit is $1,600, which is 8% of $20,000, and with a real schedule the figure could be larger. On top of that, Pat pays income tax on the conversion.
The case for converting: the converted money and its future growth can come out of the Roth tax-free later, which can lower future taxes, and it does not count toward income when withdrawn. The case against: the lost credit and the tax bill arrive now, and Pat might not need the later benefit. Does putting money in an HSA raise my marketplace subsidy? shows how a different kind of contribution moves countable income.
Year 3, age 62: a gain near the line
Pat sells investments and realizes $30,000 of gain, which is taxed as income and counts for the credit. Countable income is $60,000, and the credit is $7,200. That is still below the $63,840 line.
Now suppose the gain had been $40,000. Countable income would have been $70,000, above the line. The credit becomes zero, which is $7,200 lower on $10,000 more income. And if Pat had been getting advance credits all year on a lower estimate, the whole amount paid would have to be repaid. As of November 2026, the cap on repayment is gone for tax years starting with 2026, so the repayment is in full. i sold stock or a house: how does the gain affect my marketplace credit? covers how a sale of stock or a home flows into the credit, and I'm just over the 400% poverty line: can I lower my income to get credits? covers what legitimate adjustments exist for a household near the line.
A retiree who sees the line approaching can often spread gains over two years, sell the shares that cost the most first, or harvest losses. Each has tax consequences, so ask a professional.
Year 4, age 63: the Social Security question
Pat can claim Social Security as early as 62, or wait. For the credit, all of the benefit counts, so claiming adds to countable income. Say Pat could claim a $24,000 annual benefit at 63 and would reduce the IRA withdrawal from $25,000 to $10,000 to compensate:
- Claim at 63: $24,000 + $10,000 + $5,000 interest and dividends = $39,000. Credit: $12,000 minus 8% × $39,000 ($3,120) = $8,880.
- Wait: $25,000 + $5,000 = $30,000. Credit $9,600.
The difference is $720, which is 8% of $9,000 of additional income. A credit difference this small is no reason to claim or to wait, since the choice changes a benefit for life and depends on health, other income, a spouse's benefit and more. Pat's timeline above uses the "wait" case.
A bigger consideration: Medicare's income-related premium surcharge, known as IRMAA, looks back two tax years (IRMAA). The return Pat files for the year of age 63 sets the surcharge, if any, for the first year of Medicare at 65. And the return for age 64 sets it for the second year. So income at 63 and 64 matters beyond the credit. IRMAA explained: the income-related Medicare premium surcharge explains how the brackets work.
Year 5, age 64: the last marketplace year
This is the final year of marketplace coverage. Pat's plan keeps income at $30,000 and the credit at $9,600. The remaining task is the handoff to Medicare: sign up in the seven-month Initial Enrollment Period around the 65th birthday, and end the marketplace plan when Medicare coverage begins, because credit is generally not allowed for months of Medicare Part A. Medicare Initial Enrollment Period: your seven-month window gives the dates.
Two ways to read the same five years
The timeline above holds income low in years 1, 4 and 5 and lets it rise in years 2 and 3. Different people read that pattern differently, and both readings have a case.
The case for keeping income low every year. Each dollar of countable income costs credit, and with the cap on repayment gone, a miss costs more than it used to. A retiree who spends from cash and basis gets the largest credit, avoids tax on withdrawals now, and keeps the Medicare surcharge brackets out of reach later. Supporters of this approach point out that the credit is worth thousands of dollars a year at this age, when the benchmark premium is high.
The case for using the low-income years. A traditional IRA is a deferred tax bill. The years between retirement and the start of Social Security and required withdrawals are often the lowest-income years of a person's life, so some planners prefer to move money into a Roth account or realize gains then, at lower rates, accepting a smaller credit. Critics of heavy conversions point to the lost credit, the extra tax today and the chance that the money is never needed.
Which weighs more depends on the size of the accounts, the rates in each year, how long Pat expects to live and what Congress does with the credit and the tax code, none of which a worksheet can settle. A reasonable use of the timeline is to see what each choice costs in credit, so the cost is known before the choice is made.
What can go wrong in a plan like this
- A bad estimate. The marketplace pays credit in advance based on the income Pat reports. An unplanned sale, a larger IRA withdrawal for a roof or a car, or a conversion in December can leave Pat above the estimate. Updating the marketplace during the year (I got a raise or lost a job mid-year: when do I update my marketplace income?) keeps the advance payments close.
- No margin. With the repayment cap gone for tax year 2026 and later, an income that crosses the line costs the whole credit. Planners often leave a margin below the line, and the right size is a judgment.
- Assuming the rules stay the same. As of November 2026, no law has restored the enhanced credits for 2027. Check the current law each year instead of building a plan on an assumption.
- Ignoring the taxes. A credit is one number. The tax cost of a conversion or a gain is often as large or larger.
- Forgetting state rules. Some states have their own premium help and Medicaid rules, which change the lower line.
How to build your own timeline
- List every source of income you could draw on and whether it counts, using the table above.
- Estimate your spending for each year until Medicare.
- Write the line for each year: 400% of the poverty level, and for Medicaid states about 138%.
- For each year, choose a mix of sources, then compute countable income and the credit with the ACA subsidy estimator.
- Add taxes, IRMAA at ages 63 and 64, and your benefit timing.
- Have a tax professional check the plan, and review it every November when the new year's numbers are out.
Key takeaways
- Countable income, not your total spending, sets the credit, and sources count differently: Roth withdrawals, savings principal and investment basis do not count; traditional withdrawals, conversions, gains and all Social Security do.
- Each added $1,000 of countable income costs about the applicable percentage of it in credit, and crossing 400% of poverty costs the whole credit.
- A year of low income can be followed by a year of conversions or gains, but each year's line, percentages and tax rules change, so plan one year at a time.
- Income at ages 63 and 64 sets the Medicare surcharge two years later, so look beyond the credit.
- Update the marketplace when income changes, end the plan when Medicare starts, and take the plan to a tax professional before acting.