Blog

Worksheet: my total share of a planned surgery across five bills

A fill-in worksheet and worked example for adding up your share of a planned outpatient surgery across facility, surgeon, anesthesia, pathology and imaging.

A planned outpatient surgery rarely produces one bill. The surgery center or hospital bills for the room and supplies. The surgeon bills for the operation. An anesthesia group bills separately, a pathology lab may bill for tissue it examines, and the imaging done beforehand arrives as its own statement. Each one is a different company with its own network status, and each one is run through the same deductible and out-of-pocket maximum.

This worksheet adds them up before the surgery date so you know what to save, what to ask and what could change the total. It uses a repeatable method, shows one worked example with invented round numbers, and lists the calls that get you each figure. The example is a hypothetical, not anyone's prices.

What you need before you start

You will fill in these facts about your plan for the plan year in which the surgery will happen. Write them down first, because every line of the worksheet uses them.

  1. Deductible for the year and how much of it you have already met.
  2. Coinsurance percentage that applies after the deductible, or the copay for each type of service if your plan uses flat fees.
  3. Out-of-pocket maximum for the year and how much you have already counted toward it.
  4. Whether the plan requires prior authorization for this surgery, and whether it has been approved.

The member website and the explanation of benefits record show what has been met so far. The deductible and out-of-pocket tracker and the guide on how to track your deductible and out-of-pocket spending help keep that record. If you have an individual deductible and a family deductible, ask which applies to the person having surgery.

Prior authorization is worth checking first, because a plan can refuse to pay for a service that required it and did not get it. The guide on how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied explains the process, and the surgeon's office usually submits the request.

The six lines of the worksheet

Most planned outpatient surgeries produce some version of these charges. Your case may have more or fewer, so add rows.

Line Who bills What it covers
1. Facility Hospital outpatient department or surgery center Operating room, recovery, nursing, supplies, implants
2. Surgeon The surgeon's practice The operation, and often the follow-up visits for a set period
3. Anesthesia An anesthesia group The anesthesiologist or nurse anesthetist
4. Pathology A pathology lab Examining tissue removed during surgery
5. Imaging An imaging center or hospital radiology Scans before or during the procedure
6. Follow-up Surgeon or primary care Post-operative visits, physical therapy, supplies

The fifth bill is imaging in the title, and the sixth line is the follow-up care. Surgeons often include routine post-operative visits for a set period in the surgery fee, sometimes called a global fee, so a follow-up visit may add nothing. Ask the surgeon's office whether post-operative visits are included and for how long, because physical therapy, a boot or brace, and other follow-up services are usually separate.

For each line, collect five numbers

For every line, fill in these five items:

  1. Network status. Is this provider in network for your plan? Do not assume the facility's status applies to the surgeon, the anesthesiologist or the lab. The guide on how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network explains how to check and what to do if a directory is wrong.
  2. Allowed amount. The price your plan has agreed with that provider for that service. This is the number your share is calculated from.
  3. Deductible remaining at the point this bill is processed.
  4. Coinsurance or copay.
  5. Running total toward the out-of-pocket maximum.

The order in which claims are processed affects which line "uses up" the deductible, but it does not change the overall total, as long as every claim is processed against the same plan year.

How the arithmetic works

For each line, in order:

  • Your deductible part = the smaller of (the allowed amount) and (the deductible still remaining).
  • Your coinsurance part = coinsurance % × (the allowed amount minus the deductible part).
  • Your share for the line = deductible part + coinsurance part (plus any flat copay).
  • Update the deductible remaining: subtract the deductible part.
  • Running total = the previous running total + your share, but never above the out-of-pocket maximum. Once you hit the maximum, your share for later covered, in-network lines is $0 for the rest of the plan year.

The deductible, coinsurance and out-of-pocket maximum entries have the plain definitions. Premiums, non-covered services and out-of-network charges above the allowed amount do not count toward the maximum.

A worked example

Say Jordan has a plan with a $2,500 deductible, 20% coinsurance after it, and a $6,000 out-of-pocket maximum. Earlier in the year Jordan paid $500 toward the deductible, so $2,000 remains and $500 has been counted toward the maximum. All providers are in network. The allowed amounts, invented for the example, are:

  • Facility: $4,000
  • Surgeon: $2,200
  • Anesthesia: $800
  • Pathology: $300
  • Imaging (a pre-operative scan): $600

Processing the claims in that order:

Line Allowed Deductible left before Deductible part Coinsurance (20% of the rest) Jordan's share Deductible left after Running total toward maximum
Starting point $2,000 $500
1. Facility $4,000 $2,000 $2,000 $400 $2,400 $0 $2,900
2. Surgeon $2,200 $0 $0 $440 $440 $0 $3,340
3. Anesthesia $800 $0 $0 $160 $160 $0 $3,500
4. Pathology $300 $0 $0 $60 $60 $0 $3,560
5. Imaging $600 $0 $0 $120 $120 $0 $3,680
Total $7,900 $2,000 $3,180 $3,680

Check the math: the facility's coinsurance is 20% × ($4,000 − $2,000) = 20% × $2,000 = $400, so the share is $2,000 + $400 = $2,400. Each later line is simply 20% of its allowed amount: 0.20 × $2,200 = $440, 0.20 × $800 = $160, 0.20 × $300 = $60, 0.20 × $600 = $120. The shares add up to $2,400 + $440 + $160 + $60 + $120 = $3,180. The running total is $500 + $3,180 = $3,680, which is below the $6,000 maximum, so the maximum does not limit anything in this case. The plan pays the other $7,900 − $3,180 = $4,720.

Two variations on the same example

If the deductible were already met. With $0 of deductible remaining, every line is 20%: 0.20 × $7,900 = $1,580. The remaining deductible is why Jordan's real total is $1,600 higher ($3,180 − $1,580 = $1,600). On the $2,000 that went to the deductible, Jordan paid 100% instead of 20%, and 80% of $2,000 is $1,600.

If the maximum were lower. Say Jordan's out-of-pocket maximum were $3,500 instead of $6,000. The running total would reach $3,500 on line 3, because the share for anesthesia is exactly $160 and takes the total to $3,500. Lines 4 and 5 would then cost Jordan $0 in cost sharing. The total share would be $3,500 − $500 = $3,000 instead of $3,180. That is the cap at work, and why knowing the maximum matters as much as knowing the deductible.

Your blank worksheet

Copy this and fill it in as you collect the figures. Replace each blank with a number, and put "no" or "yes" in the network column.

Line In network? Allowed amount Deductible left before Deductible part Coinsurance % Coinsurance part Your share Running total toward maximum
Starting point ____ ____
1. Facility ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____
2. Surgeon ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____
3. Anesthesia ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____
4. Pathology ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____
5. Imaging ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____
6. Follow-up ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____ ____
Total ____ ____

If the running total reaches your out-of-pocket maximum, stop adding: write the maximum and put $0 for the lines after it.

The calls that get you each number

Numbers come from people, so make a short list of calls.

Your plan's member services. Ask for the deductible remaining, the out-of-pocket remaining, your coinsurance for outpatient surgery, whether the surgery needs prior authorization and whether it has been approved, and whether each provider by name is in network at the facility where the surgery will take place. Ask for a call reference number.

The surgeon's office. Ask for the billing codes for the planned procedure, which facility will be used, whether an assistant surgeon will be involved, whether post-operative visits are included, and the names of the anesthesia group and the pathology lab that normally work at that facility.

The facility's billing or estimates office. Ask for an estimate of the facility fee and what it includes, whether implants, devices and supplies are charged separately, and whether the facility is in network. The post on How I look up a hospital's prices before a procedure walks through price tools and what to say.

The anesthesia group and the lab. Ask whether they are in network with your plan, and what they typically bill. Federal surprise billing rules protect patients from many out-of-network bills from anesthesiologists and labs at in-network facilities, but the rules have limits and exceptions, and the surprise bill protection checker can help you check. If a provider hands you a form asking you to waive those protections, read the post on Should I sign the form that waives my surprise-billing protection? before signing.

The imaging center. Ask for the allowed amount for the scan under your plan, and whether the radiologist's reading is billed separately.

Write down who you spoke to, the date and what they said. Allowed amounts quoted by an office are estimates; the plan's cost estimator is a second source, and the two will not always match.

Checking the bills against the worksheet afterward

The worksheet is also the tool for checking what arrives later. Each provider's claim produces an explanation of benefits, and each shows the allowed amount, what the plan paid and what you owe. Lay the statements next to your filled-in rows and compare them line by line.

  • Allowed amount different from your row. Ask the plan why. A different billing code, a different site of service or a provider you assumed was in network are the usual causes.
  • Deductible applied in a different order. That is normal, and only the grand total matters. If the grand total is above your worksheet, find the line that differs.
  • A bill from a provider you did not list. An assistant surgeon, a second lab or an equipment supplier can add a line. Check whether the provider is in network and whether the surprise billing rules cover it.
  • A bill that arrives before its explanation of benefits. Wait for the explanation of benefits before paying, as long as the due date allows, and ask the provider to hold the account while the claim is processed.
  • A line you cannot recognize. Ask for an itemized bill and compare it with the surgeon's codes.

A mismatch is not proof of a mistake, but it is the signal to call the plan or the provider's billing office and ask. Many billing errors are corrected quickly when someone asks with the paperwork in hand, and the plan's appeals unit is the next step if a claim was processed under the wrong terms.

What can change the total

  • A different facility or setting. A hospital outpatient department and a free-standing surgery center can have different allowed amounts for the same operation.
  • A provider who is out of network. If a provider is out of network and not protected, the plan may pay less or nothing, and the provider may bill the difference.
  • Extra work during surgery. A surgeon who finds something unexpected may do more, and the codes and the bills change.
  • Complications and follow-up. An overnight stay, a return visit or a complication adds charges that the worksheet could not know.
  • Implants and devices. If the operation uses a device, ask whether it is billed separately.
  • The plan year. A deductible and an out-of-pocket maximum reset at the start of the plan year. A surgery in December and follow-up in January can fall into two years, each with its own deductible, as discussed in the post on The same hospital stay in March or December, what changes in what I pay?.
  • Prior authorization. A plan can deny payment when a required authorization was missed.

Planning to pay it

Once you have a total, compare it with what you can pay. If an HSA or an FSA is available, check the balance. If the total is more than you can manage at once, ask the facility and each provider about payment plans before the bills arrive, and ask the hospital about its financial assistance policy. A patient advocate or a navigator can help with the planning, and your plan's case management line sometimes can too. If a bill arrives that does not match the worksheet, compare it with the explanation of benefits before paying.

Key takeaways

  • A planned surgery usually produces separate bills from the facility, surgeon, anesthesia, pathology and imaging, and each has its own network status and allowed amount.
  • For each line, your share is the deductible still remaining (up to the allowed amount) plus coinsurance on the rest, and the running total stops at your out-of-pocket maximum.
  • In the worked example, allowed charges of $7,900 produce a $3,180 share for a person with $2,000 of deductible left and 20% coinsurance.
  • Confirm network status for every provider by name, ask about prior authorization and ask whether post-operative visits are included in the surgeon's fee.
  • Keep a note of every call, and ask a patient advocate or navigator for help if the numbers do not add up.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic