Medicaid managed care organizations

CareSource: plans, ratings and contacts

Nonprofit Ohio-based Medicaid plan with dual-eligible and marketplace plans; it leaves the Indiana, Ohio and West Virginia marketplaces after 2026.

Also known as CareSource Marketplace, CareSource MyCare Ohio, Common Ground Healthcare Cooperative

SizeMore than 2 million (company statement, April 2025)
Where it sellsMedicaid in Ohio, Kentucky, Indiana, Georgia and West Virginia; marketplace plans in Georgia, Nevada and Wisconsin for 2027 (Indiana, Ohio and West Virginia end after 2026); dual-eligible plans in Ohio and, through Commonwealth Care Alliance, Massachusetts

Contact

New members and sales 1-844-539-1733 (marketplace enrollment and general line)
Website caresource.com
Shop or enroll caresource.com/marketplace
Headquarters address 230 N. Main St., Dayton, OH 45402

Company

Headquarters Dayton, Ohio
Founded 1989
Ownership Nonprofit

Where and what

Where it sells Medicaid in Ohio, Kentucky, Indiana, Georgia and West Virginia; marketplace plans in Georgia, Nevada and Wisconsin for 2027 (Indiana, Ohio and West Virginia end after 2026); dual-eligible plans in Ohio and, through Commonwealth Care Alliance, Massachusetts
Plan types Medicaid managed care, ACA marketplace plans, dual-eligible special needs plans, TRICARE Prime demonstration
Network types HMO

Size

Members More than 2 million (company statement, April 2025)

Ratings

Medicare star rating 4.5 stars, CareSource Ohio D-SNP, 2026 Star Ratings (CMS, announced October 2025)

Fit

Best suited to People who qualify for Medicaid, or for both Medicare and Medicaid, in a state where CareSource holds a contract, and marketplace shoppers in the few states where it still sells.

Plans and products

  • Medicaid managed care
  • ACA marketplace plans
  • dual-eligible special needs plans

Brands and plan names

  • CareSource Marketplace
  • CareSource MyCare Ohio
  • CareSource Medicare Advantage
  • Common Ground Healthcare Cooperative
  • Commonwealth Care Alliance

CareSource is a nonprofit managed care organization based in Dayton, Ohio. Most of what it does is run Medicaid, the joint federal and state program for people with low incomes, under contracts with state governments. It also sells coverage for people who have both Medicare and Medicaid, and, in a shrinking number of states, ACA marketplace plans. By its own count it serves more than 2 million members.

Overview

A managed care organization is an insurer that a state pays a fixed monthly amount to arrange and pay for care for each Medicaid enrollee (see managed care organization). CareSource describes itself as a national nonprofit and says it runs one of the largest Medicaid managed care plans in the country. As of April 2025 the company said it had more than 2 million members in 13 states and about 4,700 employees. The company's own pages do not list those states; the ones this profile names are the ones a source confirmed.

History

The company says it was founded in 1989. Wikipedia traces it to Dayton Area Health Plan, which became the first mandatory Medicaid managed care program in the country, and says the plans were consolidated under the CareSource name in 2000. The same article describes the later steps: a Kentucky Medicaid partnership with Humana in 2012, MyCare Ohio (which combines Medicare and Medicaid benefits for eligible adults) in 2014, and Medicaid contracts in Indiana and Georgia around 2016 along with West Virginia.

Two 2025 deals widened its reach. In January 2025 CareSource took control of Common Ground Healthcare Cooperative, a Wisconsin nonprofit that sold individual-market plans in 24 counties, after the Wisconsin insurance commissioner approved the affiliation. Then on April 9, 2025 it completed an acquisition of Commonwealth Care Alliance, a Massachusetts plan for about 50,000 people who have both Medicare and Medicaid; the company said CCA keeps its name and about 1,600 CCA employees became CareSource employees.

Plans and products

  • Medicaid. The core business. Coverage rules, benefits and networks differ by state, because each state sets them in its contract. See medicaid managed care explained: plans, networks and appeals.
  • Dual-eligible plans. CareSource sells dual-eligible special needs plans, Medicare Advantage plans for people enrolled in both programs (see dual-eligible special needs plan), and in Ohio the MyCare Ohio program. In Massachusetts it supports Commonwealth Care Alliance's Senior Care Options and One Care plans.
  • Marketplace. Its marketplace page lists Gold, Silver and Bronze plans, some HSA-eligible, and names Georgia, Nevada and Wisconsin. The Wisconsin plans come from the Common Ground deal.
  • Military. The company's about page lists a TRICARE Prime demonstration plan, CareSource Military & Veterans.

Where it sells

For Medicaid, sources confirm Ohio, Kentucky, Indiana, Georgia and West Virginia. For the marketplace, CareSource will stop selling marketplace plans in Indiana, Ohio and West Virginia after December 31, 2026, according to a healthinsurance.org summary of a company notice dated May 15, 2026. A news report on Ohio says about 28,300 Ohioans had CareSource marketplace coverage as of May 2026 and about 60,000 were affected in Indiana. The company called the Ohio exit a strategic decision driven by rising health care costs and ongoing shifts in the marketplace, and said its Ohio Medicaid and MyCare Ohio plans are not affected. The same healthinsurance.org article says CareSource will remain in Georgia, Nevada and Wisconsin for 2027. For plan year 2027, open enrollment in Ohio runs November 1, 2026 to January 15, 2027; people losing a plan should follow what to do if your insurer leaves the marketplace in your area.

Ratings and reputation

CMS announced in October 2025 that CareSource Ohio's dual-eligible plan, with more than 8,400 members, earned 4.5 stars out of 5 in the 2026 Medicare Star Ratings, according to the company's press release. The same release says the Commonwealth Care Alliance plan in Massachusetts earned 4 stars. Star Ratings are a federal quality measure for Medicare plans and update every year. NCQA, a nonprofit quality accreditor, publishes health plan ratings by state on its report card; check it for current CareSource scores. This profile found no AM Best financial-strength rating for the company.

Enrolling and member service

Medicaid enrollment goes through the state, not CareSource: you apply to your state Medicaid agency and may then choose or be assigned to a plan (see How to apply for Medicaid: documents, timeline and what happens next). Marketplace plans are bought through the state or federal marketplace, including Georgia through Georgia Access, and Nevada through its state exchange. CareSource's marketplace enrollment and general line is 1-844-539-1733 (TTY 711). Member services is open Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m., and provider services Monday through Friday, 8 a.m. to 6 p.m., according to the company's contact page; the numbers for each Medicaid state are on the member pages there. Complaints about a plan can go to the plan first and then to the state insurance department or Medicaid agency, such as the Ohio Department of Insurance, which handles Ohio marketplace plans.

Who it suits

  • Strengths: Focused on government-funded coverage and on people with both Medicare and Medicaid; nonprofit; a 4.5-star CMS rating for its Ohio dual plan in the 2026 ratings.
  • Weaknesses: Its marketplace footprint is shrinking, with three states ending after 2026; most products are available only to people who qualify for a government program in a specific state.

How to contact

Service Number or URL
Marketplace enrollment and general line 1-844-539-1733 (TTY 711)
Headquarters, Dayton, Ohio 937-224-3300
Atlanta office 678-214-7500
Indianapolis office 317-982-6400
Frankfort office 502-213-4700
Charleston office 681-319-9500
Website https://www.caresource.com

Sources

  1. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CareSource
  2. caresource.com/about-us/
  3. caresource.com/about-us/contact-us/
  4. caresource.com/marketplace/
  5. caresource.com/newsroom/press-releases/caresource-common-ground-healthcare-cooperative-a…
  6. caresource.com/newsroom/press-releases/caresource-completes-acquisition-of-commonwealth-…
  7. caresource.com/newsroom/press-releases/caresource-ohio-achieves-4-5-star-quality-rating-…
  8. insurancenewsnet.com/oarticle/caresource-molina-to-drop-aca-marketplace-plans-in-ohio-in…
  9. healthinsurance.org/blog/health-insurers-are-exiting-the-marketplace-again-should-consum…

Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.

Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026

Compare with similar companies

Terms to know

Related guides

Related states

Mentioned in