Blog

My plan has tiers of doctors and hospitals, so how do tiers change what I pay?

How tiered and high-performance networks work, how tiers change copays and coinsurance, how they are assigned, and one knee surgery priced at two tiers.

The summary of benefits lists a hospital as "Tier 1" and another as "Tier 2", and the cost-sharing table has a column for each. Both hospitals are in the plan's network, and both are covered, yet the same operation at one of them can cost you thousands of dollars more than at the other. A tiered network is a network inside the network: the insurer sorts its in-network providers into groups and charges you less for the group it prefers.

This post explains how tiers work, how providers land in them, what the dollar difference looks like in an example with invented numbers, and what to check before you choose a doctor or hospital in a tiered plan. Plans use different names and designs, so the plan's own documents decide the details.

What a tiered network is

In an ordinary network, every in-network provider has the same cost-sharing terms for you. In a tiered network, in-network providers are placed in two or more tiers, and the cost sharing depends on the tier. Common labels are "preferred" and "standard", "Tier 1" and "Tier 2", or "high-performance" and "regular". A plan marketed with a "high-performance network" or "centers of excellence" for certain procedures is using the same idea: a group of providers the plan has designated for lower cost sharing.

Tiers can apply to doctors, to hospitals or to both. Some plans tier only hospitals, since a facility's price is a large part of a bill. Others tier physicians by specialty. The tier may change your copay, your coinsurance percentage, your deductible or all three.

Tiering is not the same as a formulary tier for drugs. Drug tiers sort medications by type and price; provider tiers sort doctors and hospitals. A plan can have both, and the words "tier 1" mean different things in each. Do not assume that a "Tier 1" hospital and a "Tier 1" drug refer to the same level of cost.

How a tier changes what you pay

Tiers usually work through cost sharing. A few common patterns:

  • A lower copay for the preferred tier. A specialist visit costs a flat amount for Tier 1 and a higher flat amount for Tier 2.
  • A lower coinsurance percentage. For hospital care, the plan pays 90% at Tier 1 and 75% at Tier 2, for instance.
  • A separate deductible for the lower tier. Less common, but some plans apply a smaller deductible to preferred providers.
  • Both. The preferred tier can combine lower copays and coinsurance.

Tiers do not change whether care is covered. Both tiers are in network, so the plan covers the service and the provider cannot balance bill beyond your tier's cost sharing. The difference is the share of the allowed amount that falls on you. And the allowed amount itself may differ, because the plan has a different negotiated rate with each provider, so a more expensive hospital can raise both your percentage and the base it applies to.

How providers get into a tier

Plans assign tiers using criteria they set, and the criteria are usually some mix of cost and quality. The cost side compares what a provider's contracted rates and typical episode of care cost the plan with what comparable providers cost. The quality side may use measures such as complication rates, readmission rates, adherence to clinical guidelines or national quality ratings, though the available quality data are uneven, especially for individual physicians.

Supporters of tiering say it gives members a clear reason to choose efficient providers, which can hold down premiums and push hospitals to compete on price and results. Critics say the rankings can reflect price more than quality, that small sample sizes make physician-level quality measures unreliable, and that tiers can steer patients away from a provider they trust to one that happens to have a lower contract price. Both concerns are plausible, and the answer depends on the specific plan and how it builds its tiers.

Assignments can change. Plans typically review tiers at least annually, and a provider's tier can move up or down at renewal. A hospital in Tier 1 this year may be in Tier 2 next year after a contract negotiation. The plan should publish its criteria or describe them to members on request, and you are entitled to ask. A provider's own billing office often knows the tier, since patients ask.

The same knee surgery at two tiers

Take a hypothetical member, Rosa, who needs an arthroscopic knee surgery. Her plan has a $2,000 deductible, a $9,000 out-of-pocket maximum and these hospital cost-sharing terms (invented for the illustration): coinsurance of 10% at Tier 1 and 25% at Tier 2.

The plan's contracted allowed amount for the entire episode, including the facility, is $20,000 at the Tier 1 hospital and $26,000 at the Tier 2 hospital. Say Rosa has not yet paid anything toward her deductible this year.

At the Tier 1 hospital:

  • Deductible: $2,000
  • Remaining allowed amount: $20,000 − $2,000 = $18,000
  • Coinsurance: 10% × $18,000 = $1,800
  • Rosa pays $2,000 + $1,800 = $3,800

At the Tier 2 hospital:

  • Deductible: $2,000
  • Remaining allowed amount: $26,000 − $2,000 = $24,000
  • Coinsurance: 25% × $24,000 = $6,000
  • Rosa pays $2,000 + $6,000 = $8,000

Both totals are below the $9,000 out-of-pocket maximum, so the cap does not help. The same operation costs Rosa $8,000 − $3,800 = $4,200 more at the Tier 2 hospital. The plan, by contrast, pays $16,200 at Tier 1 and $18,000 at Tier 2, so the insurer's cost is also higher at the Tier 2 hospital, which is how the insurer justifies the design.

The example is simplified. A real episode has several bills: the facility, the surgeon, the anesthesiologist, imaging and follow-up therapy. Each may sit in its own tier. A surgeon at a Tier 1 facility may be Tier 2 as an individual, and the anesthesia group may be in neither. It is worth asking for each.

A second example: copays across a year of visits

Tiers also show up in flat copays. Say Rosa's plan charges a $30 copay for a Tier 1 physical therapist and $60 for a Tier 2 therapist, and her surgeon prescribes 12 sessions after the knee surgery.

  • Tier 1: 12 × $30 = $360
  • Tier 2: 12 × $60 = $720
  • Difference: $720 − $360 = $360

The gap is smaller than the surgery's, but it recurs with every visit. If the Tier 2 therapist is five minutes from her home and the Tier 1 clinic is 40 minutes away, Rosa may reasonably decide the $360 is worth paying, or she may decide that she will drive. The tier makes the price visible; it does not make the decision.

One more point is easy to miss. If a provider's tier is higher than another's, the allowed amount for the same service may differ even where the copay is the same, and that matters when a deductible applies, since the plan's recognized price comes out of your pocket until the deductible is met. Compare the allowed amounts for your plan, when the plan or the provider's office will quote them, as well as the percentages.

When the cheaper tier is not the right choice

A lower tier is not automatically the better pick, and a higher tier is not automatically a mistake. A few situations where the choice is not obvious:

  • Continuity of care. If you are halfway through treatment with a Tier 2 provider, the extra cost of staying may be worth it, and some plans have a transition period for members in active treatment.
  • Specialized skill. A hospital that handles a rare procedure often may be in Tier 2 because of its cost structure. Ask the surgeon how many such operations the team performs and what the outcomes are, and balance that against the tier.
  • Distance and access. A Tier 1 hospital two hours away adds travel, lodging and time off work, which a coinsurance percentage does not show.
  • Emergencies. If you are taken to a hospital in an emergency, you generally cannot choose the tier. Plans often treat emergency care at a fixed cost-sharing level or at the preferred tier regardless of the hospital, but this varies, so read the emergency row of the summary of benefits.

The tier is one input. Your surgeon's recommendation about where an operation is best done, the hospital's record and your own circumstances belong in the decision too, and the plan's own case management or nurse line can help with the trade-offs.

What to check before you choose a doctor or hospital

A tiered plan puts more weight on a decision you make before care: which provider to use. These steps help.

  1. Find the tier list. The plan's online directory should show a tier for each provider, or the summary of benefits and coverage may list how the tiers work. How to read a Summary of Benefits and Coverage explains how to read the cost-sharing table.
  2. Look up each provider separately. The facility, the surgeon, the anesthesiologist and the lab can have different tiers.
  3. Call the plan and confirm. Ask: "What is this provider's tier for [procedure] under my plan, and what is my cost sharing at that tier?" Record the date and the person's name. how to check whether a doctor or hospital is in your network describes how to verify network status, and a tier check is the same kind of call.
  4. Ask the provider's office. The billing office should know which plans it works with and how it is classified, and it can give an estimate of the allowed amount for your plan.
  5. Ask whether a facility fee applies. Hospital-owned clinics can bill a facility fee in addition to the doctor's fee, and the tier may apply to one and not the other.
  6. Track the spending. Tiered cost sharing still counts toward the deductible and out-of-pocket maximum, and a tracker such as the deductible and out-of-pocket tracker helps you see how close you are. what is an out-of-pocket maximum and what counts toward it? explains what counts toward the cap.

Tiers in employer plans

Tiered and high-performance networks are common in employer plans, where an employer may adopt a tiered design to hold down costs or to steer employees toward certain providers. In some employer plans a "center of excellence" is a requirement for a particular procedure, in which case using a different hospital may reduce or eliminate coverage. The benefits office can say how the employer's plan is built, and the plan document controls. how employer health insurance works: premiums, plan choices and rules describes how employer plans are put together.

If you believe a provider has been put in the wrong tier, or you cannot get the information you need, ask the plan about its process for reviewing a tier assignment. For a complaint about misleading information, the plan's grievance process and the state insurance department, or, for a self-funded employer plan, the U.S. Department of Labor's benefits agency, are the places to take it.

Key takeaways

  • A tiered network sorts in-network providers into groups and charges less for the preferred group; both tiers are covered, and the tier changes your copay, coinsurance or deductible.
  • Tiers are assigned using cost and quality criteria that the plan sets and can change at renewal, and supporters and critics disagree about how well they track quality.
  • In the illustration, the same knee surgery cost $3,800 at a Tier 1 hospital and $8,000 at a Tier 2 hospital, a $4,200 difference, because both the coinsurance percentage and the allowed amount were higher.
  • Check each provider's tier separately, since the facility, surgeon and anesthesia group can differ, and confirm the tier with the plan before scheduling.
  • A lower tier is a cost signal, not a verdict; continuity of care, specialized skill, distance and emergencies can all change the right answer.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Related guides

Latest on this topic