Compare
Excellus BlueCross BlueShield vs Independent Health
Excellus BlueCross BlueShield, serving 31 upstate New York counties, compared with Western New York's Independent Health, using their profiles.
Verdict
Both are nonprofit, regionally based New York plans that sell individual, employer, Medicare Advantage and state-program coverage. They largely serve different parts of the state. The Excellus profile says its 31-county service area does not include the Buffalo area, which is where Independent Health is based, in Western New York.
For a shopper in Western New York, the question is usually which plan covers the address and includes the preferred doctors. Both companies report quality honors, but the profiles label them company-reported, so they are not an independent ranking. Independent Health also announced in November 2025 that it will join MVP Health Care, subject to regulatory approval, which could change details later.
Choose Excellus BlueCross BlueShield if
- You live in one of its 31 upstate counties across the Central New York, Southern Tier, Rochester and Utica regions.
- You want a Blue Cross Blue Shield licensee with plans for individuals, employers, Medicare Advantage and public programs.
- You are comfortable that no Medigap plan is listed on its site and that its approved 2027 marketplace increase is above the state average, as the profile notes.
Choose Independent Health if
- You live in Western New York; the profile names Allegany, Cattaraugus, Chautauqua, Erie, Genesee, Niagara, Orleans and Wyoming counties, with availability depending on the plan.
- You want a plan with an HMO heritage and HMO, HMO point-of-service and PPO designs.
- You are comfortable with the pending affiliation with MVP Health Care and with ratings the company reports about itself.
Key differences
| Item | Excellus BlueCross BlueShield | Independent Health |
|---|---|---|
| Headquarters | Rochester, New York | Williamsville, New York |
| Ownership | Nonprofit; The Lifetime Healthcare Companies | Not-for-profit; to join MVP Health Care, pending approval |
| Founded | Not stated | 1980 |
| Service area | 31 upstate New York counties | Western New York |
| Members | Nearly 1.5 million across Lifetime Healthcare Companies (2026) | About 325,000 (company website, 2026) |
| Network designs | Vary by product | HMO, HMO-POS, PPO |
| Medicare and state programs | Medicare Advantage, dual special needs, Medicaid managed care, Child Health Plus, Essential Plan | Medicare Advantage, Medicaid, Child Health Plus, Essential Plan |
| Reported ratings | NCQA Excellent (per company); J.D. Power Medicare Advantage satisfaction honor (company announcement, 2026) | NCQA 5 of 5 (company-reported, September 2026); Medicare 4.5 stars for 2027 (company-reported) |
Where to check
The New York State of Health marketplace and each plan's service-area page show whether an address is covered.
Side by side
| Excellus BlueCross BlueShield | Independent Health | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Blue Cross Blue Shield companies | Regional and provider-owned plans |
| Member services | — | 800-958-4405 |
| Website | excellusbcbs.com | independenthealth.com |
| Shop or enroll | excellusbcbs.com/plans | — |
| Headquarters | Rochester, New York | Williamsville, New York |
| Founded | — | 1980 |
| Ownership | Nonprofit | Not-for-profit regional plan; announced in November 2025 it will join MVP Health Care's family of companies, subject to regulatory approval |
| Parent company | The Lifetime Healthcare Companies | — |
| Where it sells | 31 upstate New York counties (Central New York, Southern Tier, Rochester and Utica regions) | Western New York |
| Plan types | ACA marketplace plans, New York Essential Plan, employer plans, Medicare Advantage, dual-eligible special needs plans, Medicaid managed care, Health and Recovery Plan (HARP), Child Health Plus | Individual and family plans, state-sponsored plans (MediSource, Child Health Plus, Essential Plan, MediSource Connect), NYS employee coverage, employer plans, Medicare Advantage (HMO, HMO-POS, PPO, special needs), health savings accounts |
| Network types | — | HMO, HMO-POS, PPO |
| Members | Nearly 1.5 million members across the Lifetime Healthcare Companies (Excellus corporate overview, 2026) | About 325,000 members (company website, 2026) |
| NCQA health plan rating | Excellent (NCQA Health Plan Accreditation, per company; date not stated) | 5 out of 5 (2026 commercial health plan ratings, company-reported, September 2026) |
| Medicare star rating | — | 4.5 stars (Medicare plan, plan year 2027, company-reported, October 2026) |
| J.D. Power | Named highest in customer satisfaction among New York Medicare Advantage plans for a third straight year (company announcement, 2026) | Third highest for member satisfaction, New York region (company-reported, May 2026) |
| Best suited to | — | Western New York residents and employers who want a locally based plan with an HMO heritage and a broad set of individual, state-sponsored and Medicare options. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026