Blog

Does the month I schedule surgery change what I pay under my plan?

Four hypothetical patients show, with exact arithmetic, how plan-year resets, the out-of-pocket maximum and a plan change can alter what one surgery costs.

Yes, sometimes, and by thousands of dollars. Your deductible and out-of-pocket maximum count up from zero at the start of each plan year, so a surgery that falls late in a year where you have already paid a lot can cost much less than the same surgery just after the reset. It can also cost about the same, and in some cases the later date is cheaper. Which one you get depends on how much you have already paid this year, how much care you expect next year and whether your plan or network changes on January 1.

This post works through four invented patients using one set of plan terms, so you can see the mechanics and then run your own numbers. Medical need comes first. If a surgeon says a condition should not wait, the date is a medical decision and the arithmetic below is not a reason to delay it. Everything here applies only to surgery that is planned and that your surgeon says can reasonably be scheduled either way.

The plan terms used in every scenario

All four patients start from the same hypothetical numbers. They are round illustrations and not any real plan:

  • Deductible: $2,000
  • Coinsurance after the deductible: 20% for the patient, 80% for the plan
  • Out-of-pocket maximum: $5,000 per plan year, in-network, and the deductible counts toward it
  • The surgery, with every bill included (surgeon, facility, anesthesia): an allowed amount of $20,000, all in-network

The formula for a surgery in a given year is the smaller of two figures: the deductible still owed plus 20% of the rest, or the out-of-pocket maximum still unused. The out-of-pocket maximum is the stopping point. Once your payments for covered in-network care reach it, the plan pays 100% of covered in-network costs for the rest of that plan year. Premiums, services the plan does not cover and out-of-network balance bills do not count toward it.

Charges are assigned to a plan year by date of service. A bill that arrives in February for a December operation belongs to the December plan year.

Scenario 1: Avery, deductible already met

Say Avery had a long fall of physical therapy and imaging and has already paid exactly $2,000 toward the plan's limit this year. The deductible is met. A surgery date is offered in December and another in early January.

December surgery. Avery owes 20% of $20,000, which is $4,000, but only $3,000 remains under the $5,000 limit ($5,000 - $2,000). So Avery pays $3,000. The year's total of covered cost sharing is $2,000 + $3,000 = $5,000.

January surgery, new plan year, same terms. The deductible and limit reset. Avery pays the $2,000 deductible, then 20% of the remaining $18,000, which is $3,600. That is $5,600, which exceeds the limit, so the cost is capped at $5,000.

Looked at over two plan years, December means Avery pays $5,000 this year and nothing toward the surgery next year. January means $2,000 this year and $5,000 next year. That is $5,000 versus $7,000, a $2,000 difference in December's favor.

Next year's other care changes the answer. In the December case, next year's deductible is still ahead for any other care. In the January case, the surgery uses up next year's limit, so other care that year is free. Say Avery has an amount of other care in the second year, measured at the plan's allowed prices:

  • $1,500 of other care: December costs $5,000 + $1,500 = $6,500. January costs $7,000. December wins by $500.
  • $4,000 of other care: December costs $5,000 + ($2,000 deductible + 20% of the remaining $2,000, which is $400) = $7,400. January costs $7,000. January wins by $400.
  • The break-even is $2,000 of other next-year care. Above that, January is cheaper; below it, December is.

The lesson: a big procedure in a year where you have already paid a lot uses up an almost-spent limit. Whether that is a bargain depends on what the following year looks like.

Scenario 2: Ben, deductible barely started

Say Ben has paid only $300 this year, mostly for a couple of visits. There are $4,700 left under the limit.

December surgery. The deductible still owed is $1,700, and 20% of the remaining $18,300 is $3,660, so the formula gives $1,700 + $3,660 = $5,360. That is more than the $4,700 left, so Ben pays $4,700, and the year totals $5,000.

January surgery. As in Scenario 1, the figure is capped at $5,000.

Over two plan years, December costs Ben $5,000 in total. January costs $300 this year and $5,000 next year, $5,300. The difference is the $300 he already paid. December saves $300, and only if next year's other care is less than $300 at the plan's allowed prices. If he expects more, January is as cheap or cheaper.

The lesson for people who will hit the limit either way: the saving is about how many yearly limits the surgery consumes, not about the deductible. If you will reach the maximum whichever year it falls in, the difference is only what you have already paid toward this year's limit. A bigger saving arises when you have already paid most of the limit.

Scenario 3: Cara, a plan year that does not start in January

Say Cara has an employer plan whose plan year runs July 1 to June 30. As of mid-June she has paid $1,000 toward the deductible this plan year, with $4,000 left under the limit.

Surgery on June 20. The deductible still owed is $1,000 and 20% of the remaining $19,000 is $3,800, giving $4,800. The $4,000 left is smaller, so Cara pays $4,000.

Surgery on July 8, in the new plan year: $2,000 + 20% of $18,000 ($3,600) = $5,600, capped at $5,000.

Cara's saving by going in June is $1,000, which is what she had already paid, and it shrinks or disappears if she expects more than $1,000 of other care in the next plan year, by the same logic as above.

The point for readers is that the reset date is your plan's renewal date, not January 1. Many employer plans renew on other dates, and a December deadline does nothing for you if your year ends in June. Your summary of benefits and your HR office state the plan year. Employers can also change deductibles, copays and networks at renewal, so ask what changes before assuming the new year looks like this one.

Scenario 4: Dev, a plan change at open enrollment

This is the case with the most risk. Say Dev has the plan above, has paid $500 so far this year, and is choosing a different plan for next year because its premium is $100 a month lower. The new plan's terms are a $3,000 deductible, 30% coinsurance and a $7,000 out-of-pocket maximum. Dev's surgeon is in network on both plans in the first calculation.

December surgery on the current plan. The deductible still owed is $1,500. 20% of the remaining $18,500 is $3,700, giving $5,200. The limit left is $4,500 ($5,000 - $500), so Dev pays $4,500.

January surgery on the new plan. The deductible is $3,000. 30% of the remaining $17,000 is $5,100. That gives $8,100, capped at the new limit of $7,000.

The surgery costs Dev $2,500 more on the new plan ($7,000 - $4,500). The premium saving is $100 x 12 = $1,200 over the year. So in a year with this surgery, the new plan comes out about $1,300 more expensive ($2,500 - $1,200), ignoring any other care. In a year without surgery the cheaper premium might win. That is the trade-off a plan comparison is designed to show.

Three other things change when a plan changes:

  1. The network may differ. If the surgeon or hospital is out of network on the new plan, the cost is not covered by the calculation above. Out-of-network care can have a separate, higher deductible, a separate limit, and balance billing that may not count toward your limit at all. Check the directory and confirm with the surgeon's office that they accept the specific new plan, not just the insurer's name.
  2. Prior authorization restarts. Approval from the old plan does not carry over, and a new plan's approval can take days or weeks. If you schedule for early January, start the new request as soon as the new plan's member ID is issued, and ask the surgeon's office what the plan needs.
  3. The deductible does not transfer. Money you paid toward the old deductible does not count toward the new plan's. For the planned-surgery case, the post I know I'm having surgery next year. Should I buy gold instead of silver? looks at how to choose a metal level when you know the operation is coming.

What these scenarios leave out

  • Care before and after the operation. Pre-operative testing, the surgery, follow-up visits and physical therapy each have their own dates of service. A December 28 operation followed by therapy in January splits the cost across two plan years. Ask the surgeon's office for a list of what is expected and when.
  • How a hospital stay that crosses New Year's Day is assigned. Plans differ. Some assign the whole inpatient stay to the admission date, others split by date. Ask the plan before relying on a late-December admission. The post The same hospital stay in March or December, what changes in what I pay? walks through a stay across the plan year.
  • Family deductibles. In a family plan, whether the deductible is embedded per person or shared across the family changes what counts as met.
  • Prior authorization timing and surgeon availability. The dates you can get are not always the dates you would choose, and approval can take time. The guide to how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied describes the process.
  • Facility and anesthesia bills. Confirm that the facility and the anesthesia group are in network, since they bill separately from the surgeon.
  • Your own risk of delay. A condition that worsens or a surgery that is postponed can cost more in health and in money than any deductible saving.

Run your own numbers

  1. From your latest explanation of benefits or your plan's online account, find how much you have paid toward the deductible and the out-of-pocket maximum so far this plan year. The deductible and out-of-pocket tracker can keep that total, and how to track your deductible and out-of-pocket spending explains how.
  2. Ask the surgeon's billing office for an estimate of the allowed amounts for each piece (surgeon, facility, anesthesia, pathology) at your plan.
  3. Compute the cost this year: the smaller of (deductible remaining + coinsurance on the rest) and (maximum remaining).
  4. Compute the cost on the new date: the same formula on a fresh plan year, or on the new plan's terms.
  5. Estimate the other care you will need in the second year and add it to the later date.
  6. Ask your plan's member line to confirm the dates you propose and the prior authorization lead time.

If the numbers are close, choose the date that suits your recovery and your calendar. If they differ by thousands of dollars, the advice of the surgeon's office on timing and a plan counselor or broker on the plan comparison are worth a phone call.

Key takeaways

  • Plan-year totals reset on the plan's renewal date, which is not always January 1, and charges are assigned by date of service.
  • A surgery that hits your out-of-pocket maximum costs only what remains of the limit, so having already paid much of it can save you thousands.
  • A later date can be cheaper if you expect substantial other care in the next year, so compare both years together.
  • A plan change at open enrollment can change the deductible, coinsurance, limit, network and prior authorization all at once.
  • Medical need and the surgeon's advice come before the calendar, and the plan and the surgeon's billing office can confirm your actual numbers.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic