Compare
Elevance Health (Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Wellpoint) vs Medical Mutual of Ohio
Elevance runs Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield in Ohio and 13 other states; Medical Mutual is an Ohio-only mutual insurer that left the Blue system in 1997.
Verdict
Ohio shoppers sometimes confuse these two. Elevance Health is a national, investor-owned company that sells under the Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield name in Ohio and 13 other states. Medical Mutual of Ohio is a Cleveland-based mutual company with no stockholders. It began as a Blue Cross and Blue Shield plan but left the association in 1997.
Both sell individual, employer and Medicare coverage in Ohio. The differences are scale, ownership, product breadth outside Ohio and what happens if you move. Doctor and hospital participation is plan specific, so use the provider directory of the exact plan.
Choose Elevance Health (Anthem) if
- You want a Blue Cross and Blue Shield plan with a national company behind it and a presence in 14 Blue Cross states.
- You might move or travel and want an insurer that sells in other states.
- You want Medicaid or Medicare Advantage experience across many states; Elevance sells Medicaid under names such as Wellpoint and Amerigroup.
- You are weighing legal and regulatory history: the profile reports a 2017 data-breach settlement and pending lawsuits, all described as allegations unless resolved.
Choose Medical Mutual of Ohio if
- You want an insurer focused on Ohio, owned by policyholders rather than shareholders.
- You want a company that sells individual, employer and Medicare products, including MedMutual Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans, under one local name.
- You want an insurer that sells short-term plans as well as marketplace coverage; its site lists both.
- You should weigh its limits: it sells only in Ohio, and it publishes limited public figures on revenue and ratings.
Key differences
| Topic | Elevance Health | Medical Mutual of Ohio |
|---|---|---|
| Headquarters | Indianapolis, Indiana | Cleveland, Ohio |
| Ownership | Investor-owned (NYSE: ELV) | Mutual insurance company |
| Blue Cross status | Licensee in 14 states | Left the association in 1997 |
| Where it sells | ACA plans in 18 states for plan year 2026; Medicaid and Medicare in more | Ohio |
| Members | 45.2 million medical members (year-end 2025) | More than 1.2 million Ohioans (company, November 2024) |
| Revenue | $199.1 billion (2025) | Not stated |
| Network types | HMO, PPO, EPO, POS | HMO, HMO-POS, PPO |
| Medicare | Medicare Advantage, Medigap, Part D in some states | Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement |
| Medicaid | Managed care in many states | Not listed |
See Ohio for the state's marketplace and regulator, and the Ohio Department of Insurance for complaints.
Side by side
| Elevance Health (Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield, Wellpoint) | Medical Mutual of Ohio | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | National health insurers | Regional and provider-owned plans |
| Member services | — | 877-279-3216 |
| New members and sales | — | 844-583-3072 |
| Website | elevancehealth.com | medmutual.com |
| Headquarters | Indianapolis, Indiana | Cleveland, Ohio |
| Founded | 1946 | 1934 |
| Ownership | Investor-owned (NYSE: ELV) | Mutual insurance company (no stockholders) |
| Stock ticker | ELV | — |
| Where it sells | ACA individual plans in 18 states in plan year 2026 (14 Blue Cross and Blue Shield states plus Florida, Maryland, Texas and Washington under Wellpoint); Medicaid and Medicare Advantage in additional states | Ohio |
| Plan types | ACA marketplace plans, employer plans, self-funded administration, Medicare Advantage, Medigap, Medicaid managed care, dental, vision | Individual and family plans, short-term plans, employer group plans (insured and self-funded), Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, dental, vision, life, disability, accident and critical illness |
| Network types | HMO, PPO, EPO, POS | HMO, HMO-POS, PPO |
| ACA metal levels | Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum (varies by state) | — |
| Members | 45.2 million medical members (year-end 2025) | More than 1.2 million Ohioans (company, November 2024) |
| Revenue | $199.1 billion (2025) | — |
| Best suited to | — | Ohio individuals, employers and Medicare beneficiaries who want a locally based mutual insurer with a statewide footprint. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026