Medigap and senior market carriers

Mutual of Omaha: plans, ratings and contacts

Policyholder-owned Nebraska insurer best known for Medicare Supplement; also sells dental, hospital indemnity and other supplemental coverage.

Also known as Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company, Omaha Supplemental Insurance Company, United of Omaha, Companion Life

SizeAbout 1.3 million Medigap members, 9.4% of the market (December 2025, Mark Farrah Associates)
Where it sellsMedicare Supplement plans in most states; plans and policy forms vary by state
AM Best ratingA+ (Superior)
Member services800-775-6000

Contact

Member services 800-775-6000
New members and sales 888-981-5642
Website mutualofomaha.com

Company

Legal name Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company
Headquarters Omaha, Nebraska
Founded 1909
Ownership Mutual insurance company (policyholder-owned); since April 1, 2026 organized under Mutual of Omaha Holding Company
Parent company Mutual of Omaha Holding Company

Where and what

Where it sells Medicare Supplement plans in most states; plans and policy forms vary by state
Plan types Medicare Supplement (Medigap), hospital indemnity, dental, critical illness, cancer, heart attack and stroke coverage, long-term care, group dental and vision, life insurance and annuities

Size

Members About 1.3 million Medigap members, 9.4% of the market (December 2025, Mark Farrah Associates)

Ratings

AM Best financial strength A+ (Superior)
AM Best rating as of 2026-04

Fit

Best suited to People on Original Medicare who want a standardized Medigap plan from a mutual insurer, and people shopping for add-on benefits such as dental or hospital indemnity.

Plans and products

  • Medicare Supplement
  • hospital indemnity
  • dental
  • critical illness
  • long-term care
  • life insurance
  • annuities
  • group benefits

Brands and plan names

  • Mutual of Omaha
  • Omaha Supplemental Insurance Company
  • United of Omaha Life
  • Companion Life

Mutual of Omaha is an Omaha, Nebraska, insurer owned by its policyholders rather than by shareholders. In health coverage it is best known for Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policies, which help pay costs that Original Medicare leaves to the patient. It also sells dental and supplemental products, and life insurance, annuities and long-term care. Its website lists no ACA marketplace plans, employer major-medical plans, Medicare Advantage or Part D plans.

Overview

According to the AM Best press release from April 2, 2026, Medicare Supplement remains the company's largest product by revenue, though its share is shrinking as other lines grow. AM Best also says the firm holds top-10 market positions in group benefits, pension risk transfer, indexed universal life, traditional life and reverse mortgages. Mutual of Omaha is a mutual insurer, meaning policyholders are its owners; see mutual insurance company. AM Best reported that on April 1, 2026, the organization converted to a mutual holding company structure by forming Mutual of Omaha Holding Company, which AM Best said may add financial flexibility, including the ability to issue debt.

History

Wikipedia says the company was founded in 1909 as Mutual Benefit Health & Accident Association, incorporated in Nebraska, and was renamed Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company in 1950. A subsidiary, United Benefit Life, became United of Omaha in 1981. The company sponsored the television series Mutual of Omaha's Wild Kingdom from 1963 to 1988. In 2019 it agreed to sell Mutual of Omaha Bank to CIT Bank, and in 2022 it announced a new downtown Omaha headquarters tower.

Plans and products

  • Medicare Supplement: The company's Medigap page names Plans A, C, D, F, G, M and N, notes that Plans C and F are only for people first eligible for Medicare before January 1, 2020, and says plans are underwritten by Omaha Supplemental Insurance Company. Its other pages also mention high-deductible Plan G and Plan F. Availability varies by state, and Massachusetts, Minnesota and Wisconsin have their own standardized plans.
  • Individual add-ons: Hospital indemnity, dental, critical illness, and cancer, heart attack and stroke insurance, plus long-term care. These pay fixed benefits or limited benefits rather than replacing major medical coverage; see accident, hospital indemnity and critical illness plans explained and fixed indemnity plan.
  • Group: Dental, vision, disability, life and accident products for employers.
  • Life and annuities: Whole, term and universal life, and annuities.

I did not confirm short-term medical coverage from the company's site. A third-party roster had listed it, so it is left out here.

Where it sells

The company says its Medicare Supplement plans cover the nation, but that coverage "may vary by state" and not all policy forms are in every state. The company's page lists a limited-policy notice for Georgia. Third-party reviews disagree on how many states it covers, and one says it does not sell in Massachusetts. I did not verify a state list, so check by ZIP code on its site, with a licensed agent, or with Medicare.gov's plan finder. The home state page is Nebraska.

Networks and how its plans work

Medigap plans have no networks: a policyholder sees any doctor or hospital that accepts Medicare, and the plan pays its share after Medicare pays. The company's page says a policy cannot be cancelled as long as premiums are paid on time and there was no material misrepresentation. It also says a policy can be returned within 30 days of delivery for a refund of premiums, minus claims paid. Applicants have a six-month window starting with the first month they have Part B; people under 65 get two open enrollment periods, according to the company. Outside those windows, insurers in most states may ask health questions; see medigap open enrollment: the six-month window and guaranteed issue.

Ratings and reputation

AM Best affirmed Mutual of Omaha Insurance Company and its subsidiaries at A+ (Superior) for financial strength, with a stable outlook, on April 2, 2026. AM Best also noted rising operating leverage tied to the company's funding-agreement-backed notes program, according to coverage of the release. AM Best rates an insurer's ability to pay claims; it does not rate customer service or price. In Medigap, Mark Farrah Associates reported the company second in enrollment, with about 1.3 million members and a 9.4% share at the end of 2025, behind UnitedHealthcare's AARP-branded program; see AARP Medicare Supplement Insurance from UnitedHealthcare. I did not find a state complaint ranking for it.

Costs and savings

Medigap prices depend on plan letter, age, state, tobacco use and the insurer's rating method, and change each year, so no premium appears here. The company's pages did not state its rating method or discounts in the text I read; ask before comparing quotes. The home page lists dental and indemnity products, whose benefits are limited and fixed.

Enrolling and member service

People can request a quote online, work with a licensed agent, or call the sales line. Existing policyholders use the number on their policy or the policy-update line. Claims forms are on the site, and the company says 99% of claims are processed within 24 hours (a company figure footnoted to 2025 data). Complaints about an insurer go to the state insurance department; Medicare counseling is free through the state SHIP. See medigap.

Who it suits

  • Strengths: A policyholder-owned insurer with a strong AM Best rating; a large Medigap book, second by enrollment; standardized benefits that work with any Medicare provider.
  • Limits: Not an option for people who want Medicare Advantage or Part D from the same company; state availability and plan letters vary; Medigap premiums can rise with age and vary by rating method.

How to contact

Service Details
Medicare Supplement sales 888-981-5642 (toll-free)
Updating an existing policy 800-775-6000
Other products 888-633-2168
Website https://www.mutualofomaha.com
Find an agent https://www.mutualofomaha.com/support/find-an-agent

Sources

  1. mutualofomaha.com
  2. mutualofomaha.com/medicare-supplement
  3. mutualofomaha.com/medicare-supplement-insurance
  4. insurancenewsnet.com/oarticle/am-best-affirms-credit-ratings-of-mutual-of-omaha-insuranc…
  5. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutual_of_Omaha
  6. markfarrah.com/mfa-briefs/medicare-supplement-enrollment-slightly-up-in-2025/

Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.

Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026

Head to head

Compare with similar companies

Terms to know

Related guides

Related states