Blog
My employer's wellness program offers a premium discount, what are my rights?
Twelve questions on how federal rules treat employer wellness programs: participatory vs. health-contingent, reasonable alternatives, privacy and complaints.
Your employer says that if you complete a health screening, log your steps or hit a cholesterol target, your premium drops. Maybe the flyer says "save up to $600 a year." The rules behind that sentence are more detailed than the flyer suggests, and they give you rights you may not know about: a right to a different way of earning the discount if the first way is not realistic for you, limits on how big the incentive can be, and protections for the health information you hand over. These questions walk through the federal framework in plain terms. Programs vary, and the program's own paperwork controls your case.
The basics
What kinds of wellness programs are there?
Federal rules sort employer programs offered through a group health plan into two broad groups.
Participatory programs do not depend on any health result. You earn the reward by taking part: attending a seminar, completing a health questionnaire, joining a gym, or having a screening, regardless of the numbers it produces. A premium discount for filling in a health risk assessment is an example, as long as the reward does not depend on what the answers say.
Health-contingent programs make the reward depend on meeting a health-related standard. They come in two types:
- Activity-only programs ask you to do something health-related, such as walk a certain number of steps or follow a diet plan, without requiring a particular result.
- Outcome-based programs ask you to reach a result, such as a blood pressure reading under a target, a cholesterol number or a non-tobacco status.
The group matters because the legal protections increase as you move from participatory to health-contingent. The strictest rules apply where the reward depends on a health outcome.
Can my employer require me to do a screening or a health questionnaire?
An employer can ask, and it can attach a reward to the answer. What it generally cannot do is make you pay a penalty beyond the limits in the rules, or deny you coverage for refusing. A group health plan cannot deny you eligibility or charge you different premiums based on your health status, with an exception that permits wellness-program rewards within the rules. Many programs are voluntary in the sense that you can decline and pay the standard premium.
Be careful with the word "voluntary." A $50 monthly difference may feel optional to one household and compulsory to another. The legal limits on the size of incentives (next question) exist for that reason. Separate rules under disability and genetic-information laws also restrict when an employer may ask medical questions, and those rules are enforced by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). The incentive limits under those laws have changed over the years, so if the question is about a questionnaire or a blood draw at work rather than the premium, the EEOC or an employment lawyer is the right person to ask.
The size of the incentive
How big can the incentive be?
For health-contingent programs, the federal rules from the 2013 regulations under HIPAA, as amended by the Affordable Care Act, cap the total reward at 30% of the cost of coverage. The cost of coverage means the total premium, the employer's share and the employee's share together, for the tier of coverage you are in. For programs aimed at preventing or reducing tobacco use, the cap rises to 50%.
An illustration with invented numbers shows how that works. Say the total annual cost of employee-only coverage is $8,000. Thirty percent of $8,000 is $2,400, so a health-contingent program could offer up to $2,400 a year in total rewards in that tier. If the program is an anti-tobacco program, the cap is 50%, or $4,000. A discount of $50 a month is $600 a year, well within either limit.
The cap does not apply in the same way to participatory programs, because their reward does not depend on a health factor. Rewards may take the form of a premium discount, a surcharge you avoid, a gift card or a contribution to a health savings account. How the reward is paid can have tax consequences, so ask the benefits office whether it is taxable.
Your rights if you cannot meet the standard
What is a reasonable alternative standard?
For a health-contingent program, the plan must give you another way to earn the reward if it is unreasonably difficult for you to meet the standard because of a medical condition, or medically inadvisable for you to try. This is the reasonable alternative standard. It is the part of the rules that matters most to the person who cannot hit the target.
In an activity-only program, the alternative applies if the activity is unreasonably difficult or medically inadvisable. The plan may ask for a note from your physician confirming that. In an outcome-based program, anyone who does not meet the target must be offered a reasonable alternative, such as a walking program or a class, and may get the reward for completing it. The plan has to tell you about the alternative, and the materials that describe the program should say it is available.
Here is how that might play out with invented details. Say a program gives a $300 discount if your blood pressure is under a set target, and your reading is above it. The plan must offer another way to earn the $300, perhaps attending a class or following your doctor's plan, and plans differ in what proof they may ask for, so ask what the plan requires before you assume a doctor's note is needed. If you complete the alternative, you are generally entitled to the reward.
What if I have a medical condition or disability that makes the activity hard?
That is the situation the alternative standard was written for. Ask in writing for the alternative and say why the standard is difficult. Keep a copy. For an activity-only program, the plan may ask for a physician's statement. For a disability, the Americans with Disabilities Act may separately require reasonable accommodations in how the program is run. If the request is refused, keep the refusal and see the complaint question below.
Do I have to share my doctor's records to qualify?
Not generally for a participatory program. For a health-contingent program, you may be asked to provide proof of a result, such as a screening result or a physician's note. Share what is needed and ask what happens to it. Ask whether the plan, the employer or a vendor holds the paperwork, because that matters for privacy, the subject of the next section.
Privacy and what your employer sees
What data does my employer actually see?
It depends on how the program is run. Many employers use an outside vendor to run screenings and apps. A well-structured program sends the employer only summary data, such as participation numbers or totals with no names. The vendor, not the employer, usually holds your individual results. But not every program is structured that way, and some employers see who completed what.
Ask three questions of the program's materials: Who collects my data? What will the employer receive? Who else will see it? The program's privacy notice should answer them. If it does not, ask HR in writing.
Is my health information protected by privacy law?
Partly. The federal health privacy rules under HIPAA apply to group health plans and to the vendors that handle plan information for them. If the wellness program is part of the group health plan, the information it collects is generally protected health information, and the plan cannot share it with your employer's decision makers in the employer's role as employer. If the program is run by the employer outside the group health plan, HIPAA may not cover it, though other laws may. The disability and genetic-information laws restrict how the employer may use and keep some medical information.
The gaps are in the details. An app that tracks steps and sleep may collect data covered by its own privacy policy, which may allow uses you would not expect. Read the policy before you agree, and ask what is shared with advertisers or third parties. If you are not comfortable, ask for the non-electronic route or the alternative.
Can my employer use my results against me at work?
Federal laws protect against discrimination based on disability and genetic information, and HIPAA's nondiscrimination rules bar the group health plan from using your health information to deny coverage or set your premium outside the permitted wellness rewards. Whether a specific use of your data is lawful depends on the facts. An employment lawyer or your state's labor agency can look at the details, and the EEOC takes complaints under the disability and genetic-information laws.
Making the numbers work
Is the discount worth it?
That is your decision, and it often comes down to arithmetic and comfort. Here is a way to frame it with invented numbers.
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Discount for completing the program | $50 a month = $600 a year |
| Screening is done at work, on paid time | No cost to you |
| Time on activities | Roughly 20 hours a year |
| Value of the discount per hour | $600 divided by 20 = $30 an hour |
If the discount is large and the requirements are easy, most people take it. If the requirements are costly or intrusive, you might not. Preventive screenings that your plan covers without cost sharing are separate from the program, and you may be able to get them from your own doctor. The guide Free preventive care under the ACA: what is covered at no cost explains which services are free under non-grandfathered plans.
One thing worth checking is whether the discount stacks with other pricing. For example, a program may offer a discount for you and a separate one for your spouse. Ask whether a spouse is eligible, and what a spouse must do. Genetic-information rules limit what can be asked of a spouse, so if the program asks for family medical history, ask why.
Where to take a problem
Who do I complain to if my employer's program breaks the rules?
It depends on the problem, and more than one office may be right.
- The program's design or a refused alternative under the health plan rules. The U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration handles questions about employer group health plans under ERISA. If the plan is fully insured, the state insurance department may also take a complaint, and the guide how to file a complaint with your state insurance department explains how. For a self-funded plan, the state generally cannot, and the federal agency is the route.
- Privacy of health information held by the plan or its vendors. The Department of Health and Human Services Office for Civil Rights handles HIPAA privacy complaints.
- Disability or genetic-information discrimination. The EEOC.
- Employment consequences. A state labor agency or an employment lawyer.
Start by asking the plan administrator in writing, and keep a copy. Many problems end there, because administrators prefer correcting a program to defending it.
What should I ask HR before I enroll in the program?
Write down the answers.
- Is the reward tied to participating, to an activity, or to a health result?
- What is the total reward, and what part of the premium does it represent?
- What is the reasonable alternative if I cannot meet the standard, and how do I request it?
- Who collects my data, and what does the employer receive?
- Is the program part of the group health plan?
- Can my spouse take part, and what is required of them?
- Is the reward taxable?
- When must I complete the activity to earn the discount in this plan year?
The guide questions to ask before you enroll: doctors, hospitals and drugs has a broader list for plan choices, and how employer health insurance works: premiums, plan choices and rules explains where wellness programs fit within an employer plan. A related post, the tobacco surcharge at work, how it works and how to avoid it, covers one program type in more depth.
Key takeaways
- Participatory programs reward taking part, while health-contingent programs reward meeting a health standard, and the protections are strongest in the second group.
- For health-contingent programs, federal rules from 2013 cap the total reward at 30% of the cost of coverage, and 50% when aimed at tobacco, with the cost of coverage counting the employer and employee shares.
- You are entitled to a reasonable alternative if the standard is unreasonably difficult or medically inadvisable for you, and the plan has to tell you the alternative exists.
- Ask who holds your data and what the employer sees, since health-plan information is generally protected by HIPAA but separate employer programs and apps may not be.
- Complaints go to the Department of Labor, the state insurance department for fully insured plans, the HHS Office for Civil Rights for privacy, or the EEOC for disability and genetic-information issues.