Blog
How do I tell if my employer plan provides minimum value?
Minimum value is a floor on what an employer plan pays, apart from affordability: how the 60% test works, where to find the answer, what it means for credits.
Imagine a warehouse worker handed a benefits packet with a plan that costs $60 a month. The premium looks like a bargain. The deductible is $9,000, hospital stays are not covered until that deductible is met, and the plan pays a flat $100 for each doctor visit. The worker wonders whether this thing counts as real health insurance for purposes of the marketplace, because a neighbor said that if an employer "offers coverage" you cannot get a premium tax credit. The neighbor is right only in part. An offer blocks the credit only when the plan is both affordable and meets minimum value. A plan can be offered and still fail the second test.
This explainer covers the second test: what minimum value measures, how a plan is checked against it, why bare-bones plans often fail it, where the answer is written down, and what the answer changes for your marketplace options. The numbers in the examples are invented.
Minimum value in one paragraph
An employer plan provides minimum value if it covers at least 60% of the total allowed cost of covered benefits for a standard population, and it provides substantial coverage of inpatient hospital stays and physician services. That is the federal definition in plain English. Notice the unit of measurement: it is not what you personally pay, it is the share the plan pays across an average group of people under a standard set of assumptions. A plan can meet the 60% standard and still leave a particular person with a large bill.
Minimum value is the employer-plan counterpart of the "bronze" level of marketplace plans, which are designed to pay about 60% on average. Plans that sit near that line are not necessarily bad, and plans that sit below it are not necessarily scams, but the label has legal consequences. See minimum value for the formal definition and bronze, silver, gold and platinum plans: what the metal levels mean for the metal levels.
Minimum value is not the same as affordability
These two tests are applied together and then confused. Each answers a different question.
| Test | Question | What is measured |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum value | Does the plan pay enough of covered costs? | Average share the plan pays, plus hospital and physician coverage |
| Affordability | Is the price within reach for you? | Your share of the cheapest self-only plan that has minimum value, compared with a percentage of household income |
For plan years beginning in 2026 the affordability percentage is 9.96%, and for plan years beginning in 2027 it is 10.22%, as the IRS set in its yearly guidance (the facts sheet records both). For the marketplace credit, the offer of employer coverage blocks the credit only if both tests pass. A plan that is cheap but thin fails minimum value. A plan that is rich but priced beyond the percentage fails affordability. Either way, the offer does not stand in the way of a credit. Is your employer coverage affordable? The affordability test explained covers the affordability side in detail, and My employer's coverage costs too much, can I get marketplace credits? works through scenarios.
Why a plan can be offered and still fail
Insurers and employers are free to sell and buy plans that cover less than the standard. A plan can fail minimum value for several reasons.
Very high deductibles with thin coverage
Say an employer plan pays nothing toward most services until a $9,000 deductible is met, and then pays 70% until an out-of-pocket maximum. The average payment across a typical population may fall below 60% because most people do not reach the deductible in a typical year. It is the average that counts, which is why a plan with a lower deductible but low reimbursement for hospitals can also fail.
Fixed-dollar benefits
Some products pay a fixed amount per day in the hospital or per doctor visit, no matter what the bill is. They are sold as an add-on or as the main plan. A fixed indemnity plan that pays a flat $100 per office visit does not track the actual cost of care, so it generally does not meet minimum value, and many are not even minimum essential coverage. A similar story applies to "limited benefit" plans that cover only certain services, to some discount cards (which are not insurance at all) and to some short-term plans (see short-term health insurance: what it covers and what it does not).
Missing hospital or physician coverage
A plan that leaves out inpatient hospital care or physician services does not provide substantial coverage of them, so it fails even if the dollar percentage looks high on other services. Some "mini-med" style plans work this way.
Offered, but only as a supplement
Plans that are labeled "supplemental" or "voluntary benefit" are designed to sit next to another plan, not to replace one. If a supplement is the only thing your employer offers, it does not give you minimum value, and you may be uninsured in a legal sense even though you paid premiums out of your check.
How a plan is actually tested
Two paths exist for plan sponsors. The first is a calculator published by the federal government, in which the plan's deductible, coinsurance, copays and out-of-pocket limit are entered. The calculator runs them against a standard population of claims and returns a percentage. The second is a design-based safe harbor, a checklist of plan designs that are treated as meeting minimum value without further computation, and a third option is to have an actuary certify the plan.
A tiny illustration shows the idea. Say the standard population's total covered costs are $10,000 per person (an invented round number) and the plan, after deductibles, coinsurance and copays, pays $5,400 of it on average. 5,400 divided by 10,000 is 54%, below the 60% line, so the plan fails. If the average payment were $6,200, that would be 62% and the plan would pass. The real test uses the government's modeled claims, so a person cannot reproduce it with a pocket calculator. The employer or insurer is the one who runs it.
Where to find the answer
You do not have to guess. The answer is written in a few places.
- The Summary of Benefits and Coverage. Every group plan must give you one, and the last page asks whether the plan meets minimum value standards, along with whether it provides minimum essential coverage. See summary of benefits and coverage. Ask HR for the document if you have not received it.
- The Form 1095-C your employer files. The code on the offer line indicates whether the employer says it offered coverage that provides minimum value. Code 1H, for example, covers cases with no offer or an offer that did not meet the standard. I got a Form 1095-C from my employer, so what do the codes mean? reads the form.
- Your benefits administrator or HR. Ask in writing: "Does the plan I am offered provide minimum value under the ACA?" A written answer is the most useful thing to have at tax time.
- The marketplace application. The HealthCare.gov application asks whether you are offered employer coverage, and some state marketplaces ask for details about the plan. Your employer can fill out a worksheet for you so that the marketplace has the correct answer.
- The plan document. The summary plan description lists benefits, though it does not usually say "minimum value" outright.
If the answers conflict, believe the written statement from the plan administrator and keep it. A navigator can help you decide what to do next, and the employer coverage affordability test covers the other half of the question.
What the result changes for you
If the plan provides minimum value and is affordable
An offer of that plan blocks the premium tax credit for you for the months it was available to you, even if you decline it. You can still buy a marketplace plan at full price, with no credit, but a credit paid in advance for those months would have to be repaid in full when you reconcile at tax time. Because the cap on repayment of excess advance credits was eliminated for tax years after 2025, the amount at stake can be the whole credit (the facts sheet cites Public Law 119-21, section 71305).
If the plan fails minimum value
The offer does not block the credit. You may be able to buy a marketplace plan with a credit based on your household income, if your income falls within the credit range, and if the thin plan is not even minimum essential coverage you can keep it alongside. If it is minimum essential coverage and you are enrolled in it, that enrollment can itself block the credit, so ask a navigator or tax professional before holding both. The credit for 2027 follows the original schedule, with contribution percentages from 2.15% to 10.22% of income, and no credit above 400% of the federal poverty level, as of November 2026. See How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share for how it is calculated.
If you do not know yet
Do not enroll in a marketplace plan and take advance credits while the answer is unknown. Get the written answer first, because advance credits based on a wrong "no offer" answer are the ones that get repaid.
Timing
Open enrollment is the main way to switch, so for plan year 2027 on HealthCare.gov the window is November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027. Outside that window you generally need a special enrollment event. Not having a minimum-value plan is not by itself one of those events, so ask a navigator whether any other event applies to you.
What it means for your employer
Employers with 50 or more full-time-equivalent employees can owe a penalty if they do not offer minimum value coverage to enough of their full-time workers and a worker then receives a premium tax credit. For calendar year 2026 the two amounts are $3,340 and $5,010, and for calendar year 2027 they are $3,780 and $5,670 (IRS Revenue Procedures 2025-26 and 2026-22). That is why many employers run the test and say so on the Summary of Benefits and Coverage. For the mandate, see employer shared responsibility. Smaller employers are not subject to it, but their plan can still affect the employee's credit.
Marketplace notices to employers are a point to know about: when an employee gets a premium tax credit, the marketplace may notify the employer. That notice does not mean the employee did anything wrong. It is part of how the employer requirement is enforced.
Questions to put to HR
- Does the plan I am offered provide minimum value? Please confirm in writing.
- Is it minimum essential coverage?
- What is my share of the monthly premium for the cheapest plan you offer that provides minimum value, employee only?
- Is any of the coverage a fixed-indemnity or limited-benefit product, or does any of it sit on top of a main plan?
- Which tool or calculator was used to determine minimum value?
If the answers are unclear, the plan's insurer or administrator can answer for the plan. A plan that is a self-funded arrangement has an administrator, not an insurer, and the employer is the one to ask.
Key takeaways
- Minimum value is a federal floor: the plan must pay about 60% of covered costs for a standard population and cover hospital and physician services in a substantial way.
- An employer offer blocks the premium tax credit only if the plan is both affordable and provides minimum value; failing either one leaves the credit open.
- Fixed-indemnity, limited-benefit and supplemental products usually do not provide minimum value, and some are not minimum essential coverage.
- The Summary of Benefits and Coverage and HR's written answer are the places to look, and an advance credit taken on a wrong answer can have to be repaid in full.
- A navigator or tax professional can apply the answer to your situation, including the timing of enrollment.