Blog

Medigap timing mistakes: when the six-month window really starts

Seven ways people lose the guaranteed right to buy Medigap, from delaying Part B to dropping a policy, with what each costs and how to avoid it.

The Medigap open enrollment period is a one-time, six-month window. During it, any insurer selling Medigap in your state must sell you any policy it offers, at the same rate it charges others your age, and cannot turn you down or charge more because of your health. Once it ends, in most states an insurer can ask health questions and refuse or reprice you. The rule is simple to state and easy to miss, because the clock does not start on the date most people assume.

The window begins the first month you are 65 or older and enrolled in Medicare Part B. Both conditions have to be true. Everything below is a way that sentence gets misread.

Mistake 1: Treating the 65th birthday as the starting gun

How it happens. A person turns 65 in March, hears "you have six months," and counts to September. But if that person is still working and has delayed Part B, the clock has not started at all. The reverse also happens: someone who enrolled in Part B at 64 because of disability hears "Medigap needs Part B" and assumes the window opened then.

What it costs. If you believe the window is open when it is not, you may skip applying for a policy during the only period when your health history does not matter. If you believe it closed when it has not, you may buy a more expensive or less suitable policy out of panic.

How to avoid it. Find the date your Part B coverage begins. It is on your Medicare card (the "Medical (Part B)" effective date) and in your Social Security letter. The window starts the first day of the month in which you are both 65 or older and enrolled in Part B, and it runs six full months. Mark the last day on a calendar before you start shopping. The Medicare Initial Enrollment Period calculator helps with the Part B date, and Medicare Initial Enrollment Period: your seven-month window covers the seven-month sign-up period around your birthday.

Mistake 2: Starting Part B late after job-based coverage and not noticing the window moved

How it happens. A person works past 65, stays on the employer plan and delays Part B. Later the job ends, Part B starts under a special enrollment period, and the Medigap window opens that month. If the person has relied on a rule of thumb ("it expires six months after 65"), they conclude it is gone.

The opposite error exists too. Someone who enrolls in Part B late through the General Enrollment Period, from January 1 to March 31, with coverage starting the month after sign-up, may not realize that this also opens the Medigap window, and that it is the best moment to shop.

What it costs. A missed window means medical underwriting for the rest of your Medicare life, in most states. A late-enrollment penalty for Part B is a separate cost, and a permanent one: 10% for each full 12 months you could have enrolled and did not.

How to avoid it. If you delay Part B because of employer coverage, ask the plan sponsor whether it counts as primary for your situation. medicare and employer coverage: who pays first if you work past 65? explains who pays first. Then plan the Medigap purchase for the month your Part B starts, not a date from your birthday. An employer plan that ends is a prompt to go to Medicare.gov or Social Security and confirm the Part B effective date. I retired and my eight-month Part B window closed, so what now? covers the case where the eight-month special enrollment period has already run out.

Mistake 3: Buying in the wrong month

How it happens. Medigap cannot start before Part B does, and the effective date you ask for matters. Two things go wrong. People apply before their Part B is effective, and the insurer rejects the application or delays it. Or they apply in the final days of the window and the insurer takes weeks to process it.

What it costs. An application sent too early can be rejected, and a rejection that surfaces late in the window leaves little time to apply again. An application sent late can be caught by processing delays that you cannot control, so ask the insurer, in writing, which date it treats as your application date.

How to avoid it.

  1. Ask for an effective date that matches the first day of your Part B coverage, or the first of a later month you choose.
  2. Apply during the first weeks of the window, not the last, so there is room to fix problems.
  3. Keep a copy of the application and a record of the date you submitted it.
  4. If the insurer asks health questions during open enrollment, answer them accurately, but ask why. Questions on an open-enrollment application are usually about the date you enrolled in Part B and whether you have other coverage, not your health.

A pre-existing-condition waiting period is a related trap. An insurer may impose a waiting period of up to six months on conditions treated in the six months before you applied, though time you had creditable coverage reduces or removes it. Ask directly whether any waiting period applies.

Mistake 4: Dropping a policy to save money

How it happens. A premium rises. A person on a fixed income decides to cancel the Medigap policy, thinking they can buy another later or fall back on Original Medicare. Maybe they intend to try a Medicare Advantage plan with a $0 premium.

What it costs. Outside the open enrollment window and outside the specific guaranteed-issue rights, an insurer in most states can underwrite you, which means asking about your health. A person who was healthy at 65 and has since developed a heart condition or diabetes may be turned down or priced very high. KFF estimated that 74% of people in Medicare Advantage have a condition that could lead to a Medigap denial outside the protected windows. The right to re-enter, if you have it at all, depends on your state and your circumstances.

How to avoid it. Before you cancel, compare options inside the policy first. Ask the same insurer about a different plan letter, shop the same letter with other insurers, and check whether your state has a birthday rule or continuous guaranteed issue. Some states, including Connecticut and New York, let people change Medigap policies at any time; Massachusetts and Maine have annual windows; and in 16 states a birthday rule lets someone who already has a policy switch to an equal or less comprehensive one around the birthday. Switching Medigap insurers to pay less without losing coverage walks through switching without a gap. A birthday rule does not help someone who has no policy at all.

Mistake 5: Applying for the wrong plan letter

How it happens. A friend recommends "Plan F," or an old article describes Plan C. A person who became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020 cannot buy Plan C or Plan F, and the application for the plan they have in mind goes nowhere. Or they choose Plan N because it is cheaper, then learn they dislike the visit copays and the possibility of Part B excess charges.

What it costs. Inside the window you can buy any plan an insurer sells. After the window you may be denied a more comprehensive plan. Moving from a more generous letter to a cheaper one is usually easier than the other direction, and moving up is often where underwriting bites.

How to avoid it. Decide on the letter before the window opens. Put two letters side by side with the medigap plan comparison chart, price both with a few insurers, and then pick. Consider where you might want to be in five years: if you are healthy now and expect to need more care later, the more comprehensive plan is hard to add afterwards. If you are weighing the amount of a premium against the chance of a large year, the arithmetic belongs in a worksheet, not a hunch. medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue covers the rules that apply when a window opens or closes.

Mistake 6: Assuming the window can be extended

How it happens. A person is sick in the hospital in the last month of the window, or is waiting for a doctor to confirm a diagnosis, and assumes the insurer will make an exception.

What it costs. The window is a legal one. Insurers have no power to extend it, and an exception for one person is not something a company or a counselor can promise.

How to avoid it. If there is a health event, apply first and manage the event second. An application submitted inside the window is protected even if you later have a bad month. If you are truly unable to apply, ask a SHIP counselor whether a state rule offers another path.

Mistake 7: Overlooking a second guaranteed-issue right

How it happens. People think the open enrollment window is the only one. It is not. Federal law gives guaranteed-issue rights in specific situations, such as a Medicare Advantage plan leaving your area or your employer coverage ending, and some states add more. These rights come with deadlines of their own, usually counted in weeks or a couple of months from the event, and they may be limited to certain plan letters.

What it costs. A person who loses a Medicare Advantage plan in December and does not know about the right to buy Medigap may let the deadline pass while sorting out drug coverage.

How to avoid it. When any coverage ends, read the notice for the dates and ask a SHIP counselor whether a guaranteed-issue right applies. Can a Medigap insurer turn me down after my open enrollment ends? and guaranteed issue explain how these rights work.

A quick calendar for a typical case

Say Marta, a hypothetical reader, turns 65 on July 12 and is still working with employer coverage. She delays Part B. Her Medigap window has not started. She retires on March 31 of the following year, enrolls in Part B in March using her eight-month special enrollment period, and her Part B starts April 1. Her window runs from April through September. If she applies in April, she has five months of slack. If she waits until the end of September and the insurer is slow, she has none.

The same arithmetic works for any start date: count six months from the first month you are both 65 and in Part B, and treat the first month as month one.

Questions to ask before you buy

  • What is my Part B effective date, and what is the last day of my window?
  • Is this application under open enrollment or under regular underwriting?
  • Which plan letters will I have trouble adding later?
  • Does a waiting period for pre-existing conditions apply?
  • Does my state have a birthday rule, continuous guaranteed issue or an annual window?
  • Who is the free, unbiased person I can ask: my SHIP counselor or the state insurance department?

Key takeaways

  • The six-month Medigap window starts the first month you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B, not on your birthday.
  • Mark the end of the window on a calendar and apply early, because insurers cannot extend it.
  • Dropping a policy to save money can mean losing the right to buy another without underwriting.
  • Plans C and F are not available to anyone who became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020.
  • A separate guaranteed-issue right can follow the loss of other coverage; the notice you receive states the dates.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic