Compare
EmblemHealth vs Healthfirst
Two New York City nonprofit plans compared: EmblemHealth, with its own medical practices and Connecticut subsidiary, and hospital-sponsored Healthfirst.
Verdict
EmblemHealth and Healthfirst are both nonprofit plans centered on the New York City area, and both sell Medicaid, Essential Plan, marketplace and Medicare coverage. They are organized differently. EmblemHealth formed in 2006 from two older plans, GHI and HIP, and includes its own medical offices, AdvantageCare Physicians. Healthfirst was founded by hospital systems, and its parent is controlled in equal portions by 21 hospitals.
Each profile reports a regulatory matter, described as a report and not a finding of current practice. EmblemHealth reached a 2026 settlement with the New York attorney general over its behavioral health provider directory, without admitting the findings. Healthfirst's matter is a state examination report covering 2016 through 2019. The profiles do not support a declared winner. Which plan fits depends on your borough or county, eligibility for Medicaid or the Essential Plan, and whether your doctors are in the network for the exact plan.
Choose EmblemHealth if
- You want a plan whose parent organization also runs medical offices, and in-person help at its Neighborhood Care locations in Cambria Heights, Harlem, Chinatown and East New York.
- You want employer group coverage, including small group, large group and labor union plans, or plans for city, state and federal employees.
- You want Medicare Supplement (Medigap) as well as Medicare Advantage.
- You need Connecticut coverage, since EmblemHealth owns ConnectiCare.
Choose Healthfirst if
- You live in New York City, Long Island, Westchester or the Hudson Valley and may qualify for Medicaid, the Essential Plan, Child Health Plus or a dual-eligible Medicare plan.
- You want a plan sponsored by New York hospital systems.
- You are weighing Medicare Advantage and Healthfirst's published ratings: its largest contract earned 4.5 stars in the 2026 Star Ratings, according to a company release. Ratings differ by contract and year.
- You are interested in long-term care plans.
Key differences
| Topic | EmblemHealth | Healthfirst |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | Nonprofit | Nonprofit, sponsored by New York hospital systems |
| Founded | 2006 (from GHI and HIP) | 1990 |
| Where it sells | New York; Connecticut via ConnectiCare | New York City, Long Island, Westchester, Hudson Valley |
| Marketplace | Marketplace and off-marketplace plans | Leaf marketplace plans |
| Medicare | Medicare Advantage and Medigap | Medicare Advantage and dual-eligible special needs plans |
| Medicaid and children | Medicaid managed care, Child Health Plus | Medicaid managed care, Child Health Plus |
| Employer coverage | Small group, large group, labor union | Small group |
| Network types | HMO, PPO, EPO | HMO |
| Members | Not stated | More than 2 million New Yorkers (company, 2025) |
| Reported matter | $2.5 million attorney general settlement, February 2026, over directory accuracy | State examination report dated September 14, 2026, covering 2016 to 2019 |
| Own medical practices | AdvantageCare Physicians | Not stated |
See New York for the marketplace and Medicaid programs, and the state's Department of Financial Services for complaints.
Side by side
| EmblemHealth | Healthfirst | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Regional and provider-owned plans | Regional and provider-owned plans |
| Member services | 888-225-6133 | — |
| New members and sales | — | 844-488-1486 |
| Website | emblemhealth.com | healthfirst.org |
| Headquarters | New York, New York | New York, New York |
| Founded | 2006 | 1990 |
| Ownership | Nonprofit | Nonprofit, sponsored by New York hospital systems |
| Where it sells | New York (plus Connecticut and parts of New York through its subsidiary ConnectiCare) | New York City, Long Island, Westchester and the Hudson Valley |
| Plan types | ACA marketplace and Essential Plan coverage, employer group plans, Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, Medicaid managed care, Child Health Plus | Marketplace (Leaf) plans, Essential Plan, Medicaid managed care, Child Health Plus, Medicare Advantage, dual-eligible special needs plans, long-term care plans |
| Network types | HMO, PPO, EPO | HMO |
| Members | — | more than 2 million New Yorkers (company, 2025) |
| Medicare star rating | — | 4.5 stars, largest Medicare Advantage contract, 2026 Star Ratings (company release, October 10, 2025) |
| Best suited to | People in the New York City area who want a locally based nonprofit plan with its own affiliated medical practices and neighborhood service locations. | New Yorkers in the downstate region who qualify for Medicaid, the Essential Plan, Child Health Plus or a dual-eligible Medicare plan, or who shop on NY State of Health. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026