ICHRA vs group plan cost calculator
Compares yearly employer and employee cost under a group health plan and an ICHRA, now called a CHOICE Arrangement, with every input editable.
Runs entirely in your browser: nothing you enter is sent or stored by this site. Results are estimates for planning, not a quote or advice.
How to use it
- Enter how many employees you would offer it to. This only scales the employer totals.
- Under "Group plan", enter the total monthly premium for one employee, what the employee pays toward it, and the employee's expected out-of-pocket costs for the year.
- Under "ICHRA / CHOICE Arrangement", enter the monthly allowance you would give, any administration fee, the monthly premium of the individual plan the employee would buy, and that plan's expected out-of-pocket costs.
- Optionally enter household income for the affordability comparison.
The starting values are averages and stand-ins: change them to your renewal quote and real marketplace prices.
In September 2026 CMS began calling the ICHRA a CHOICE Arrangement. It described no change to the underlying rules: an employer of any size with at least one W-2 employee sets a monthly allowance that employees use to buy their own coverage.
How the math works
For one employee and one year, employee-only coverage:
- Employer cost, group plan = (premium − employee contribution) × 12.
- Employer cost, ICHRA = (allowance + administration fee) × 12.
- Employee cost, group plan = employee contribution × 12 + out-of-pocket costs.
- Employee cost, ICHRA = (individual premium − allowance, not below zero) × 12 + out-of-pocket costs. If the allowance is more than the premium, the unused part reduces the out-of-pocket costs, since reimbursement can cover qualified expenses.
Example with the starting values: a group premium of $817 a month (KFF's 2026 average single premium of $9,804 divided by 12), the employee paying $139 (KFF's $1,672 divided by 12), and $1,955 of out-of-pocket costs (the KFF average deductible, used as a stand-in). An allowance of $678 matches what the employer pays now, and the individual plan costs $703 (the KFF 2027 national average benchmark premium for a 40-year-old, before any credit).
- Employer: $8,136 a year either way, or $203,400 for 25 employees.
- Employee, group plan: $1,668 + $1,955 = $3,623.
- Employee, ICHRA: ($703 − $678) × 12 = $300, plus $1,955 = $2,255, which is $1,368 less.
The tool also shows the allowance that costs the employer the same ($678, less any fee) and the allowance that keeps the employee's premium bill unchanged ($703 − $139 = $564).
What it assumes
- Employee-only coverage. For family coverage, type family figures in every box. The KFF 2026 family premium averages $28,303 a year.
- One allowance for everyone. Rules allow some variation by age or family size, which this tool does not model.
- The same out-of-pocket costs under both designs unless you change them. Individual silver plans often carry different deductibles, so that stand-in is the weakest number here.
- No taxes. Employer contributions are generally deductible and reimbursements for premiums and qualified expenses generally tax-free under both designs, so the tool leaves them out.
Where it stops being right
- It compares dollars, not coverage. A group plan and an individual plan can have different networks, drugs and benefits, which the tool cannot see.
- The affordability line compares the employee's premium after the allowance with the 10.22% the IRS sets for employer coverage in 2027. How an ICHRA offer counts for affordability and how it interacts with a marketplace premium credit are not verified on this site. Ask a benefits adviser, the IRS or the marketplace.
- Employer eligibility, notice requirements and class rules are outside the tool.
- Plan prices change each year, and marketplace premiums depend on age and county.
Reference figures: CMS, CHOICE Arrangements; KFF, 2026 Employer Health Benefits Survey.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026