Blog

My income is right at the Medicaid line: Medicaid or marketplace plan?

How Medicaid's monthly income test differs from the marketplace's yearly estimate, with a decision list for incomes near 138% or, in other states, 100%.

Picture a single adult, call her Rena, whose paychecks add up to somewhere near $22,000 a year. She lives in a state that expanded Medicaid. One website says she may qualify for Medicaid. Another says she can buy a marketplace plan with a large tax credit. Both can be true on the same day, and which one applies depends less on her yearly total than on how each program measures income, and on when.

This post is for a reader whose income sits close to the Medicaid line. It explains how the screening works, why a monthly test and a yearly estimate can give different answers, and how to decide what to apply for and in what order. It also covers the other line that matters in states that did not expand Medicaid: 100% of the poverty level, where marketplace credits begin.

Two lines, depending on your state

Medicaid for adults without a disabling condition is built around two very different rules, and which one you face depends on where you live.

In a state that adopted medicaid expansion, adults under 65 who are not otherwise eligible can qualify with household income up to 138% of the federal poverty level. The figure is the 133% written into the Affordable Care Act plus a standard 5-point income disregard that states apply when they convert to the new income method. As of November 2026, 41 states including the District of Columbia have expanded, according to KFF's tracker.

In the 10 states that have not expanded (Alabama, Florida, Georgia, Kansas, Mississippi, South Carolina, Tennessee, Texas, Wisconsin and Wyoming, per the same KFF page), the adult limit is set by each state and is often far below the poverty line for parents. Many childless adults cannot qualify on income alone. In those states the line that matters for a reader near the bottom of the range is 100% of the poverty level, because marketplace premium tax credits generally start there. Below it, the person may fall into what the guide The Medicaid coverage gap: who falls between Medicaid and credits calls the coverage gap.

A reader who is not sure which kind of state they live in can use the medicaid expansion and eligibility lookup and then confirm with the state Medicaid agency, because the agency's own table is the one that decides.

How the numbers translate into dollars

The 2026 federal poverty guideline for a household of one in the 48 contiguous states and D.C. is $15,960. The guideline for two people is $21,640, for three $27,320, and for four $33,000.

For one person, 138% of $15,960 is $15,960 × 1.38 = $22,024.80 a year, or about $1,835 a month. The 100% line for one person is $15,960 a year, or $1,330 a month. KFF's tracker uses $21,597 for 138% of the older 2025 guideline, which is $15,650 × 1.38. States update their tables on their own schedules, so the number your state is applying this month may be either one. The notice or the state website gives the figure that counts.

Household size is a separate step: it is counted by the tax-filing rules for most adults, and a bigger household has a higher line. The post How does Medicaid count my income? MAGI, household size and what is left out covers what counts as income and who counts as household. For this decision, remember that a larger household moves both lines up, and that a miscounted household is one of the commonest reasons for a wrong result.

The monthly test and the yearly estimate

This is the part that confuses people near the line.

Medicaid looks at current monthly income. When you apply, the agency generally compares what you are receiving this month with the monthly limit for your household size. Your yearly total matters less than whether this month's income is under the limit. Because the test is repeated at renewals and when you report a change, a person can qualify in one month and not in another.

Premium tax credits look at projected income for the whole tax year. When you apply for marketplace help, you estimate your modified adjusted gross income, abbreviated modified adjusted gross income, for the year. The credit is then figured on that estimate, and reconciled against your actual income when you file taxes.

Here is a labeled hypothetical with round numbers. Say Jordan is single and expects to be paid $1,700 a month for eight months and $2,400 a month for four months.

  • Yearly income: (8 × $1,700) + (4 × $2,400) = $13,600 + $9,600 = $23,200.
  • Percent of the poverty level for the yearly estimate: $23,200 ÷ $15,960 is about 145%.
  • Monthly test against a limit of about $1,835: the $1,700 months are under it; the $2,400 months are over it.

In an expansion state, Jordan might qualify for Medicaid in the low-income months and not in the high-income months, while a marketplace estimate for the year would put Jordan at about 145% of the poverty level, which is a band where credits are large. The post Which income does Medicaid use when my pay swings from month to month? goes further into how agencies treat irregular pay.

None of this is a prediction that a particular agency will approve or deny anyone. It shows why two correct screenings can send the same person in different directions.

What each path looks like at this income

Medicaid

If you qualify, the benefits are broad, the premium is usually zero or very small, and cost sharing is limited. The cost is mainly administrative: you must report changes, renew, and respond to notices on the agency's schedule. Federal rules signed in 2025 add more of this for adults in expansion programs. As of November 2026, the work and community engagement requirement for expansion adults aged 19 to 64 is set to begin no later than January 1, 2027, with an optional "hold harmless" period through June 30, 2027 that CMS announced on November 13, 2026, and that states must decide on by December 11, 2026. Six-month renewals for expansion adults apply to renewals scheduled on or after December 31, 2026. Exemptions exist, including for parents of children 13 and under and people who are medically frail. The state agency can tell you which rules apply to your case and when.

Marketplace plan with a credit

For plan year 2027, the share of income a person is expected to pay toward the benchmark silver plan is 2.15% below 133% of the poverty level and rises from 3.23% to 4.30% between 133% and 150% (IRS Rev. Proc. 2026-26). For Jordan at about 145%, the applicable percentage works out to roughly 4%, as an illustration, which on $23,200 is about $930 a year, or roughly $77 a month for the benchmark plan, before any choice of a cheaper or costlier plan. The credit fills the gap between that share and the benchmark premium. The guide How ACA premium tax credits work: income, benchmark plan, your share shows the method, and the ACA subsidy estimator will do the arithmetic for your numbers.

At this income, a silver plan also comes with cost-sharing reduction. For 2027 the out-of-pocket limit on the cost-sharing-reduction variants is $4,000 for one person at 100% to 150% of the poverty level, against a general plan-year limit of $12,000 for self-only coverage, per CMS guidance published in January 2026. The deductible and copays on that variant are also much lower than on the standard silver plan.

A marketplace plan has a monthly premium, a network that may be narrower than the Medicaid managed care plan, and a tax reconciliation step. Under the 2025 budget law, excess advance credit must be repaid in full beginning with tax year 2026, with no income-based cap. That makes an accurate estimate worth the effort.

The rule that connects the two

A person who is eligible for Medicaid generally cannot receive premium tax credits. That is why the marketplace asks about income first and may send your application to the state. It is also why the choice is not purely a preference: in an expansion state, if you are found eligible for Medicaid, buying a marketplace plan means paying full price for it. Conversely, if the state finds you ineligible, you can proceed to a plan with credits.

The decision list

Work down this list in order. Stop at the first item that settles your situation.

  1. If you live in an expansion state and your current monthly income is clearly under the monthly limit (a safe margin below, such as $1,700 against about $1,835), apply for Medicaid. You may also qualify later by month if your income varies; you do not have to guess about the year.
  2. If your current monthly income is slightly over the limit but your yearly estimate is lower (income that is falling, a job ending, a seasonal pattern), apply anyway and report the real month. The agency applies its own rules about which month and which income count. A denial is useful information, covered below.
  3. If your monthly income is clearly over the limit, skip to the marketplace and use a careful yearly estimate. Do not shave the estimate to get a better credit, because the difference comes back as a repayment.
  4. If you live in a state that has not expanded Medicaid and your income is above 100% of the poverty level, apply through the marketplace. You will be assessed for credits, and for Medicaid under your state's narrower rules.
  5. If you live in such a state and your income is below 100%, check any group you might fit (parent, pregnant, disabled, 65 or older). If none does, read The Medicaid coverage gap: who falls between Medicaid and credits and speak to a navigator about other options, including community health centers.
  6. If income could land on either side of the line during the year, use the Medicaid agency for the low months and the marketplace for the high months, and ask a navigator how to coordinate. People moving between the two should read My Medicaid ended: how do I get marketplace coverage without a gap? or Should I switch from my marketplace plan to Medicaid now that my income dropped?.

Two cautions apply to the whole list. First, apply on only one site if you can, because a single application on HealthCare.gov or your state exchange screens you for both programs. Second, ask for the decision in writing and keep it.

Why a Medicaid denial letter matters for the marketplace

A denial is not only bad news. It is a record that connects two programs.

When the state decides you are over the income limit, the decision tells the marketplace that you are not eligible for Medicaid, which is one of the conditions for credits. A written notice also states the income, household size and limit the agency used. If any of those is wrong, that is your basis for a correction or an appeal. The related post The marketplace sent me to Medicaid but Medicaid denied me, so now what? covers what to do when the two programs disagree.

Read the reason on the letter before you rely on it. A denial because you were over the limit is different from a denial because the agency did not receive documents. The second does not necessarily mean you are over the limit, and it may not unlock credits in the way the first does. In that case you may be able to send the missing items and ask the agency to reconsider, or file the appeal, rather than moving on.

Keep the letter with your marketplace records. If you later get a data matching notice, or the marketplace asks about Medicaid eligibility, the letter is the proof. In an expansion state a person who is denied or dropped from Medicaid solely for failing to meet the work requirement is ineligible for premium tax credits under the 2025 budget law, as KFF has summarized it, so the reason on a letter can matter a lot in 2027.

A worked comparison near the line

Here is a second hypothetical, in an expansion state. Marcus is single, expects $2,000 a month steadily, and has no other income.

  • Yearly income: 12 × $2,000 = $24,000.
  • Against the 2026 guideline: $24,000 ÷ $15,960 is about 150%.
  • Monthly test: about $1,835 is the limit, so $2,000 is over it by $165.

Marcus is over the Medicaid line by a modest amount. A marketplace application, using a yearly estimate of $24,000, places him at the top of the 133% to 150% band, where the expected contribution toward the benchmark plan is about 4.3% for 2027. That is 0.043 × $24,000 = $1,032 a year, or $86 a month. He is also still eligible for a silver plan with cost-sharing reductions, because he is below 250%. The marketplace is plausibly the right path for him unless his income drops. If he later has a month under the limit, he should report it and apply, since Medicaid looks at the month.

For Rena, the reader we started with, the answer depends on her actual monthly pay and her state. The point of the example is not the result. It is the steps: find the monthly limit, compare it to this month's pay, estimate the year, and check what the marketplace would cost.

Questions to put to the person who can answer

  • A navigator or a licensed broker can screen both programs with you for free or for no extra cost to you, and can explain your state's marketplace. The guide How to apply for Medicaid: documents, timeline and what happens next lists what to gather.
  • The state Medicaid agency can confirm the table it is using and explain a denial or the work-requirement status of your group.
  • A tax professional can answer how a changing income affects the repayment, especially in a year when income swings across the 138% or 100% lines.

Key takeaways

  • Medicaid tests this month's income; the marketplace tests a projection for the whole year. A person near the line can be on one side of one test and the other side of the other.
  • In expansion states the adult Medicaid line is 138% of the poverty level; in non-expansion states the line to watch is 100%, where credits start.
  • A person eligible for Medicaid generally cannot get premium tax credits, so apply to Medicaid first if you are clearly under the monthly limit.
  • Do not understate yearly income to improve a marketplace credit: excess advance credit must be repaid in full starting with tax year 2026.
  • Keep the Medicaid decision letter, and read the stated reason before relying on it.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic