Blog

How does the Medicaid five-year look-back treat gifts, and what is the penalty?

How the 60-month look-back reviews transfers, which ones are exempt, and how a penalty period is figured, with a worked example at an invented divisor.

When someone applies for Medicaid to pay for nursing home care or other long-term services, the state does not look only at what they own today. It asks for statements covering the previous 60 months and checks whether assets were given away or sold for less than they were worth. A transfer for less than fair value inside that window does not disqualify a person from Medicaid forever. It creates a penalty period, a stretch of time during which Medicaid will not pay for long-term care, and the length of that stretch is a matter of arithmetic.

This post explains how the review works, which transfers are generally exempt, how a penalty is calculated with a worked example, and what the rules mean for someone who is thinking about helping a parent or planning for their own care. The numbers in the examples are invented for illustration. State rules differ in important details, and an elder law attorney is the right person before any transfer is made.

What the look-back is for

medicaid is the main payer for long-term nursing facility care in the United States, because Medicare's coverage of nursing facility stays is short and limited to skilled rehabilitation. The guide on Does Medicare pay for nursing home care and home care? explains that gap. Medicaid, though, is a program for people with limited income and resources. If anyone could give their savings and home to their children and apply the next day, the program would be paying for the care of people who could have paid for it themselves.

The look-back is the rule that addresses this. Federal law sets the look-back period at 60 months, counted backward from the date a person is both in an institution (or applying for home and community based services) and has applied for Medicaid. States use that 60-month period for long-term care Medicaid. The rule applies to long-term services and supports, not to the ordinary Medicaid coverage a child or pregnant adult receives.

Two points are often misunderstood:

  • The look-back is about transfers, not about everything you spent. Paying bills, buying groceries, repairing a roof and taking a vacation are not transfers. Giving money or property away, or selling it for far below its value, is.
  • The look-back reviews history, but the penalty looks forward. The period of ineligibility is not served in the past. It starts later, as described below.

What the state reviews

At application, you are generally asked for 60 months of statements for every account, copies of deeds and titles, records of any property sold, and an explanation for withdrawals that look unusual. The caseworker looks for patterns: a large check to a relative, a sudden sale of a house at a price well below the assessed value, an account that was emptied and closed, a life insurance policy cashed in, a loan that was forgiven.

Things that commonly count as a transfer for less than fair value include:

  • Gifts of cash or property to children, grandchildren or anyone else.
  • Selling a car, land or a house to a family member for less than it is worth.
  • Adding another person's name to a bank account or deed, which can be treated as a gift of a share.
  • Forgiving a loan that is owed to you.
  • Giving up an inheritance you were entitled to, in some states' treatment.
  • Putting assets into certain trusts that you cannot reach.
  • Paying a relative for care without a written agreement for fair compensation, which the agency may see as a disguised gift.

Small, regular gifts also appear in the records. Holiday and birthday presents do not usually raise concern, but a state may treat a large wedding gift or a long series of monthly transfers differently, and the rules on what is acceptable vary. An agency that sees repeated withdrawals will ask what they were for. Keep receipts for expenses you paid on your own behalf.

Transfers that are generally exempt

Federal law lists transfers that do not create a penalty. The categories below are the common ones. Details, such as how long a person must have lived in a home, are set by statute and state rules, so confirm them with the state agency or an attorney.

  • Transfers to a spouse, or to another person for the sole benefit of the spouse. This is why a couple can often move assets between them without a penalty, though the rules on how much the spouse at home may keep are a separate topic covered in my spouse needs a nursing home, so what does the spouse at home keep?.
  • Transfers of the home to certain people: the spouse; a child who is under 21 or who is blind or permanently disabled; a sibling who already has an equity interest in the home and lived there for at least one year before the person entered the facility; and an adult child who lived in the home for at least two years before institutionalization and provided care that allowed the parent to stay out of a facility.
  • Transfers to a blind or disabled child, or to a trust for that child's sole benefit.
  • Transfers to certain trusts for a disabled person under 65, when the trust meets specific legal requirements.
  • Transfers for fair market value. Selling something at its real price, and putting the money to use, is not a gift. The proceeds, however, may count as a resource.
  • Returns of the asset. If the gifted property comes back to the applicant, many states reduce or erase the penalty for the amount returned.

The exemptions are narrow and precise. A parent who gives the house to a child who lived with them for eighteen months but not two years does not meet the caregiver child exemption, however close the child is. A deed prepared by a friend that omits the right language may fail a rule that a lawyer would have met. A separate post, Which Medicaid planning mistakes involve deeding the house or gifting to kids?, goes through the most common failures.

How the penalty is calculated

The formula is straightforward, and the state supplies one number.

Penalty period in months = total uncompensated value of transfers inside the look-back ÷ the state's monthly divisor.

The divisor is a figure each state sets, based on the average monthly private-pay cost of nursing facility care in that state. It differs from state to state and can change, so you must ask the state Medicaid agency what the current divisor is. The examples below use an invented divisor of $10,000 per month. That is not a real state's number, and you should not use it for planning.

Worked example 1: one gift

Say Ruth, 82, gave her grandson $60,000 three years ago to help him buy a house. She now needs nursing facility care and applies for Medicaid.

  • Transfer inside the look-back: $60,000
  • Illustrative divisor: $10,000 per month
  • Penalty: $60,000 ÷ $10,000 = 6 months

During those 6 months Medicaid will not pay for her nursing facility care, even though she is otherwise eligible.

Worked example 2: a partial month

Say Carl, 79, gave his daughter $75,000 two years ago.

  • $75,000 ÷ $10,000 = 7.5
  • Penalty: 7 months and half of a month

Federal law requires states to account for the partial month, and states differ in how they count the days. Some convert the fraction to days; some round. The agency's notice will state the start and end date.

Worked example 3: several gifts add up

Say Maya, 85, gave $5,000 to a niece 40 months ago, $12,000 to a grandson 30 months ago and $23,000 to a church in the last year, for a total of $40,000.

  • Total uncompensated transfers: $5,000 + $12,000 + $23,000 = $40,000
  • $40,000 ÷ $10,000 = 4 months

Many states total all transfers made within the look-back and then impose one period. A single large gift and several small ones can have the same effect. Whether a gift to a religious or charitable organization is treated the same way as a gift to a relative varies, and a lawyer can tell you how your state handles it.

When the penalty starts

This is the part that surprises families. The penalty period does not begin on the day of the gift. Under federal law it generally begins on the later of two dates: the first day of the month after the transfer, or the date the person is eligible for Medicaid and would be receiving institutional-level care but for the penalty.

In practice, that means the clock starts only when the person:

  1. is in a nursing facility or has been assessed as needing that level of care,
  2. has applied for Medicaid, and
  3. has already spent down to the state's resource limit.

So in the first example, if Ruth has the $60,000 problem and also still has $50,000 above the resource limit, the clock does not start while she has that money. She would have to use the excess on care first. Only when she has no other resources, is in the facility and has applied does the 6 months begin. During those 6 months she must find another way to pay, which could mean her income, family support or a long-term care policy.

This is why giving away money "five years ahead" is not simple, and why giving it away a year or two ahead can cause a hardship. If the gift was made long before the look-back, the penalty never arises. If it was made inside the window, the penalty falls on the person at the point when they are least able to cover costs.

How a penalty can end or shrink

A penalty is not always final.

  • Return of the gift. If the asset or money is returned in full, many states cancel the penalty. A partial return reduces it. This can be hard to do when the recipient has spent the money.
  • Hardship waivers. States must have a process to waive a penalty when it would deprive a person of medical care that endangers health or life, or of food and shelter. Granting one is rare and the process is formal. An attorney or the agency can explain the criteria.
  • Proof that the transfer was not for Medicaid purposes. A person may show that the asset was transferred for another reason, for example a gift made decades ago before any illness, or for fair value. Records matter. Good documentation can mean the difference between a penalty and none.
  • Errors. Agencies miscalculate. A divisor may be misapplied, or a transfer counted twice. You can ask for a written explanation, and if you disagree you have a right to a fair hearing, which usually has a short deadline noted in the notice.

What the look-back means for different people

For an older adult in good health, the look-back is mainly a reason to see an attorney before making large gifts, not to avoid generosity. Helping with a grandchild's tuition today may be fine for some and risky for others, depending on whether long-term care is likely and how much other money is available.

For an adult child, the rule is a reason to keep records. If you pay a parent's bills, write down what you paid, from which account, and why. If a parent gave you money for their own care, keep proof that it was used for that purpose. If a parent lives with you and you provide care, discuss a written personal care agreement with a lawyer rather than relying on informal payments.

For anyone planning, long-term care insurance sits on the other side of the same problem. A long-term care insurance policy pays for care without a look-back, within its own terms, and some states have partnership programs that interact with Medicaid asset rules. The guide on long-term care insurance explained: how it works and what it costs covers how these policies work and what they cost.

Questions to ask an elder law attorney

Bring statements for the last five years and a list of gifts you remember. Ask:

  • What is our state's divisor today, and how does the state count partial months?
  • Are any of these past transfers exempt?
  • Which assets can safely be spent on the person's own needs, and what records should I keep?
  • Is there an exempt way to use money, such as paying off a mortgage or making repairs to a home the person still lives in, that fits our situation?
  • What happens to the home, including estate recovery after death? The Q&A What does Medicaid estate recovery take from a parent's house after death? covers that.
  • If we do something this year, what is the worst outcome and how likely is it?

A certified elder law attorney, or one who focuses on Medicaid planning, is trained to answer questions like these. A local Area Agency on Aging, a state bar referral service or legal aid for seniors can help find one, and some legal aid organizations offer free help to people with low incomes.

Key takeaways

  • The look-back is 60 months of transfers, reviewed when someone applies for long-term care Medicaid, and the penalty is a period when Medicaid will not pay for long-term care.
  • Penalty months equal the uncompensated transfers divided by the state's monthly divisor, so a $60,000 gift at an illustrative $10,000 divisor produces 6 months.
  • The penalty clock generally starts only when the person is in care, has applied and has no other excess resources, which is why a gift can cause trouble years later.
  • Transfers to a spouse, certain transfers of the home and transfers to a disabled child are generally exempt, but the conditions are narrow.
  • Keep records of every payment you make for a parent and see an elder law attorney before any transfer, because state rules and divisors differ.

Terms used in this guide

Related guides

Latest on this topic