Tools

Short-term plan vs ACA plan comparison

Compares the premium a short-term plan saves with what you could owe in a bad year, and lists the structural differences from an ACA marketplace plan.

Runs entirely in your browser: nothing you enter is sent or stored by this site. Results are estimates for planning, not a quote or advice.

How to use it

  1. Enter the short-term plan from its quote: monthly premium, deductible, coinsurance, out-of-pocket maximum (0 if the quote lists none) and the most the plan will pay in total (0 if there is none).
  2. If some of your care might fall under an exclusion, such as a condition you already have, enter the share a short-term plan might not cover.
  3. Enter the ACA plan: monthly premium after any premium tax credit, deductible, coinsurance and out-of-pocket maximum.
  4. Set three sample years of care. The tool shows the total cost of each plan in each year and a table of differences.

How the math works

For each plan the cost of a year is twelve premiums plus what you pay for care. For the short-term plan, the excluded share is paid entirely by you. On the covered share you pay the deductible, then coinsurance, capped at the out-of-pocket maximum if there is one. If what the plan pays would exceed its policy maximum, you pay the rest. The ACA plan uses the same deductible, coinsurance and maximum logic without exclusions or a policy maximum.

Worked example with the starting numbers, which are illustrations. Short-term: $180 a month, $5,000 deductible, 40% coinsurance, no out-of-pocket maximum, $250,000 policy maximum. ACA: $420, $4,500, 20%, $9,000.

  • A year with no care: short-term $2,160, ACA $5,040.
  • $5,000 of allowed charges: short-term $2,160 + $5,000 = $7,160; ACA $5,040 + $4,500 + $100 = $9,640.
  • $300,000: short-term $2,160 + $5,000 + 40% of $295,000 = $125,160; ACA $5,040 + $9,000 = $14,040.
  • If the whole $300,000 were excluded, the short-term plan would cost $302,160.

These were checked by hand and by script.

What it assumes

  • You enter both plans from real quotes. The defaults are illustrations only.
  • ACA-compliant plans cannot set an out-of-pocket maximum above $12,000 for one person in 2027 (CMS 2027 premium adjustment percentage guidance); the tool notes when your ACA entry is higher.
  • Allowed charges are the same on both plans.

Where it stops being right

  • The tool does not know whether a short-term insurer would accept you, which conditions it would exclude, or what the policy's fine print says. The policy, the insurer and your state insurance regulator can tell you.
  • The table of differences is general: rules on how long short-term plans can last, whether they renew and whether they can be sold differ by state and have changed in recent years. The tool states no duration.
  • Premium tax credits apply only to marketplace plans. The tool does not estimate your credit; HealthCare.gov or your state marketplace does.
  • Dollar figures show exposure, not likelihood. A short-term plan can be the cheaper choice in a year with little care; the tool shows what the bad year would look like.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026

Related guides

Terms used here

Latest on this topic