Compare
AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcare vs Mutual of Omaha
Two large Medigap sellers: AARP-branded plans from UnitedHealthcare, and a policyholder-owned Nebraska insurer that also sells dental and other add-ons.
Verdict
Both companies sell Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policies, which pay part of what Original Medicare leaves to the patient, such as deductibles and coinsurance. Neither has a provider network: a policyholder can see any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare. Because Medigap benefits are standardized by plan letter, the letter matters more than the brand when comparing benefits, while price, rating method and service differ by company and state.
The main differences are structural. The AARP program is sold by UnitedHealthcare under a licence from AARP, requires AARP membership, and is the largest Medigap book by enrollment. Mutual of Omaha is owned by its policyholders, also sells dental, hospital indemnity and other add-on coverage, and ranks second in Medigap enrollment. Neither profile names a winner for every buyer; the right choice depends on state availability, plan letter and the quote you receive.
Choose AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcare if
- You are already an AARP member, or are willing to join, since membership is required.
- You want a Medigap plan from a large national insurer owned by UnitedHealth Group.
- You want a letter plan such as A, B, G, K, L or N, or C or F if you first became eligible for Medicare before 2020.
- You live in Massachusetts, Minnesota or Wisconsin and want the state-specific standardized plans the company lists.
- You are comfortable with the licensing arrangement in which UnitedHealthcare pays royalties to AARP, which the profile notes has drawn lawsuits and scrutiny.
Choose Mutual of Omaha if
- You prefer a policyholder-owned (mutual) insurer; its profile reports an AM Best rating of A+ (Superior) as of April 2026.
- You want a Medigap plan and may also want dental, hospital indemnity or similar add-on coverage from the same company.
- You are looking at a plan letter from the company's list of A, C, D, F, G, M and N, including high-deductible Plan G or Plan F.
- You do not want to join a membership organization to buy.
Both profiles ask buyers to confirm availability by ZIP code, with a licensed agent or on Medicare.gov, because neither lists a verified state roster.
Key differences
| Topic | AARP Medicare Supplement (UnitedHealthcare) | Mutual of Omaha |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | Owned by UnitedHealth Group, marketed under licence from AARP | Policyholder-owned mutual; Mutual of Omaha Holding Company since April 1, 2026 |
| Membership | AARP membership required | Not stated as required |
| Medigap enrollment | 4.27 million members, 29.7% of the market (December 2025) | About 1.3 million members, 9.4% (December 2025) |
| Plan letters named | A, B, G, K, L, N; C and F for those first eligible before 2020 | A, C, D, F, G, M, N; C and F for those first eligible before 2020 |
| State-specific plans | Massachusetts, Minnesota, Wisconsin | Massachusetts, Minnesota, Wisconsin |
| Other products | Medigap only in this profile | Dental, hospital indemnity, life, annuities and more |
| Financial rating | No AM Best rating found for the branded policies | A+ (Superior), AM Best, April 2026 |
| Networks | None; any provider accepting Medicare | None; any provider accepting Medicare |
| Guaranteed acceptance | Six-month open enrollment period and some other situations | Six-month open enrollment period; two periods for people under 65 |
See Medigap explained: Medicare Supplement plans A through N for what each letter does, and use your state's SHIP counselor for free comparison help.
Side by side
| AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcare | Mutual of Omaha | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Medigap and senior market carriers | Medigap and senior market carriers |
| Member services | — | 800-775-6000 |
| New members and sales | 1-833-591-5020 (apply by phone; TTY 711) | 888-981-5642 |
| Website | aarpmedicareplans.com | mutualofomaha.com |
| Headquarters | Minnetonka, Minnesota | Omaha, Nebraska |
| Founded | — | 1909 |
| Ownership | Owned by UnitedHealth Group (NYSE: UNH); marketed under licence from AARP | Mutual insurance company (policyholder-owned); since April 1, 2026 organized under Mutual of Omaha Holding Company |
| Parent company | UnitedHealth Group | Mutual of Omaha Holding Company |
| Stock ticker | UNH | — |
| Where it sells | Plans offered depend on where you live; the company says not all plans are available in all states | Medicare Supplement plans in most states; plans and policy forms vary by state |
| Plan types | Medicare Supplement (Medigap) Plans A, B, G, K, L and N, plus C and F for people first eligible for Medicare before 2020; state-specific plans in Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin | Medicare Supplement (Medigap), hospital indemnity, dental, critical illness, cancer, heart attack and stroke coverage, long-term care, group dental and vision, life insurance and annuities |
| Members | 4.27 million Medigap members, 29.7% of the market (December 2025, Mark Farrah Associates) | About 1.3 million Medigap members, 9.4% of the market (December 2025, Mark Farrah Associates) |
| AM Best financial strength | — | A+ (Superior) |
| Best suited to | People on Original Medicare who are AARP members and want a standardized Medigap plan from a large national insurer. | People on Original Medicare who want a standardized Medigap plan from a mutual insurer, and people shopping for add-on benefits such as dental or hospital indemnity. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026