Blog
What can I buy with my HSA or FSA? Everyday items sorted by yes, maybe, no
A three-way sort of drugstore and everyday purchases for HSA and FSA money, with the reason behind each call and what happens if you pay for the wrong thing.
Say a drugstore receipt shows eight items: a $15 prescription copay, $12 allergy tablets, $9 sunscreen, $8 menstrual products, $5 bandages, $14 vitamins, $7 shampoo and $4 toothpaste. The total is $74. Sorted the way most plans sort it, $49 is a clear yes (15 plus 12 plus 9 plus 8 plus 5), the $14 of vitamins is a maybe, and the $11 of shampoo and toothpaste is a no. The sorting rules below explain why, and what to do when a purchase falls between the lines.
One rule sits above all the others. The federal tax code defines what counts as medical care, but each plan decides how to administer it. An FSA has an eligible-expense list kept by the plan administrator, and an HSA custodian usually publishes a similar list. When the list and a general article like this one disagree, the plan's list governs for an FSA, and for an HSA the tax rules govern but the custodian's list is the sensible starting point.
How the two accounts differ at the register
Both accounts pay for qualified medical expenses: the diagnosis, treatment, mitigation or prevention of disease, and the services and supplies that go with those. They differ in how they treat the same purchase.
| Question | HSA | Health FSA |
|---|---|---|
| Who decides what is eligible | The tax code; you are responsible for staying inside it | The tax code, applied through the plan's eligible-expense list |
| Does the account check each purchase | Usually not; the account holder keeps the records | Yes; the administrator requires proof of the expense |
| When the expense must occur | Any time after the account was set up | During the plan year, with carryover or a grace period if the employer offers one |
| Can it pay insurance premiums | Only a few kinds (see below) | No |
| If you pay for something ineligible | The amount is income and, before 65, generally carries a 20% additional tax | The administrator asks you to repay, offsets it against other claims, or the amount can be treated as taxable pay |
The guide FSA vs HSA: the differences in eligibility, limits and rollover has the full comparison. The point for a shopper is that the HSA gives you more freedom and more responsibility, and the FSA gives you a safety net and a paperwork request.
Column one: clear yes
These are purchases that are medical care under the tax rules and that nearly every eligible-expense list accepts. The reason is stated beside each one.
- Copayments, coinsurance and deductible payments for a doctor, hospital, urgent care or telehealth visit. They are the patient's share of medical care, which is the original purpose of both accounts.
- Prescription drugs with a pharmacy label in your name. A prescribed drug is medical care by definition.
- Over-the-counter medicines without a prescription, such as pain relievers, allergy tablets, cold and cough products and antacids. Since a 2020 law change, these no longer need a prescription to be reimbursable.
- Menstrual care products, including pads, tampons and cups. The same 2020 law made them eligible.
- First aid supplies, such as bandages, gauze, thermometers and blood pressure monitors, because they treat or measure a medical condition.
- Eyeglasses, prescription sunglasses, contact lenses and contact lens solution, as well as eye exams. Correcting vision is medical care.
- Dental treatment, including exams, cleanings, fillings, extractions, dentures and braces for a dental condition.
- Hearing aids and their batteries, which treat a hearing impairment.
- Mental health counseling and substance use treatment, from a licensed provider.
- Sunscreen with a broad-spectrum label. Lists generally accept it, though a few administrators ask for a rating on the label; check the plan list.
A simple test for a yes: would a doctor recognize the purchase as something that treats, prevents or measures a condition?
Column two: maybe
A maybe is an item that is medical only for the person who needs it for a specific diagnosis. The administrator may ask for a letter of medical necessity, a short note from a clinician that names the condition, says why the item treats it and states the period it covers.
- Vitamins and supplements. General-health vitamins are not eligible. A vitamin recommended for a diagnosed deficiency may be, with a letter. In the example receipt above, the $14 of vitamins would be a no without a clinician's note and a yes with one.
- Weight-loss programs. A program for obesity, hypertension or another diagnosed condition can qualify; a program for general fitness does not.
- Special foods. Gluten-free food for a person with celiac disease can qualify, but only the amount by which it costs more than the ordinary version of the same food.
- Massage therapy. Generally eligible only when it treats a diagnosed condition, rather than relaxation.
- Orthopedic shoes, compression stockings and similar supports. Eligible when prescribed for a condition, and sometimes only the extra cost over ordinary versions.
- Air purifiers, humidifiers and similar equipment for a condition such as severe asthma. Eligible only with the clinician's letter, and sometimes only part of the cost.
- Acupuncture, chiropractic care and similar services. Many lists accept them, others ask for a diagnosis. The administrator can tell you.
- Smoking-cessation programs and drugs. Often accepted; ask for the administrator's current list.
A letter of medical necessity is not a promise. The administrator decides whether the letter is enough, and the answer can differ between plans. Asking before you buy is cheaper than asking after.
Column three: no
These are generally not eligible, because they are for general wellness, comfort or appearance rather than treating a condition.
- Gym dues and general fitness programs. Staying healthy in general is not treating a diagnosed illness.
- Cosmetic items and procedures, such as teeth whitening, cosmetic surgery without a medical reason, hair removal and anti-aging products.
- Toiletries and everyday personal care, such as shampoo, toothpaste, deodorant and ordinary toothbrushes.
- Baby items, such as diapers and formula, unless the clinician has prescribed a specific medical formula for a condition (and then it is a maybe).
- General-health vitamins and herbal products, as above.
- Sunglasses without a prescription. Non-prescription reading glasses are a related case that many lists accept, so the line can be confusing; check before you buy either.
- Expenses of someone who is not you, your spouse or your tax dependent, such as a parent you do not claim, an unmarried partner, or a friend.
- Funeral expenses, and other costs that are not medical care.
Insurance premiums: where the two accounts differ most
A health FSA cannot pay insurance premiums at all. The money is for out-of-pocket costs, not for the cost of the coverage.
An HSA also cannot pay ordinary health insurance premiums, but the tax code makes a few exceptions:
- COBRA continuation coverage premiums. After a job loss, the premium for COBRA continuation coverage can be paid from an HSA tax-free.
- Premiums for health coverage while receiving unemployment compensation.
- Qualified long-term care insurance premiums, up to an age-based yearly limit. See long-term care insurance.
- Medicare premiums, such as Medicare Part B and a Part D or Medicare Advantage premium, for someone 65 or older, but not Medigap premiums.
That list is why someone who has just lost a job and kept an HSA can use it to pay a COBRA bill, and why an FSA holder in the same position cannot.
What to do before you pay
When a purchase falls between the lines, three steps save most of the trouble.
- Check the plan's list first. The administrator's website has a searchable list for FSAs, and a custodian page for HSAs. Search for the exact product type, not a brand.
- Ask for a letter if the item is a maybe. A clinician's note usually takes a day or two. Keep a copy.
- Keep the itemized receipt, which shows the merchant, the date, the item and the amount. A card slip that shows only a total is not enough for an FSA and is weak evidence for an HSA.
The post Is this plan HSA-eligible? A checklist to verify before you enroll is about the plan side of HSA eligibility, and Why was my FSA card declined or flagged, and what do I send to fix it? covers what a request for documentation looks like and how to answer it.
What happens if you pay for something ineligible
For an FSA, an ineligible purchase usually surfaces as a request for documentation. If you cannot show the expense was eligible, you may be asked to repay the amount, or the administrator may offset it against another claim you submit, and if neither happens the amount can end up counted as taxable pay. The rules are the plan's, and the benefits office can explain the order in which it applies them.
For an HSA, nobody asks for the receipt when you spend the money. The consequence arrives at tax time. The ineligible amount is included in income, and if you are under 65 and are not disabled, a 20% additional tax generally applies. At 65 or older, the amount is taxed as ordinary income without the 20% add-on. If you pay for an ineligible item by mistake, tell the custodian right away. Some custodians have a way to return a mistaken distribution, and the tax rules about correcting one have conditions, so a tax professional is the person to ask. The sibling post Can I pay medical bills out of pocket and reimburse myself from my HSA later? explains the record-keeping that makes an audit uneventful.
The FSA election planner and the guide FSA use-it-or-lose-it rules, carryover and grace periods help with the other risk, which is having FSA money left at the end of the plan year and spending it hurriedly on items that turn out to be ineligible.
Mixed carts and other edge cases
Real shopping trips mix categories, and a few situations come up repeatedly.
- A mixed receipt. At a pharmacy or big-box store, the card or the account should be charged only for the eligible items. Ask the cashier to split the payment, or pay for the eligible items first. With an FSA card, a mixed basket at a store that cannot identify eligible items is a common reason a charge is flagged.
- Two accounts, one expense. The same dollar cannot be paid twice. If an insurer paid part of a bill, only your share is eligible, and the explanation of benefits shows what that share is. Keep the statement with the receipt.
- A dependent care FSA is a separate account. It pays for child or adult day care so that you can work, not medical items, and none of the lists above apply to it.
- Prepaying. An FSA reimburses expenses incurred during the plan year, which generally means the date of service or purchase, not the date you paid a deposit for something later.
A shopping-day checklist
Before you go to the register:
- Is the item a medicine, a medical supply, a medical service or a correction for vision, hearing or teeth?
- Is it listed on the plan's current eligible-expense page?
- If it is a maybe, do you have the clinician's letter?
- Are you paying with the right account, so the HSA is not charged for an FSA expense or the reverse?
- Will you get an itemized receipt?
- Is the purchase for you, your spouse or your tax dependent?
- Have you already claimed it somewhere else, such as an insurance claim or a tax deduction?
Key takeaways
- The plan's own eligible-expense list governs an FSA; for an HSA the tax rules govern, and the custodian's list is a guide.
- Prescriptions, copays, over-the-counter medicines without a prescription, menstrual products, glasses, contacts and most dental and vision costs are clear yes items.
- A maybe needs a diagnosis and often a clinician's letter of medical necessity; ask before you buy.
- Gym dues, cosmetic items, toiletries and general-health vitamins are generally no.
- An FSA cannot pay premiums; an HSA can pay only a few kinds, including COBRA, qualified long-term care and some Medicare premiums but not Medigap.
- An ineligible FSA purchase leads to a repayment request, and an ineligible HSA purchase leads to income tax and, before 65, a 20% additional tax.