Blog

Why did I get a Part D penalty? Creditable coverage mistakes at 65

How the Part D late enrollment penalty works, the creditable-coverage mistakes new enrollees make when leaving job or VA coverage, and how to dispute it.

A Part D penalty letter usually arrives months after a person starts a drug plan, and it usually follows a gap nobody remembered. The penalty is a small monthly amount added to the drug plan's premium, and it can last as long as you have Part D. The cause is almost always one of a handful of mistakes about creditable drug coverage, meaning drug coverage that Medicare considers at least as good as the standard Part D benefit. This post walks through how the penalty is calculated, the mistakes that trigger it among people who moved onto Medicare from a job, the VA or another plan, and how to dispute one.

How the penalty works

The Part D late enrollment penalty applies when, after your Initial Enrollment Period ended, you went 63 days or more in a row without Part D or other creditable drug coverage. For each full month you were without that coverage, the penalty is 1% of the national base beneficiary premium. The base premium was $38.99 in 2026 and is $41.33 for 2027, so each uncovered month is about $0.39 in 2026 and about $0.41 in 2027 (1% of $38.99 is $0.3899, and 1% of $41.33 is $0.4133).

The penalty is added to your plan's monthly premium for as long as you have Part D, and its dollar amount is recalculated each year as the base premium changes. People who get Extra Help, the low-income subsidy, generally do not pay it. The plan's letter shows the exact amount, because CMS rounds the figure.

Here are two labeled hypothetical examples with invented round gaps, using the 2027 base premium of $41.33.

Seven full months uncovered. 7 months times 1% equals 7%. 7% of $41.33 is $2.89 a month, which is about $34.68 over a year (2.89 times 12).

Twenty full months uncovered. 20 months times 1% equals 20%. 20% of $41.33 is $8.27 a month, about $99.24 over a year (8.27 times 12).

Those amounts are small compared with a Part B penalty, but they last as long as you have a Part D plan. The medicare late enrollment penalty calculator lets you try your own numbers, and Medicare late enrollment penalties for Part B and Part D compares the Part B and Part D penalties.

Mistake 1: Tossing the creditable coverage notice

Each year before October 15, employers, unions and other drug plan sponsors that offer drug coverage to people eligible for Medicare must tell those people whether the coverage is creditable. The notice is easy to take for junk mail. It is also your proof.

How it happens: a person retires or leaves a job, joins Medicare, and gets a drug plan years later. A penalty letter asks whether they had creditable coverage during the gap. They cannot remember, and the former employer's notices are in a recycling bin.

What it costs: without a record, the plan may count the gap as uncovered months, and you must prove otherwise.

How to avoid it: keep every notice, and photograph or scan them. If you lack them, ask the former plan's benefits office for a written statement of the dates you were covered and whether the drug coverage was creditable. Ask for it before the plan asks.

Mistake 2: Assuming all drug coverage counts

Having some drug coverage is not the same as having creditable drug coverage. Creditable means the coverage is expected to pay, on average, at least as much as the standard Part D benefit. Many employer and retiree plans are creditable, but some are not, and the plan's own notice says which.

What does not automatically count: a discount card, a coupon program or a pharmacy savings club; a health care sharing ministry, which is not insurance; coverage that has a very small drug benefit; and a stand-alone or Advantage drug plan you dropped. Individual marketplace plans may or may not be creditable, so read the plan's notice instead of assuming.

How it happens: a person has a plan with a drug benefit, never reads the notice, and joins Medicare believing they are fine.

How to avoid it: look for the phrase "creditable" in the notice. If the notice says "not creditable," treat the coverage as not counting, and consider joining Part D during your Initial Enrollment Period even if you keep the other plan. If the notice is unclear, ask the sponsor in writing.

Mistake 3: Assuming VA or other government drug coverage needs no paperwork

Drug coverage through the VA is generally treated as creditable, and so is drug coverage through TRICARE, and many Federal Employees Health Benefits plans. Veterans and federal retirees often reasonably decide not to join Part D on that basis. The mistake is the paperwork, not the decision.

How it happens: the person assumes the government knows. Years later, when they do join a drug plan, the plan asks for the gap's dates and the person has no letter.

What it costs: the plan can record uncovered months, and you must explain them.

How to avoid it: keep a record, such as a notice from the plan or a statement of your VA enrollment, and check each year whether your coverage's status has changed. Health insurance for veterans: VA care, TRICARE and other coverage explains how VA care and Medicare relate. If you are unsure, a State Health Insurance Assistance Program counselor (SHIP) can help you read the notice.

Mistake 4: Letting a gap grow after job coverage ends

Job-based drug coverage is the most common creditable coverage for people who enroll in Medicare, and the biggest gap risk is the moment it ends.

How it happens: a person retires, or the employer ends the retiree plan, or the person leaves a job and goes without. The person is busy with other things, and the 63 days pass.

What it costs: every full month after the first 63 days uncovered is a month of penalty, with a total counted in months for as long as the gap lasts.

How to avoid it: when drug coverage is about to end, line up Part D before the last day. A special enrollment period generally opens when you lose creditable coverage, and Medicare.gov states how long it lasts. Do not wait for the first pharmacy bill.

Mistake 5: Choosing Medicare Advantage without drug coverage

A person who joins a Medicare Advantage plan that does not include drug coverage may have no Part D at all. In many Advantage plan types, adding a stand-alone drug plan can end the Advantage enrollment, and the rules vary by plan type, so check before assuming you can add one later. The plan's materials state which type it is. If no drug coverage comes with it, the 63-day clock runs. Medicare Part D explained: drug plans, formularies and costs describes how drug plans fit with the Parts A, B and C.

Mistake 6: Ignoring the penalty letter, or the plan's request for information

When a plan believes you have a gap, it will usually send a notice and ask you to say whether you had creditable coverage. The notice includes a deadline and a way to respond.

What it costs: if you do not answer, the plan may apply the penalty as it is calculated.

How to avoid it: respond in writing by the deadline in the letter. Include the dates and the name of the former plan, and any notice you kept.

Mistake 7: Misreading when the clock starts and stops

The gap that counts begins after your Initial Enrollment Period ends and ends on the day you start a Part D plan or other creditable coverage. Two misreadings are common. Some people count from their 65th birthday and ignore the seven-month window, which runs from three months before the birthday month to three months after it (Initial Enrollment Period). Others assume that the day they signed up is the day coverage began, when the plan's start date may be the first of the next month.

The first is easy to catch by looking at the dates on your plan's welcome letter. The second matters because each full uncovered month adds 1% to the penalty. If the plan says your coverage began on the first of a month, count whole months up to that date. If you disagree with the count, ask the plan which dates it used and compare them with your own records.

Three hypothetical people and their gaps

These people are invented, with round numbers, to show how the pieces combine. All use the 2027 base premium of $41.33.

Ana left a job at 65 with drug coverage that her employer's notice called creditable, joined Medicare, and signed up for a Part D plan that started the month her old coverage ended. She has no gap. She also kept the notice, so if the plan ever asks, she can answer in one email. Her penalty is $0.

Bill turned 65 covered by a retiree plan that had a drug benefit. He never read the notice, which said the coverage was not creditable. He joined Part D after 14 full months past his Initial Enrollment Period. That is 14% of $41.33, or about $5.79 a month (0.14 times 41.33 is 5.7862). Had he read the notice, he could have joined Part D during his Initial Enrollment Period and paid no penalty.

Carol used VA drug coverage and discarded the paperwork. Years later she joined a Part D plan because she wanted to use pharmacies outside the VA system. The plan asked about her gap. Because VA drug coverage is generally treated as creditable, she asks the VA for a written statement of her enrollment dates and sends it in. The result depends on that proof, which is why keeping records matters.

The differences between them are not about income or intelligence. They are about notices, dates and records.

How to dispute a penalty

The Part D plan notifies you of the penalty, and you have a right to ask for it to be reconsidered. The steps are the same in outline in each case.

  1. Read the letter. It states the number of uncovered months and the deadline to respond.
  2. Collect proof. Gather the notices, a statement from the former employer, union or plan, and enrollment records showing the dates of coverage.
  3. Respond to the plan. Say which months were covered, and send the proof. Keep copies.
  4. Ask for reconsideration if the plan rejects it. The notice explains how to request a review by an independent reviewer. The deadline is on the notice, so do not guess.
  5. Ask for help. A SHIP counselor can help you write the request.

If a mistake happened because someone gave you wrong advice, Wrong Medicare advice left me with a penalty. Can I get it fixed? explains a separate route. If you are asking whether Part D is worth it when you take no drugs, see Do I need Part D if I take no medicines? The penalty math and the decision.

A short checklist before you turn 65

  • Find the most recent creditable coverage notice for each plan that covers your drugs.
  • Mark the end date of each plan on a calendar.
  • Decide before that end date which Part D plan you will join.
  • Keep proof of coverage for your files, with dates.
  • Ask a SHIP counselor if any step is unclear.

Key takeaways

  • The Part D penalty is 1% of the national base beneficiary premium for each full uncovered month after a gap of 63 days or more; in 2027 that is about $0.41 per month ($41.33 base premium).
  • It is added to your plan premium for as long as you have Part D, and is recalculated each year.
  • Keep the annual creditable coverage notices, because they are your proof when a plan asks about a gap.
  • Not all drug coverage is creditable: discount cards, sharing ministries and some plans do not count, and VA, TRICARE and many employer plans usually do.
  • If you get a penalty letter, answer by the deadline, send proof, and ask for reconsideration if the plan does not accept it.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic