Regional and provider-owned plans
Independent Health: plans, ratings and contacts
Western New York plan founded in 1980 as an HMO. Sells individual, state-sponsored, employer and Medicare plans; announced in 2025 it will join MVP Health Care.
Also known as Independent Health Association, IH, Independent Health Medicare Advantage, Independent Health Marketplace
Contact
| Member services | 800-958-4405 |
|---|---|
| Website | independenthealth.com |
Company
| Legal name | Independent Health Association, Inc. |
|---|---|
| Headquarters | Williamsville, New York |
| Founded | 1980 |
| Ownership | Not-for-profit regional plan; announced in November 2025 it will join MVP Health Care's family of companies, subject to regulatory approval |
Where and what
| Where it sells | Western New York |
|---|---|
| Plan types | Individual and family plans, state-sponsored plans (MediSource, Child Health Plus, Essential Plan, MediSource Connect), NYS employee coverage, employer plans, Medicare Advantage (HMO, HMO-POS, PPO, special needs), health savings accounts |
| Network types | HMO, HMO-POS, PPO |
Size
| Members | About 325,000 members (company website, 2026) |
|---|
Ratings
| NCQA health plan rating | 5 out of 5 (2026 commercial health plan ratings, company-reported, September 2026) |
|---|---|
| Medicare star rating | 4.5 stars (Medicare plan, plan year 2027, company-reported, October 2026) |
| J.D. Power | Third highest for member satisfaction, New York region (company-reported, May 2026) |
Fit
| Best suited to | Western New York residents and employers who want a locally based plan with an HMO heritage and a broad set of individual, state-sponsored and Medicare options. |
|---|
Plans and products
- Individual and family plans
- State-sponsored plans
- Employer plans
- Medicare Advantage
- Spending and savings accounts
Brands and plan names
- Independent Health
- MediSource
- Medicare Family Choice
Independent Health is a health plan serving Western New York, based in Williamsville according to Wikipedia. The company says it has about 325,000 members and more than 1,500 associates. It sells individual and family plans, state-sponsored plans, employer coverage, Medicare plans and spending and savings accounts, and it has a foundation that runs community health programs in the region.
In November 2025 it announced that it will join MVP Health Care's family of companies, subject to regulatory approval. See History for what the company's pages say about its status.
History
Independent Health says it was founded in 1980 as a University at Buffalo graduate school project that proposed a preventive-care-focused health maintenance organization (HMO). Wikipedia describes it as a regional health insurance company covering eight Western New York counties: Allegany, Cattaraugus, Chautauqua, Erie, Genesee, Niagara, Orleans and Wyoming.
On November 18, 2025, Independent Health announced it would join the MVP Health Care family of companies, a step its newsroom says is "subject to regulatory approvals." According to the affiliation website, both boards approved it unanimously, the two organizations together would serve nearly one million members and bring in about $7 billion a year, both would keep their brands and leadership for now, and members would see no immediate change in coverage, benefits or local service. That site calls the affiliation pending but also carries a footer headline saying MVP "completes" it, and the pages do not reconcile the two statements. See MVP Health Care and check either company's news page for the current status.
Plans and products
- Individual and family plans. Plans for people who buy their own coverage.
- State-sponsored plans. MediSource (Medicaid), Child Health Plus, the Essential Plan and MediSource Connect, according to the company's about page. See Basic Health Program for the kind of program behind the Essential Plan.
- Employer coverage. Group plans and coverage for New York State employees.
- Medicare. Medicare Advantage plans; the company says it offers HMO, HMO-SNP, HMO-POS and PPO plans, including an institutional special needs plan for nursing-facility residents. See Medicare Advantage explained: how Part C plans work.
- Spending and savings accounts. Health-related accounts such as HSAs; see HSA.
Where it sells
Independent Health is a Western New York plan. Wikipedia describes its service area as eight counties: Allegany, Cattaraugus, Chautauqua, Erie, Genesee, Niagara, Orleans and Wyoming, and which counties a given plan serves depends on the product and plan year. Check the plan's service area before enrolling, because someone living just outside it may not be able to buy the plan or may find its network thin. For the state, see New York.
Networks and how its plans work
The company's heritage is the HMO model, and it sells HMO, HMO point-of-service and PPO designs depending on the line. See HMO. A plan's network rules and referral requirements are in its summary of benefits and provider directory.
Ratings and reputation
The company's newsroom reports, as company statements:
- On September 15, 2026, NCQA's top overall rating of 5 out of 5 stars for its 2026 commercial health plan ratings, its fourth consecutive year.
- On October 15, 2026, a 4.5-star rating for its Medicare plan for plan year 2027 (Medicare's medicare star ratings are published by CMS each October).
- On May 27, 2026, a ranking of third highest for member satisfaction in the New York region by J.D. Power.
Costs and savings
For 2027, New York regulators approved an average 6% individual-market increase against 20.6% requested, according to ACA Signups as cited by healthinsurance.org; that is a statewide average, not an Independent Health figure. A person's premium depends on plan, age, county and tax credits. See premium tax credit.
Enrolling and member service
Individuals enroll through NY State of Health or through the company, and the state marketplace remains the only route to premium tax credits and the Essential Plan. The company's contact page splits its phone lines between employer coverage and Medicare and individual coverage, so use the line that matches your product. Medicare shoppers use Medicare's enrollment periods. Employers go through the company or a broker. Complaints can go to Independent Health and then to the New York Department of Financial Services.
Who it suits
- Strengths: a locally based plan with a long HMO history, broad product lines, a company-reported 5-star NCQA commercial rating and 4.5-star Medicare rating.
- Weaknesses: limited to Western New York; the pending affiliation could change details later; ratings shown here are the company's own reports.
How to contact
| Service | Number or URL |
|---|---|
| Medicare and individual coverage | 716-505-8515 or 800-958-4405 |
| Employer coverage | 716-631-5392 or 800-453-1910, option 4 |
| Website | https://www.independenthealth.com |
Sources
- independenthealth.com
- independenthealth.com/about.html
- independenthealth.com/about/newsroom.html
- independenthealth.com/about/contact-us.html
- independenthealth.com/medicare
- en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Independent_Health
- aneweraofhealth.com/our-future
Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.
Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026