Tools

ICHRA vs group plan cost calculator

Compares yearly employer and employee cost under a group health plan and an ICHRA, now called a CHOICE Arrangement, with every input editable.

Runs entirely in your browser: nothing you enter is sent or stored by this site. Results are estimates for planning, not a quote or advice.

How to use it

  1. Enter how many employees you would offer it to. This only scales the employer totals.
  2. Under "Group plan", enter the total monthly premium for one employee, what the employee pays toward it, and the employee's expected out-of-pocket costs for the year.
  3. Under "ICHRA / CHOICE Arrangement", enter the monthly allowance you would give, any administration fee, the monthly premium of the individual plan the employee would buy, and that plan's expected out-of-pocket costs.
  4. Optionally enter household income for the affordability comparison.

The starting values are averages and stand-ins: change them to your renewal quote and real marketplace prices.

In September 2026 CMS began calling the ICHRA a CHOICE Arrangement. It described no change to the underlying rules: an employer of any size with at least one W-2 employee sets a monthly allowance that employees use to buy their own coverage.

How the math works

For one employee and one year, employee-only coverage:

  • Employer cost, group plan = (premium − employee contribution) × 12.
  • Employer cost, ICHRA = (allowance + administration fee) × 12.
  • Employee cost, group plan = employee contribution × 12 + out-of-pocket costs.
  • Employee cost, ICHRA = (individual premium − allowance, not below zero) × 12 + out-of-pocket costs. If the allowance is more than the premium, the unused part reduces the out-of-pocket costs, since reimbursement can cover qualified expenses.

Example with the starting values: a group premium of $817 a month (KFF's 2026 average single premium of $9,804 divided by 12), the employee paying $139 (KFF's $1,672 divided by 12), and $1,955 of out-of-pocket costs (the KFF average deductible, used as a stand-in). An allowance of $678 matches what the employer pays now, and the individual plan costs $703 (the KFF 2027 national average benchmark premium for a 40-year-old, before any credit).

  • Employer: $8,136 a year either way, or $203,400 for 25 employees.
  • Employee, group plan: $1,668 + $1,955 = $3,623.
  • Employee, ICHRA: ($703 − $678) × 12 = $300, plus $1,955 = $2,255, which is $1,368 less.

The tool also shows the allowance that costs the employer the same ($678, less any fee) and the allowance that keeps the employee's premium bill unchanged ($703 − $139 = $564).

What it assumes

  • Employee-only coverage. For family coverage, type family figures in every box. The KFF 2026 family premium averages $28,303 a year.
  • One allowance for everyone. Rules allow some variation by age or family size, which this tool does not model.
  • The same out-of-pocket costs under both designs unless you change them. Individual silver plans often carry different deductibles, so that stand-in is the weakest number here.
  • No taxes. Employer contributions are generally deductible and reimbursements for premiums and qualified expenses generally tax-free under both designs, so the tool leaves them out.

Where it stops being right

  • It compares dollars, not coverage. A group plan and an individual plan can have different networks, drugs and benefits, which the tool cannot see.
  • The affordability line compares the employee's premium after the allowance with the 10.22% the IRS sets for employer coverage in 2027. How an ICHRA offer counts for affordability and how it interacts with a marketplace premium credit are not verified on this site. Ask a benefits adviser, the IRS or the marketplace.
  • Employer eligibility, notice requirements and class rules are outside the tool.
  • Plan prices change each year, and marketplace premiums depend on age and county.

Reference figures: CMS, CHOICE Arrangements; KFF, 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Related guides

Terms used here

Latest on this topic