Regional and provider-owned plans

Healthfirst: plans, ratings and contacts

Hospital-sponsored nonprofit plan in the New York City area selling Medicaid, Essential Plan, marketplace and Medicare Advantage coverage.

Also known as Healthfirst Health Plan, Healthfirst PHSP, Healthfirst Leaf, Healthfirst Medicare

Sizemore than 2 million New Yorkers (company, 2025)
Where it sellsNew York City, Long Island, Westchester and the Hudson Valley

Contact

New members and sales 844-488-1486
Website healthfirst.org

Company

Legal name Healthfirst Health Plan, Inc. and Healthfirst PHSP, Inc. (parent: Healthfirst, Inc.)
Headquarters New York, New York
Founded 1990
Ownership Nonprofit, sponsored by New York hospital systems

Where and what

Where it sells New York City, Long Island, Westchester and the Hudson Valley
Plan types Marketplace (Leaf) plans, Essential Plan, Medicaid managed care, Child Health Plus, Medicare Advantage, dual-eligible special needs plans, long-term care plans
Network types HMO

Size

Members more than 2 million New Yorkers (company, 2025)

Ratings

Medicare star rating 4.5 stars, largest Medicare Advantage contract, 2026 Star Ratings (company release, October 10, 2025)

Fit

Best suited to New Yorkers in the downstate region who qualify for Medicaid, the Essential Plan, Child Health Plus or a dual-eligible Medicare plan, or who shop on NY State of Health.

Plans and products

  • Leaf marketplace plans
  • Essential Plan
  • Medicaid managed care
  • Child Health Plus
  • Personal Wellness Plan
  • Medicare Advantage
  • dual special needs plans
  • long-term care plans

Brands and plan names

  • Healthfirst Leaf
  • Healthfirst Leaf Premier
  • Healthfirst CompleteCare
  • Healthfirst Connection Plan
  • Healthfirst 65 Plus Plan

Healthfirst is a not-for-profit health plan in the New York City region. It describes itself as founded by the leading hospital systems of New York, and its coverage centers on government programs: Medicaid managed care, the state's Essential Plan, Child Health Plus, Medicare Advantage and plans for people who have both Medicare and Medicaid. It also sells marketplace plans under the Leaf brand. The company says it serves more than two million New Yorkers.

Overview

Unlike a Blue Cross plan or a national insurer, Healthfirst operates only in New York, so its profile is mostly relevant to people in the city and nearby counties. For how provider-sponsored plans differ from others, see provider-owned health plans: when the insurer and the hospital are one.

History

Healthfirst's lead health plan was incorporated on September 6, 1990, under the name Managed Health, Inc., and began business on October 19, 1990, according to a New York State Department of Financial Services (DFS) examination report published in 2026. In 1998 the state approved Healthfirst, Inc., a nonprofit controlled in equal portions by 21 hospitals, to take control of that plan. The plan changed its name to Healthfirst Health Plan, Inc. in November 2015. Healthfirst PHSP, a prepaid health services plan that serves people in government programs, was incorporated in 1994, and an insurance company subsidiary, HealthFirst Insurance Company, began business in 2017. The same report says Healthfirst, Inc. is the ultimate parent of these entities.

Plans and products

Healthfirst's website organizes its products into two families:

  • Individual and family. Leaf marketplace plans (including Leaf Premier), Essential Plans, Medicaid managed care, Child Health Plus and the Personal Wellness Plan.
  • Medicare and long-term care. Medicare Advantage plans, dual eligible special needs plans and long-term care plans.

The company's Medicare plans named in a 2025 press release include CompleteCare, the Connection Plan, the Life Improvement Plan, the Increased Benefits Plan and the 65 Plus Plan. Healthfirst also sells small group coverage to employers, according to the DFS report. See Medicare special needs plans explained: D-SNP, C-SNP and I-SNP for who qualifies for the dual-eligible products.

Where it sells

Healthfirst says it serves New York City, the Hudson Valley, Westchester and Long Island. Individual plans are sold through NY State of Health, the state marketplace; availability by county is posted by the marketplace each year. New York describes the state's marketplace and Medicaid programs.

Networks and how its plans work

Healthfirst's plans use managed-care networks: members generally choose primary care and specialist providers from the plan's directory, and costs depend on the product. Medicaid and Essential Plan members typically have little or no cost sharing; marketplace and Medicare members have copays and deductibles set by the plan. See managed care organization for how Medicaid plans of this kind are paid and regulated.

Ratings and reputation

Healthfirst said in an October 10, 2025 release that its largest Medicare Advantage contract earned 4.5 out of 5 stars from CMS for the 2026 Star Ratings, the second year in a row, covering more than 275,000 enrollees. Ratings differ by contract and year; check Medicare.gov. A separate August 21, 2025 company release said Healthfirst ranked first among 12 plans in the New York Department of Health's Medicaid Quality Incentive Program, based on 2023 measures.

A DFS market conduct report dated September 14, 2026, covering the period 2016 through 2019, listed departures from state requirements in areas such as prompt payment of claims, grievance notices and utilization review timing. The report describes findings from that earlier period; it does not describe current practice, and this page does not summarize the company's response.

Costs and savings

For Medicaid, Child Health Plus and the Essential Plan, eligibility and income decide cost. For marketplace Leaf plans, premiums depend on age, county, plan level and any financial help through NY State of Health. The company posts its requested rate changes for individual and small group plans on its website, and DFS publishes approved rates. No current premium is quoted here.

Enrolling and member service

Healthfirst lists these enrollment lines on its website: individual and family, 844-488-1486 (Monday to Friday, 9 a.m. to 6 p.m.); Medicare Advantage, 877-237-1303 (Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.). It lists several member services numbers without labeling which plan each serves; the number on your member card or the mobile app is the one to use. Brokers can reach 855-456-3668. Complaints about an insurer can be filed with DFS (800-342-3736).

Who it suits

  • Strengths: Focus on Medicaid, Essential Plan and dual-eligible members in the New York City region, with a hospital-system sponsorship and strong published quality ratings for some lines.
  • Limitations: Sold only in New York, mainly downstate; a 2016-2019 conduct report recorded compliance departures; plan details change each year.

How to contact

Service Number or URL
Individual and family enrollment 844-488-1486
Medicare Advantage enrollment 877-237-1303
Medicaid, Essential Plan, Child Health Plus renewal 844-500-9820
Leaf plan renewal 855-718-1822
Provider services 888-801-1660
Broker services 855-456-3668
Website https://healthfirst.org

Sources

  1. healthfirst.org/about-us
  2. healthfirst.org/about-us/newsroom/press-releases/healthfirst-medicare-advantage-earns-4-…
  3. healthfirst.org/newsroom/healthfirst-ranked-1-in-quality-among-nys-medicaid-plans
  4. dfs.ny.gov/system/files/documents/2026/10/16031M19.pdf
  5. healthfirst.org/contact

Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.

Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026

Head to head

Compare with similar companies

Terms to know

Related guides

Related states

Mentioned in