Compare
Golden Rule Insurance Company (UnitedHealthcare) vs Medi-Share (Christian Care Ministry)
Golden Rule sells underwritten short-term insurance; Medi-Share is a Christian sharing ministry that is not insurance. Neither is an ACA plan.
Verdict
These two are alternatives to ACA marketplace coverage, and neither is an ACA plan. They work differently. Golden Rule Insurance Company, a UnitedHealth Group subsidiary, is an insurer that issues short-term medical policies under the UnitedHealthOne name. Medi-Share is a health care sharing ministry run by a nonprofit: members share each other's eligible bills, and Medi-Share says it is not insurance and that payment is not guaranteed.
Short-term insurance is a contract with an insurer, but it is medically underwritten, generally excludes preexisting conditions and may omit categories ACA plans must cover. Medi-Share depends on faith and lifestyle requirements and written sharing guidelines, and limits sharing for pre-existing conditions. Neither qualifies for federal tax subsidies as an ACA plan. Check your state's rules with the state insurance department.
Choose Golden Rule if
- You need temporary medical coverage for a gap, such as the time between jobs; terms run from about one month to nearly 12 months depending on the state.
- You want an insurer's contract with several deductible options and a company that lists an A (Excellent) AM Best rating, stated by the company and worth confirming.
- You can start quickly: the company says coverage may start the day after application.
- You accept that the company reviews health history, and an application may be denied.
Choose Medi-Share if
- You hold the Christian faith and will sign the Statement of Faith and follow the ministry's lifestyle standards.
- You accept that sharing is voluntary and not guaranteed, and that you remain responsible for any bill not shared.
- You want a program with named Annual Household Portion levels ($1,000 to $12,000 for Medi-Share Complete) and a longer-term arrangement than a short-term policy.
- You are 65 or older with Medicare Parts A and B; Medi-Share 65+ is built to sit alongside Medicare.
Key differences
| Topic | Golden Rule | Medi-Share |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Insurance company | Health care sharing ministry, not insurance |
| Parent | UnitedHealth Group | Christian Care Ministry, Inc., nonprofit |
| Headquarters | Indianapolis, Indiana | Melbourne, Florida |
| Founded | 1940 | 1993 |
| Payment guarantee | Policy terms apply | Not guaranteed |
| Pre-existing conditions | Generally not covered | Limited sharing, increasing after 36 and 60 months |
| ACA minimum essential coverage | No | No |
| Eligibility | Medical underwriting | Faith statement and lifestyle standards |
| State rules | Some states exclude or restrict | State disclosures for Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin |
See short-term health insurance: what it covers and what it does not and health care sharing ministries explained: not insurance, so what are they? for the trade-offs.
Side by side
| Golden Rule Insurance Company (UnitedHealthcare) | Medi-Share (Christian Care Ministry) | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Short-term and supplemental carriers | Health care sharing ministries (not insurance) |
| Member services | 800-273-8115 | 800-264-2562 (member services) |
| New members and sales | — | 800-772-5623 (joining Medi-Share) |
| Website | uhone.com | medishare.com |
| Headquarters | Indianapolis, Indiana | Melbourne, Florida |
| Founded | 1940 | 1993 |
| Ownership | Subsidiary of UnitedHealth Group (NYSE: UNH) | Nonprofit religious ministry |
| Parent company | UnitedHealth Group | Christian Care Ministry, Inc. |
| Stock ticker | UNH | — |
| Where it sells | Short-term medical in most states, with some states excluded; terms and eligibility vary by state | Offered nationally; the site carries state-specific disclosures for Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, and Maryland members pay providers directly under a Maryland Insurance Administration determination |
| Plan types | Short-term medical, TriTerm medical, fixed benefit, dental, vision, accident, critical illness, hospital indemnity | Health care sharing (Medi-Share Complete for individuals and families; Medi-Share 65+ for members 65 and older with Medicare Parts A and B) |
| Network types | — | Provider discount network |
| Members | — | 350,000+ members (Medi-Share's website, 2025) |
| AM Best financial strength | A (Excellent) | — |
| Best suited to | — | People who hold a Christian faith, accept the ministry's lifestyle and sharing guidelines, and understand that bill sharing is voluntary and not guaranteed. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026