Blog
How state reinsurance programs lower marketplace premiums
A round-number example of how a state pays part of very high claims so insurers price lower, how federal pass-through funding fits in, and what members notice.
A state's announcement that its reinsurance program lowered marketplace premiums describes real arithmetic, but it is easy to misread. The state is not discounting your plan. It is covering part of the most expensive members' claims out of a separate pot of money, so that the insurer has fewer big costs to build into its price. The insurer's rate filing then comes in lower than it otherwise would, and the people who feel it most are those who pay the full premium.
This post explains the mechanism with invented round numbers, shows where federal money comes in, and says what a member does and does not see.
What reinsurance means here
Insurance for insurers has a long history. An insurer that sells a large number of policies may buy protection against a few enormous claims, so that one patient with a transplant or a premature newborn does not wipe out a year's margin. That product is reinsurance, and the state reinsurance program entry defines it in the ordinary sense.
A state reinsurance program for the individual market uses the same idea but is funded and run by the state. Insurers in the state's individual market keep selling plans as usual. When a member's claims for the year pass a threshold, the program reimburses the insurer for part of the amount above it. Because the insurer expects that reimbursement, it can set premiums lower.
Designs differ. Some programs pay on claims above a dollar threshold. Others have paid for claims tied to a list of costly conditions. Some have a ceiling above which they stop paying. The parameters that define a program are:
- Attachment point: the amount of one member's claims, in a year, that the insurer pays alone before the program pays anything.
- Coinsurance rate: the share of claims above the attachment point that the program pays.
- Cap: the point above which the program stops paying and the insurer is back on the hook.
A worked example with round numbers
All figures here are invented to show the mechanism. They are not any state's actual parameters.
Say a state program has an attachment point of $50,000, a coinsurance rate of 80% and a cap of $250,000. An insurer has a member whose covered claims in the year total $200,000.
- The insurer pays the first $50,000 alone.
- The amount above the attachment point is $200,000 − $50,000 = $150,000.
- The program pays 80% of that: 0.80 × $150,000 = $120,000.
- The insurer pays the other 20%: $30,000.
- The insurer's total cost for this member is $50,000 + $30,000 = $80,000, instead of $200,000.
Now take a larger case. A member's claims total $300,000.
- The insurer pays the first $50,000.
- The program pays 80% of claims between $50,000 and the cap at $250,000. That range is $200,000, and 0.80 × $200,000 = $160,000.
- The insurer pays the remaining 20% of that range: $40,000.
- Everything above the cap is the insurer's: $300,000 − $250,000 = $50,000.
- The insurer's total is $50,000 + $40,000 + $50,000 = $140,000, which equals $300,000 − $160,000.
The member's own cost sharing is unaffected in both cases. The member still pays the deductible, coinsurance and out-of-pocket maximum in the plan's contract, and the program only changes who bears the insurer's side of the bill.
From claims to premiums
The effect on the premium comes from adding up many members. Say an insurer expects 10,000 members and $60,000,000 in claims for the year. That is $6,000 per member per year, or $500 per member per month. Suppose the program is expected to reimburse $6,000,000 of those claims.
- Net claims the insurer must cover: $60,000,000 − $6,000,000 = $54,000,000.
- Per member per year: $54,000,000 ÷ 10,000 = $5,400. Per month: $5,400 ÷ 12 = $450.
- The claims part of the premium is $450 instead of $500, which is 10% lower: $50 ÷ $500.
Administrative costs and margin are added on top by the insurer, so the actual premium effect is a little smaller in percentage terms than the claims effect. The point is that the program lowers the amount insurers have to price for, and regulators who review rates (the rate review process) can ask insurers to show the reduction in filings. A state may say its program reduced premiums by some percentage compared with what they would have been without it. That is a comparison with a scenario that did not happen, which makes it an estimate, and analysts sometimes disagree about the size.
Reinsurance should not be confused with risk adjustment, which is a permanent federal program that moves money between insurers based on the health of the people they enroll, or with the older federal transitional reinsurance program that ran in the first years of the Affordable Care Act. A state program is separate from both.
Where federal money comes in
States usually start such a program under a section 1332 waiver, which lets a state change some marketplace rules if it meets federal guardrails. A reinsurance program lowers premiums, and the premium tax credit is pegged to the benchmark plan premium, so lower premiums also lower the federal government's credit payments. Under a 1332 waiver the state may receive "pass-through funding" based on the federal savings that result. The state then puts that money, plus its own funds, into the program.
Put another way:
- The state sets up the program and estimates its effect.
- Premiums, including the benchmark, come in lower.
- Federal credits per person fall because the benchmark fell.
- The federal government pays the state an amount tied to that savings.
- The state pays reimbursement to insurers out of pass-through funding and other sources, which have included state appropriations and assessments on insurers.
The amounts depend on federal rules and annual estimates, and the rules on subsidies changed for 2026 and 2027, so a state's pass-through funding can change from year to year. A state's budget office or insurance department publishes its numbers. Waivers are time-limited and are reviewed for renewal, so a program is not permanent by default.
What a member notices, and what they do not
A member usually notices very little, and that is by design.
- The premium may be lower than the previous year or rise by less than the national average. The change shows up in the premium rather than in a line item. A state might also publish a comparison, such as "X% lower than without the program".
- The plan's benefits and network are the same as an insurer would otherwise offer. The program is not a benefit.
- The claims process is unchanged. The program pays the insurer and not the member, so a member never files anything with it.
- Cost sharing is unchanged: the deductible, copays, coinsurance and out-of-pocket maximum come from the plan.
A subsidized member may notice less than an unsubsidized one. For a household that receives the premium tax credit, the credit adjusts with the benchmark, so their net cost for the benchmark plan is still set by their income. They may see a small effect, if any, for plans priced above or below the benchmark. The people who benefit most directly are those who buy without a credit, whether because they earn too much or choose to shop off the marketplace, and the federal government, whose credit payments fall. The How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share guide shows why.
Two households, one program
Say a state program lowers the benchmark Silver premium for a 40-year-old from $800 to $720 a month. These numbers are invented.
Household A gets a premium tax credit. Based on its income, the household is expected to contribute $300 a month toward the benchmark plan. The credit is the benchmark premium minus that contribution.
- Before the program: $800 − $300 = $500 credit, and the household pays $300 for the benchmark plan.
- After the program: $720 − $300 = $420 credit, and the household still pays $300.
The household's net cost for the benchmark plan did not move. The federal government pays $80 less per month, which is the savings that the state's pass-through funding is based on.
Household B has an income above the credit limit and receives no credit.
- Before the program: $800 a month.
- After the program: $720 a month, which is $80 less, or $960 a year.
The same program, then, is felt very differently depending on the credit. That is one reason both supporters and critics describe the programs in terms of the unsubsidized market.
Reading a state's announcement
When a state says its reinsurance program lowered rates, these checks help you judge the claim:
- Which plan year? Programs are evaluated year by year, and federal funding rules for the credit changed for 2026 and 2027.
- Which premium? A statement about average benchmark premiums is not a statement about the plan you are considering.
- Compared with what? The no-program figure is an estimate by the state or its actuaries. Look for the assumptions in the waiver documents.
- Who pays? Some of the funding comes from the federal pass-through and some from state sources. If the state's share is small, a program may be more exposed to federal changes.
The case for and against
Supporters say reinsurance stabilizes a market in which a few high-cost members drive prices, draws insurers into the state, lowers premiums for people who get no credit and costs the state less than it appears when federal pass-through funding is counted. They also point to states that saw average rate changes smaller than neighbors' after starting a program. Alaska, whose page notes a program in place since 2018, is one of the earliest examples; the Alaska page records what the research found.
Critics raise several points. A program can reduce what the federal government spends on credits without helping people who are subsidized, so the main beneficiaries are unsubsidized buyers and the federal budget. State money, and pass-through funding that varies with federal rules, can run short. Insurers may price assuming a program that ends, which could lead to a jump when it does. And a program that pays for high-cost claims does not address why those claims are high, so it does not reduce the underlying cost of care. Reasonable people weigh these points differently.
How to find out whether your state has one
- Look at your state insurance department's website for rate review pages. Rate filings for the individual market often mention reinsurance when it applies.
- Look at your state marketplace's site or press releases at the start of open enrollment. States usually announce premium changes and the reasons.
- Check the state's page on this site, such as Alaska for one example, and then confirm against the department's own pages.
- Ask a navigator or a licensed broker how the program, if any, shows up in the plans you are looking at. They can tell you where the filings are.
If you are looking at a specific number, such as "the program lowered premiums by 20%," ask three things: compared with what, for which plan year, and for whom. The answer for an unsubsidized buyer can differ from the answer for a subsidized one.
Questions people ask
Does reinsurance mean the state is paying my claims? No. The state reimburses the insurer, not the member, and only for part of the largest claims. Your plan still pays your claims under its contract.
Will a program protect me if I get very sick? Your protection comes from the plan's out-of-pocket maximum. A program changes the insurer's cost, not yours.
Is it the same as a high-risk pool? Older high-risk pools put people with costly conditions in a separate plan. A reinsurance program keeps everyone in the regular market and funds the insurer's high-cost claims instead.
Could the program end? Yes. Waivers and state funding have time limits and are subject to review. A state's insurance department or legislature announces changes.
Key takeaways
- A state reinsurance program reimburses insurers for part of very large claims, so they can price premiums lower; it does not reduce what a member owes under the plan.
- The example shows the mechanics: attachment point, coinsurance rate and cap decide how much the insurer saves per claim, and adding up many members shows the premium effect.
- Federal pass-through funding comes from the savings in premium tax credits that lower premiums create, and it can change with federal rules and estimates.
- Unsubsidized buyers feel the difference most; subsidized buyers are tied to income through the benchmark, so they may notice less.
- Ask "compared with what, for which year, for whom" when a state reports a percentage, and check your state insurance department for the filing details.