Regional and provider-owned plans
Medical Mutual of Ohio: plans, ratings and contacts
Cleveland-based mutual insurer selling individual, employer and Medicare plans in Ohio. A Blue plan until 1997; proposed a 21.6% 2027 marketplace increase.
Also known as Medical Mutual, MedMutual, Medical Health Insuring Corp.
Contact
| Member services | 877-279-3216 |
|---|---|
| New members and sales | 844-583-3072 |
| Website | medmutual.com |
Company
| Legal name | Medical Mutual of Ohio |
|---|---|
| Headquarters | Cleveland, Ohio |
| Founded | 1934 |
| Ownership | Mutual insurance company (no stockholders) |
Where and what
| Where it sells | Ohio |
|---|---|
| Plan types | Individual and family plans, short-term plans, employer group plans (insured and self-funded), Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, dental, vision, life, disability, accident and critical illness |
| Network types | HMO, HMO-POS, PPO |
Size
| Members | More than 1.2 million Ohioans (company, November 2024) |
|---|
Fit
| Best suited to | Ohio individuals, employers and Medicare beneficiaries who want a locally based mutual insurer with a statewide footprint. |
|---|
Plans and products
- Individual and family plans
- Employer group plans
- Medicare Advantage
- Medicare Supplement
- Dental and vision
- Life and disability
Brands and plan names
- MedMutual Advantage
- MedMutual Supplement Plus
- MedMutual SeniorCare
- Paramount
Medical Mutual of Ohio is a health insurer based in Cleveland that sells to individuals, employers and people on Medicare across Ohio. It is a mutual company: it has no stockholders, and the company says its focus is on policyholders and their dependents. Its newsroom boilerplate describes it as one of the oldest and largest health insurers based in Ohio, serving more than 1.2 million Ohioans (as of November 2024). Its website calls it "Ohio's Hometown Health Insurer."
It is not a Blue Cross Blue Shield licensee today, although it has Blue Cross roots (see History). Shoppers sometimes confuse it with the Blue plan that Anthem operates in the state; see Elevance Health.
History
The company traces its origin to hospital prepayment plans in Cleveland. According to Wikipedia's account, the Cleveland Hospital Service Association was formed in 1934 (the company's own boilerplate also gives 1934 as its founding year). Hospital and physician plans in northern Ohio merged over decades, and the combined business became Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Ohio in 1986. In 1997 the company left the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association and took the name Medical Mutual of Ohio. Wikipedia also lists the 2016 acquisition of the HealthSpan insurance business from Mercy Health.
According to the healthinsurance.org Ohio page, Medical Mutual bought Paramount Insurance Company in 2024; Paramount appears among the Ohio marketplace filers for 2026. That page notes it had no separate 2027 filing, which suggests the products may be folded into Medical Mutual's own, though the page does not say so directly.
On leadership, the company announced on November 13, 2024 that its president and chief executive had stepped down effective November 12 and that its chief financial officer was named interim chief executive. The board said it was in no rush to name a permanent replacement. This profile did not find a later announcement.
Plans and products
Medical Mutual's website lists these lines:
- Individual and family: medical, short-term, dental, vision, accident and critical illness, and life coverage. The site mentions a subsidy eligibility checker, and says that people who do not qualify for premium tax credits can look at off-marketplace plans.
- Employer group: small, midsize and large group health plans, both fully insured and self-funded (see self-funded plan); consumer-driven health plans; prescription drug coverage; group dental, vision, life, disability and accident, critical illness and hospital indemnity; and coverage under the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program.
- Medicare: MedMutual Advantage HMO, HMO-POS and PPO plans (offered with a Medicare contract), Medicare Supplement plans including MedMutual Supplement Plus, and SeniorCare. See Medicare Advantage and medigap for how those two kinds differ.
Where it sells
Medical Mutual sells in Ohio. Which counties a given plan covers varies by plan year, and the Medicare Advantage service area is set each fall; check the insurer, Medicare.gov's plan finder or HealthCare.gov for the current list. For the state's marketplace and regulator, see Ohio.
Networks and how its plans work
Its Medicare Advantage line includes HMO, HMO point-of-service and PPO options, and the employer and individual lines use the usual mix of HMO and PPO designs. Network rules differ by plan, so the summary of benefits and the provider directory for the specific plan are the controlling documents. See HMO.
Ratings and reputation
Wikipedia notes that in 2001 the company's SuperMed Plus PPO was the first PPO in the nation to earn full accreditation from the National Committee for Quality Assurance, a historical point rather than a current rating. CMS star ratings for Medicare Advantage plans change every October, so look up the current rating of any plan on Medicare.gov. This profile did not find a current AM Best rating it could confirm for the company.
Medical Mutual's website reported a data incident at Berkeley Research Group, a vendor of Express Scripts, which is Medical Mutual's pharmacy benefit manager, and gave members a dedicated phone line for questions. The page did not say how many members were affected.
Costs and savings
Rates for individual-market plans are filed each year with the Ohio Department of Insurance and reviewed on the federal RateReview site. According to healthinsurance.org, which cited RateReview.HealthCare.gov data accessed August 23, 2026, Medical Health Insuring Corp. (MedMutual) proposed an average 2027 increase of 21.6% before subsidies, compared with proposed changes of 9.5% to 24.1% for the other Ohio marketplace insurers that filed. Those were proposed figures, not final approved rates, and an individual's change depends on plan, age, county and subsidy. See premium tax credit.
According to the same source, two Ohio marketplace insurers (CareSource and Molina) are leaving the individual marketplace for 2027, and a new entrant (AmeriHealth Caritas) joins, so the set of choices around Medical Mutual has shifted.
Enrolling and member service
Individuals can enroll through HealthCare.gov (Ohio uses the federal marketplace; open enrollment for 2027 coverage runs November 1, 2026 through January 15, 2027, with a December 15 deadline for coverage starting January 1) or off the marketplace through the company or a licensed agent. Employers work with the company or a broker. Medicare Advantage and Supplement shoppers enroll during Medicare's enrollment periods. Complaints about a claim or coverage can go to the company's grievance process first, and to the Ohio Department of Insurance if unresolved;.
Who it suits
- Strengths: a single Ohio-focused insurer that offers individual, employer and Medicare products; mutual ownership; separate service lines for each segment.
- Weaknesses: Ohio only, so it does not help people who move out of state; its 2027 proposed marketplace increase was among the higher ones filed; the company publishes limited public figures on revenue and ratings.
How to contact
All times Eastern, from the company's website.
| Service | Number or URL |
|---|---|
| Individual and Medicare Supplement customer care | 877-279-3216 |
| Medicare Advantage customer care | 800-982-3117 |
| Employer group customer care | 800-382-5729 |
| Licensed sales agent (TTY 711) | 844-583-3072 |
| Website | https://www.medmutual.com |
| State regulator | Ohio Department of Insurance, https://insurance.ohio.gov |
Sources
- medmutual.com
- medmutual.com/About-Medical-Mutual/Newsroom/2024/November/Medical-Mutual-Announces-CEO-T…
- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medical_Mutual_of_Ohio
- healthinsurance.org/ohio/
Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.
Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026