Blog
I turned 65 on a marketplace plan: what happens to my credit and when to cancel
Seven mistakes people make when moving from a subsidized marketplace plan to Medicare at 65, what each can cost, and a sequence for ending the plan safely.
A marketplace plan and Medicare are built on different calendars, different rules and different agencies, and neither one reminds you of the other. A person who has a subsidized marketplace plan at 64 and turns 65 is the person most likely to fall between them. Nothing automatically cancels the marketplace plan, nothing automatically signs up a person who is not collecting Social Security, and the penalty for missing a Medicare deadline lasts for as long as you have Medicare.
This post is organized as a list of mistakes: how each one happens, what it can cost and how to avoid it. It ends with a sequence for ending the marketplace plan. The dollar figures in the examples are invented, except where a published Medicare figure is cited with its year. The person who answers your individual question is a SHIP counselor (the State Health Insurance Assistance Program offers free, unbiased Medicare counseling; see SHIP), Social Security or the marketplace.
The background in four sentences
Medicare's Initial Enrollment Period is seven months: the three months before the month you turn 65, the birthday month and the three months after. Premium-free Part A is available to most people who have worked about ten years (40 quarters) in jobs covered by Medicare, and most people pay $0 for it; for 2026 the monthly Part A premium for people with fewer quarters is $311 with 30 to 39 quarters and $565 with fewer than 30, according to CMS. Marketplace credits are meant for people who do not have other qualifying coverage, and Medicare Part A is treated as qualifying coverage. Individual marketplace insurance is not the kind of coverage that lets you delay Part B without a penalty.
Mistake 1: Assuming the credit continues until you cancel
How it happens. You have a marketplace plan that comes with an advance credit, paid monthly to the insurer. When you become entitled to premium-free Part A, you generally stop being eligible for the credit. But the advance credit does not stop on its own. The marketplace does not necessarily know you have Medicare. The credit keeps being paid to your insurer until you update your application or end the plan.
What it costs. The credits paid for months in which you were not eligible are excess credits, and they must be repaid when you file your return. Starting with tax year 2026, all excess advance premium tax credit must be repaid in full regardless of income, under Public Law 119-21 as summarized by KFF. Say a $400 monthly credit keeps flowing for five months after you become ineligible. That is $400 times five, which is $2,000 to repay on your return, plus the confusion of reconciling the months. See the repayment guide.
How to avoid it. Tell the marketplace the date Medicare Part A begins, and end the marketplace plan or the credit as of that date. Do not wait for it to notice.
A note on what "eligible" means. The rule that matters is eligibility for premium-free Part A. If you would have to pay a premium for Part A because you have too few work quarters, you can generally keep a marketplace plan and its credits, and you are not forced to take Medicare. That is a decision to make with your SHIP counselor, since delaying Part B has its own consequences. How the marketplace treats someone who is eligible for premium-free Part A but has not yet enrolled depends on details that the marketplace or Social Security should confirm for your situation, not a general post.
Mistake 2: Treating a marketplace plan as a reason to delay Part B
How it happens. Many people with a job and a group health plan can delay Part B without penalty because their employer coverage counts for a special enrollment period. People assume the same is true for a marketplace plan. It is not. Individual marketplace coverage does not qualify you for the special enrollment period that employer coverage based on current work provides.
What it costs. The Part B late enrollment penalty is 10% for each full 12 months you could have enrolled and did not, according to Medicare. It is added to your premium for as long as you have Part B. A worked illustration with the published figure for 2026: the standard Part B premium is $202.90 a month. If you wait 24 months past the end of your Initial Enrollment Period, that is two full 12-month periods, so 20% of $202.90, which is $40.58 a month. The 2027 premium has not been announced as of November 2026, and the amount of the penalty tracks the premium. Over years, the extra adds up. A person who delays and then has a health event can also face a gap: after the Initial Enrollment Period, Part B signup is limited to the General Enrollment Period, January 1 to March 31, with coverage starting the month after sign-up.
How to avoid it. If you do not have employer coverage based on current work, plan to enroll in Part B during the Initial Enrollment Period. See the late penalties guide and the initial enrollment period guide.
Mistake 3: Cancelling the marketplace plan before Medicare is active
How it happens. You want to do the right thing, so on the day you sign up for Medicare you cancel the marketplace plan. But Medicare may not start for weeks or months. Under the current rule, when you sign up in the month you turn 65 or in the three months after, coverage starts the first of the month after you sign up. If you sign up before your birthday month, coverage starts the first of the birthday month. People born on the first of a month have their coverage start a month earlier, as covered in Why does Medicare start a month early if my birthday is on the first?.
What it costs. A gap. If you cancel in March and Medicare starts May 1, you are uninsured for April, and a medical event in April is yours to pay.
How to avoid it. Get the start dates of Part A and Part B confirmed in writing before you ask the marketplace to end the plan, and choose an end date that lines up, which is the day before Medicare begins. The initial enrollment calculator helps you place the dates, and If I sign up for Medicare in a given month, when does coverage start? shows the start date for each sign-up month.
Mistake 4: Staying on the marketplace plan once Medicare has started
How it happens. You like your plan, the doctor is in the network, and nothing seems urgent. You pay the premium without the credit, or you keep the credit by mistake.
What it costs. Aside from the credit repayment in Mistake 1, there is a more basic problem. Federal rules generally make it illegal for someone to knowingly sell a marketplace plan to a person who has Medicare Part A and Part B, and the marketplace expects you to end the plan when Medicare begins. A person with both parts who keeps paying for a marketplace plan is also paying for coverage that duplicates, and does not coordinate well with, Medicare. Whether you can keep a marketplace plan while enrolled only in Part A (for example if you are still working) is a nuanced question for the marketplace or a counselor.
How to avoid it. Treat the Medicare start date as the end date of the marketplace plan, unless a counselor has confirmed a specific reason to keep it.
Mistake 5: Ignoring the drug coverage question
How it happens. Your marketplace plan included prescription drug coverage, so you think that Part D is not needed. When the marketplace plan ends, so does that drug coverage.
What it costs. Medicare Part D has its own late enrollment penalty: 1% of the national base beneficiary premium for each full month without creditable drug coverage, according to Medicare, which is about $0.41 a month in 2027 by arithmetic on the published base premium of $41.33, and is added for as long as you have Part D. Whether your marketplace plan's drug coverage was "creditable," meaning at least as good as standard Medicare drug coverage on average, is something the insurer can tell you in a notice. If it was not creditable, months with only that coverage can count toward a penalty.
How to avoid it. Choose a Part D plan or a Medicare Advantage plan with drug coverage, timed so it begins when Medicare does, and ask your insurer for its creditable coverage notice. The guide to health insurance after 65 gives the overall map.
Mistake 6: Missing the Medigap window
How it happens. Original Medicare pays a share of costs and leaves gaps, and many people fill them with Medigap. Medigap has a one-time six-month open enrollment window that starts the first month you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B, during which the insurer cannot turn you down or charge more because of your health. After the window, insurers in most states can use medical underwriting. A person focused on ending the marketplace plan may not notice the Part B date that starts this clock.
What it costs. A person with a health condition who misses the window may be refused a policy or charged more. See medigap open enrollment period for the definition.
How to avoid it. Note the Part B start date and compare Medigap and Medicare Advantage before the window closes. Neither is a recommendation here: the choice between them is contested, and each suits different people. Your SHIP counselor can compare them for free.
Mistake 7: Forgetting the rest of the household
How it happens. You move to Medicare, but a younger spouse stays on a marketplace plan that was priced using your shared household income and sometimes your family size.
What it costs. Your leaving the household's marketplace plan can change the spouse's credit, because the calculation depends on household income and who is covered. If the application is not updated, the advance credit may no longer match the truth, and the difference is settled on the tax return. The post I'm on Medicare and my husband is 58, so how does his marketplace plan work? looks at the household math.
How to avoid it. Update the application with your new status when you end your plan. Ask the marketplace how the spouse's credit changes.
A sequence for ending the marketplace plan
This ordering protects against all seven mistakes. The details of the dates depend on your birthday.
- About six months before your 65th birthday, note your Initial Enrollment Period dates and check your work record or Social Security account for quarters worked. If you receive Social Security benefits, you may be enrolled in Parts A and B automatically; if not, you sign up yourself.
- Decide how you will cover Part B, Part D and any supplement. Talk to a SHIP counselor. Ask specifically what happens to your marketplace credit when Part A starts.
- Choose your Medicare start date by choosing when to sign up within the Initial Enrollment Period. Remember the rule: signing up before your birthday month starts coverage the first of the birthday month.
- Sign up for Part A and Part B with Social Security, and choose your Part D or Medicare Advantage plan and any Medigap policy so they begin on the same date.
- Get the start dates in writing from Social Security or your Medicare account.
- Ask the marketplace to end the plan the day before Medicare begins, and ask for the end date in writing. Do not cancel until step 5 is complete.
- Update the application for anyone who stays on the marketplace plan.
- Keep the paperwork and check your Form 1095-A when it arrives to confirm the plan's end month.
As a worked example with invented dates, say Rosa turns 65 on July 20, 2027 and signs up for Medicare in April 2027. Because she signs up before her birthday month, coverage starts July 1, 2027. She asks the marketplace to end her plan June 30. If she had cancelled in April, she would have been uninsured for May and June.
Who to ask
Free, individual help is available from a SHIP counselor for Medicare choices, from Social Security for enrollment and start dates, and from the marketplace for credits and ending the plan. A tax professional can answer how any months of overlap will show up on your return. This post cannot tell you what you are eligible for.
Key takeaways
- The advance credit does not stop on its own when Medicare begins, so tell the marketplace the date Part A starts or you may repay credits in full at tax time.
- A marketplace plan does not let you delay Part B without a penalty, which is 10% of the premium for each full 12 months you could have enrolled and lasts as long as you have Part B.
- Confirm Medicare's start dates in writing before ending the marketplace plan, then end it the day before to avoid a gap.
- Line up Part D and a Medigap or Medicare Advantage decision with the Medicare start date, because the Medigap window and the drug penalty both run on clocks.
- A SHIP counselor, Social Security and the marketplace answer the individual questions; a tax professional handles the return.