Blog
How do I appeal my IRMAA surcharge now that I've retired and my income dropped?
How to ask Social Security to lower an income-related Medicare surcharge after retirement or another life-changing event, with evidence, timing and an example.
The letter that announces an income-related surcharge on your Medicare premiums is built on a tax return from two years ago, back when you were still working. If you have since retired and your income has fallen, the surcharge may be measuring a life you no longer have. Social Security has a process for this, and it is a request, not a lawsuit. You show that a qualifying event reduced your income, you give your estimate for the lower year, and Social Security decides whether to use it instead of the old return.
This walkthrough follows that process in order: how the surcharge is set, which events qualify, the form and evidence, who decides, which year's income to estimate, how an approval is applied, what to do if you are denied, and a worked example of a retirement. It describes how the process works in general. Social Security makes the decision and sets the paperwork, so check its current form instructions before you send anything.
Step 1: Understand what the surcharge is measuring
The surcharge is called the income-related monthly adjustment amount, or IRMAA. It is added to your Part B premium, and to your Part D drug plan premium if you have one. Social Security sets it from your modified adjusted gross income (modified adjusted gross income) as reported on your federal tax return from two years earlier. In general that figure is your adjusted gross income plus any tax-exempt interest.
So the 2026 surcharge is generally based on your 2024 return, and the 2027 surcharge will generally be based on your 2025 return. The 2026 figures, from CMS, for a single filer are:
| 2024 income (single) | Total Part B premium per month, 2026 | Part D surcharge per month, 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Up to $109,000 | $202.90 | $0 |
| $109,001 to $137,000 | $284.10 | $14.50 |
| $137,001 to $171,000 | $405.80 | $37.50 |
| $171,001 to $205,000 | $527.50 | $60.40 |
| $205,001 to under $500,000 | $649.20 | $83.30 |
| $500,000 or more | $689.90 | $91.00 |
Married couples filing jointly have higher thresholds, and married people filing separately have different ones. The 2027 brackets and premium had not been announced as of November 16, 2026, so confirm them on Medicare.gov when they are published. The IRMAA explained: the income-related Medicare premium surcharge guide explains the structure, and the How does a big income year now raise my Medicare premiums two years later? post shows how to test your own income against it.
The delay is the reason an appeal makes sense. If your income fell last year or this year, your premium will not reflect it for a year or two unless you ask.
Step 2: Check whether your event qualifies
Social Security accepts a request to use a lower income estimate only for specific "life-changing events." As described by Social Security, the list includes:
- Marriage.
- Divorce or annulment.
- Death of a spouse.
- Work stoppage (you stopped working, including retiring).
- Work reduction (you cut your hours or pay).
- Loss of income-producing property, for example from a disaster or a sale tied to an event.
- Loss or reduction of pension income.
- Certain settlement payments from an employer or former employer, such as after a bankruptcy or closure.
Things that are not on the list generally do not qualify. A drop in investment gains, a year without a one-time sale, or a decision to take less from an account is a change in income, but it is not one of the events. A retirement, however, is a classic work stoppage. If you are unsure whether your situation fits, ask Social Security or a SHIP counselor before you assemble evidence.
The event must also have reduced your income compared with the year Social Security used. A retirement that happened but left your income about the same (for instance, because large retirement account withdrawals replaced your pay) will not help.
Step 3: Pick the right year to estimate
This is the step that confuses people. Social Security's decision turns on what your income will be (or was) in a particular year compared with the older year used for the surcharge.
- Estimate your modified adjusted gross income for the year in question: all income that appears on a tax return, such as wages, pension payments, taxable Social Security, taxable withdrawals from retirement accounts, interest, dividends, capital gains, plus tax-exempt interest.
- Use the year that Social Security's form instructs. In general it is the year of the event or the later year in which your premium is being set. If the event happened late in the year, the full-year effect may not show until the next year, and you may have to ask again then.
- Be realistic. If you will take large withdrawals, sell a house or convert an account to a Roth, include them.
The estimate is a promise, in effect. Social Security can later compare it with your actual tax return, and if your actual income turns out to be higher, it can change the surcharge and you could owe the difference. The Medicare IRMAA surcharge calculator on this site lets you test where a given income falls in the brackets.
Step 4: Get the form and the evidence
Social Security's form for this request is the Medicare Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount, Life-Changing Event, form SSA-44. The form asks for the event, its date, the income you expect and the evidence. Use the current version from Social Security's website or your local office, and follow its instructions for how to submit it.
Evidence depends on the event. Typical examples:
- Retirement or work stoppage. A letter from your employer on company letterhead giving the date you stopped working, a final pay stub, or a retirement or separation notice. If you are self-employed, documentation that the business closed or that you stopped working.
- Work reduction. An employer letter or pay records showing hours or pay before and after.
- Pension changes. The pension statement showing the change.
- Divorce, marriage or a spouse's death. The decree, marriage certificate or death certificate.
- Income estimate. Pension statements, Social Security award letters, and statements for any planned withdrawals, to support your figure.
Keep copies of everything. You will be signing the form to say the information is accurate, so do not guess about dates or amounts. If something is missing, say what is missing and when you will have it, rather than inventing it.
Step 5: Submit it and know who decides
Social Security, not Medicare and not your plan, decides. The form's instructions say how to submit it (in person at a local office, by mail or other methods listed there). Ask for a receipt or write down the date you sent it.
After review, Social Security may:
- Approve the request and use your estimate to set a lower surcharge.
- Ask for more evidence.
- Deny the request, with an explanation.
You will get a written notice. Read it, because the notice states which income Social Security used and what appeal rights you have.
Step 6: How an approval is applied
If Social Security approves, it generally recalculates your surcharge for the year in question using the lower income. In many cases, the new amount applies for that whole year, so you may be refunded any extra amount already deducted from your Social Security benefit or paid by bill. Ask the agency how and when the refund will arrive.
Then think about next year. Because the surcharge for the following year is again based on an older return, your old high income can reappear in the next determination. Ask Social Security whether it needs updated information each year or will keep applying the lower amount. In many cases, you will need to confirm again until the older return caught by the two-year lookback reflects your lower income. Put a reminder on your calendar for the fall when next year's premium notices arrive.
Step 7: If you are denied
You have the right to ask Social Security to reconsider. The notice gives the deadline, which for Social Security decisions is generally 60 days from the date you receive it, and tells you how to file. Use the time to figure out why you were denied. Common reasons include:
- The event is not on Social Security's list.
- The evidence did not show the event or its date.
- The estimated income was not lower enough to change the bracket.
- The wrong year was estimated.
If the reason is missing evidence, add it and request reconsideration. If you think the event qualifies and was misread, say so in writing. A SHIP counselor, a legal aid office or an attorney experienced in Social Security matters can help.
A worked example
This is a hypothetical with invented incomes, using the 2026 figures above.
Say Pat, single, worked full time through December 2025 and retired on December 31, 2025. Pat's 2024 tax return showed modified adjusted gross income of $150,000. For 2026 Social Security sets Pat's surcharge from that 2024 return, which falls in the $137,001 to $171,000 bracket.
What Pat is charged under the old return.
- Part B total: $405.80 a month. The standard premium is $202.90, so the surcharge is $405.80 minus $202.90 equals $202.90 a month.
- Part D surcharge: $37.50 a month.
- Combined surcharge: $202.90 plus $37.50 equals $240.40 a month.
- Over twelve months: $240.40 times 12 equals $2,884.80.
What Pat does. Pat files the life-changing-event request for work stoppage, with an employer letter giving the retirement date, and estimates 2026 income at $48,000 (invented: a pension, Social Security and modest interest).
If approved. $48,000 is under $109,000, so the first bracket applies: $202.90 for Part B and no Part D surcharge. Pat's premiums drop by $240.40 a month, which is $2,884.80 over the year. If Pat had already paid several months at the higher rate, Social Security would refund the difference. For example, if five months were paid at the higher rate, the refund would be $240.40 times 5, which is $1,202.00.
The next year. For 2027, Social Security will generally look at the 2025 return, which includes a full year of wages, so Pat expects another high determination and plans to file again with the 2027 estimate. The surcharge for 2028 would then be based on the 2026 return, which reflects the lower income.
Mistakes that cost people time or money
- Waiting for the surcharge to fix itself. The two-year lookback means a premium based on old wages can last a year or more after you retire unless you ask.
- Estimating only wages. Retirement account withdrawals, taxable Social Security and one-time gains count toward the estimate. An estimate that leaves them out can produce a later bill.
- Sending a request for an event that is not on the list. Check the list first, and use a counselor if unsure.
- Forgetting the surcharge shows up in two places. It affects the Part B premium and any Part D surcharge, and how it is collected depends on whether you are billed or have it deducted. The How does Medicare take my Part B premium out of my Social Security check? post explains deduction and billing, and the medicare premiums and deductibles: what you pay in 2026 and 2027 guide lists the premium components.
- Not refiling. An approval for one year does not always carry to the next.
- Missing the appeal deadline after a denial.
A checklist before you send the form
- Confirm the event is on Social Security's list.
- Confirm the year of income you are estimating, and make the estimate complete.
- Gather evidence for the event, with dates.
- Use the current form and follow the submission instructions.
- Keep copies and a record of the date you sent it.
- Ask how and when any refund will arrive and whether to refile next year.
- Watch for the notice and its deadline.
Key takeaways
- The surcharge is generally based on your tax return from two years earlier, so a retirement or other life-changing event can leave you paying for income you no longer have.
- Social Security decides requests to use a lower income estimate, using form SSA-44 and evidence of the event; Medicare and your plan do not.
- Estimate your full modified adjusted gross income for the correct year, including withdrawals and one-time income, since Social Security can compare it with your actual return later.
- An approval generally recalculates the surcharge for the year, but you may need to ask again the next year; a denial can be reconsidered, usually within 60 days.
- A SHIP counselor or Social Security can confirm the current form, the right year and the deadline for your case.