Blog

What should I ask a direct primary care practice before I sign up?

A grouped checklist of questions about fees, labs, access, contracts, closures, referrals, HSA fit and red flags, each with the reason to ask.

A direct primary care membership is a private contract between you and a practice, so the terms are whatever the practice's agreement says. There is no plan summary to compare and no regulator reviewing the wording the way a state reviews an insurance policy. That makes the questions you ask before signing more important than they would be with an insurance plan. This checklist groups them, and for each one explains why it matters, so you can ask them by phone, by email or at a free introductory visit.

First, what the arrangement is and is not. In Direct primary care membership, you pay a flat recurring fee for a defined set of primary care services. It is not insurance, and it does not replace a health plan for hospital stays, specialists, emergencies or most prescriptions. A comparison of the cost of pairing it with a high-deductible or catastrophic plan is in is direct primary care plus a catastrophic plan cheaper than a regular plan?. This post is about vetting a particular practice.

Ask for the answers in writing, or ask for the membership agreement and read it. A practice that is happy to explain its terms will usually be happy to send them.

How to use the list.

  1. Pick the questions that matter to you. Not all will, and a list of 40 will not get answered.
  2. Ask the same questions of two practices if you can, so you have something to compare.
  3. Put the answers beside your own needs. A family with young children needs different things than a retired person with a long medication list.
  4. Do not pay or sign until you have read the agreement and the cancellation terms.

Group 1: What the fee covers

  • What exactly is included in the monthly fee? Ask for a list: office visits, telehealth, home visits, routine procedures such as minor wound care, vaccinations, basic in-house tests. Why: practices differ widely, and "unlimited visits" can still exclude things you assumed were included.
  • Is there a visit limit, a fair-use policy or an extra charge for certain services? Why: some memberships are all-inclusive and some bill per procedure or per extended visit.
  • What does the fee cover for each person on a family membership? Ask whether the price changes with age, whether children are included and how adding a baby works. Why: pricing structures for families vary, and a family fee affects the HSA arithmetic described below.
  • Are there enrollment, registration or annual fees on top of the monthly fee? Why: a low monthly figure plus a large initial fee changes the real first-year price.
  • Can the fee rise, and with how much notice? Why: a contract that lets the practice raise the price at any time without notice is a risk you can price in.

Group 2: Labs, imaging and medications

  • Which lab tests and imaging are included, and which are billed separately? Why: this is where the total cost is often decided. A practice may bring in blood draws at no charge but send the specimen to a lab that bills you or your plan.
  • Which lab and imaging center do you use, and is it in my plan's network? Why: an in-network lab usually costs less if you are paying through your plan, and an out-of-network one can mean a large bill. The worksheet doctor, hospital and drug network check worksheet keeps track of what you have confirmed, and the guide how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network explains how to check.
  • Can I get lab work done at a lab of my choosing or with a transparent cash price? Why: some practices publish prices; some will give you an order for the lab you choose.
  • Does the practice dispense medications, and at what price? Why: some practices stock common generics at low prices, which can matter if you take them every day. Others do not dispense at all. Ask whether the prices apply to your specific medications.
  • Who orders refills and how fast? Why: a delay in a refill can leave you without a needed medication, and a clear process prevents that.

Group 3: Access and after-hours care

  • How do I reach the doctor, and how fast do you answer? Ask about text, phone, portal and email. Why: easy contact is the main promise of the model, so test it. You might send a question during the introductory process and see how long it takes to get an answer.
  • What happens after hours, on weekends and when the doctor is on vacation? Why: a membership that promises access but has no coverage plan for nights and holidays may send you to urgent care and the ER anyway.
  • Who sees me if my doctor is away? Why: a practice with one clinician has a gap, and a practice with a covering arrangement closes it.
  • What is the typical wait for a same-day or next-day visit? Why: ask for a realistic answer, not the best case.
  • Do you do telehealth visits, and are they included? Why: telehealth can make routine access much easier and is a common feature of these memberships.

Group 4: Panel size and continuity

  • How many members does each doctor have? Why: smaller panels are a selling point, and the number tells you what to expect. Practices often say what their target panel size is; ask whether it is the current number or an aim.
  • Is the practice accepting new members, and is there a waitlist or a cap? Why: a closed panel can force you to leave if your household changes.
  • What happens if my doctor leaves, retires or changes practices? Why: a membership with one doctor is a relationship with one person. Ask whether another clinician will take over, whether you may transfer records and whether fees are refunded.
  • How long has the practice been open? Why: a brand-new practice has no track record, which is not disqualifying but is a risk to weigh.

Group 5: Contract, billing, cancellation and closure terms

  • What is the term and how do I cancel? Ask whether it is month to month or an annual commitment, how much notice is required and whether cancellation is by email or in writing. Why: the exit terms are where members get surprised.
  • Is there a refund for unused months if I cancel or if I move? Why: annual prepayments can be hard to recover.
  • What happens if I miss a payment? Why: some practices pause service quickly, and some give a grace period.
  • How is the fee billed, and is there an auto-renewal? Why: renewals that happen without a reminder can add up.
  • What do I receive that I can use for taxes or reimbursement? Why: you may want an itemized statement. Ask for one.

If the practice closes

  • What happens to my records, and how do I get a copy? Why: you have the right to your medical records, and a practice that closes needs a plan for them. Ask where the records are kept and how you would request them.
  • What happens to prepaid fees if the practice closes? Why: a prepaid annual fee for a practice that shuts is a loss unless the agreement says otherwise.
  • Is there a plan to transfer members to another practice? Why: continuity of care matters, especially if you have a chronic condition.

Group 6: Referrals and specialists

  • How do you handle referrals to specialists, and do you have relationships with specialists that offer lower cash prices? Why: the practice does not run your insurance, so referrals follow your plan's network rules. Some practices negotiate cash prices with specialists and imaging centers, which can help if you have a high deductible.
  • Who handles prior authorization for specialist or hospital care? Why: if you have an insurance plan with a referral or approval requirement, the practice may or may not help with the paperwork. Ask.
  • How are specialists billed, and does the DPC doctor coordinate my care when I am admitted to a hospital? Why: a primary care doctor who follows you through a hospital stay is valuable, but a DPC doctor may not have admitting privileges. Ask what the practice does.
  • Do I still need my insurance plan's primary care physician designation? Why: some plans, notably HMOs, require you to name an in-network primary care physician to cover referrals. A DPC doctor outside the network may not satisfy that requirement.

Group 7: HSA and your health plan

As of November 2026, a recent law says a direct primary care arrangement does not disqualify you from an HSA if the fees are at most $150 a month, or $300 a month for more than one person, for months beginning after December 31, 2025. IRS guidance for 2027 states the same $150 and $300 amounts. Because the rules are new and depend on what the arrangement includes, ask:

  • Does your membership qualify as a direct primary care service arrangement under the HSA rules, and have members used it with an HSA? Why: a practice's answer is not tax advice, but it should know the basic rule and should not promise a tax result.
  • What is the fee for the household I would be enrolling, and is it within the $150 and $300 monthly limits? Why: a fee above the limit can affect HSA eligibility, so you want the price in view before you decide. A tax professional is the person to confirm.
  • Can I pay the fee with my HSA? Why: eligibility to contribute is one question and paying the fee tax-free from the account is another; ask a tax professional before assuming either.
  • Does your practice work with high-deductible plans, and have you seen the arrangement alongside the plan I am considering? Why: your plan must still be an HSA-eligible high-deductible plan to contribute. The guides How a health savings account (HSA) works: limits and tax benefits and High-deductible health plans (HDHPs) explained: pros and cons cover those rules.

Group 8: Does the practice bill insurance?

  • Do you bill insurance for anything, or is everything under the membership? Why: some practices bill insurance for services outside the membership, and some do not accept insurance at all. The answer affects whether your visits and tests count toward your deductible.
  • If I pay cash for a service, will you give me a receipt I can submit to my plan? Why: a plan may or may not count it toward your deductible; ask your plan.
  • Are you in my plan's network for anything outside the membership? Why: a clinic can be outside the network for billed visits even if it is convenient.

Red flags

Any of these is a reason to slow down and ask more:

  • Promises that the membership replaces health insurance, or language implying it is insurance.
  • Pressure to sign or pay right away, or "limited-time" pricing.
  • Refusal to share the membership agreement or fee schedule before you pay.
  • Claims of guaranteed savings or tax results.
  • No written cancellation or refund terms.
  • A clinician whose license you cannot find in your state's medical board lookup.
  • No clear plan for emergencies, nights or the doctor's absence.
  • Vague or evasive answers about what happens to records or prepaid fees.

A one-page score sheet

Question Practice A Practice B
Monthly fee for my household
Enrollment or other fees
Labs and imaging included?
In-network lab?
After-hours coverage
Panel size
Cancellation terms
Records and prepaid fees if it closes
HSA fit confirmed with a tax professional?

Fill it in as you call. The comparison usually makes the choice clearer than any single answer.

To raise cost with any clinician once you are a member, the post What can I say to my doctor to lower the cost of a test or treatment? has word-for-word questions.

Key takeaways

  • A direct primary care agreement is a contract, so get the fee, inclusions and cancellation terms in writing before you pay.
  • Labs, imaging, medications and specialists are where the real cost sits, so ask what is included and what is billed separately.
  • Ask what happens to your records and prepaid fees if the doctor leaves or the practice closes.
  • As of November 2026, an arrangement within $150 a month ($300 for more than one person) does not block HSA eligibility, but a tax professional should confirm your situation.
  • Treat promises of replacing insurance, guaranteed savings or pressure to sign as red flags.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic