Guides
Health care sharing ministries explained: not insurance, so what are they?
Sharing ministries are not insurance: members send monthly shares that help pay other members' bills, with no legal promise that any bill will be paid.
A health care sharing ministry is not health insurance. It is an organization, typically faith-based, in which members make regular monthly payments, often called shares, that are used to help pay other members' medical bills according to the ministry's own written guidelines. Because it is not insurance, it generally makes no legal promise to pay any bill, is not regulated as insurance in most states, and is not covered by the consumer protections that apply to ACA plans.
How sharing works
Ministries differ, but the common pattern looks like this.
- You join and pay a monthly share. The amount often depends on age, household size and the level of the program you pick. It is a contribution, not a premium.
- You pay the first part of each need yourself. Many programs set an initial unshared amount per incident or per year, which works somewhat like a deductible.
- You submit a need. After you receive care, you or the provider send the bill to the ministry, which reviews it against its guidelines.
- The ministry arranges sharing. Depending on the program, other members' shares are sent to you, to the provider, or to a pool, and the ministry decides what is eligible and how much is shared.
Some ministries also negotiate prices with providers or direct members to cash-pay discounts, but many members are treated as self-pay patients at the point of care. Payment can come weeks or months after the bill.
What is not guaranteed
The central difference is the legal one. In insurance, the insurer has a contract with you and state regulators enforce it. In sharing, the guidelines usually state that the program is voluntary and that the ministry is not obligated to pay anything. A sharing program's documents commonly include language to that effect, often with a disclosure that the plan is not insurance. Read it.
Items that are commonly limited or excluded include:
- Pre-existing conditions. Many programs have waiting periods or caps for conditions you had before joining, and some do not share them at all.
- Services. Some programs exclude or limit maternity, mental health, substance use treatment, preventive care or prescription drugs, and some exclude care tied to behaviors or conditions their guidelines disapprove of.
- Caps. Per-incident or annual sharing limits that apply to the total, not just to your cost.
- Eligibility rules. Many require members to affirm a statement of faith or to follow lifestyle guidelines.
Because the ministry is not an insurer, ACA rules such as the ban on annual and lifetime dollar limits, coverage of essential health benefits, a guaranteed out-of-pocket maximum, and the internal appeal and external review process do not apply. The ministry may have its own dispute process. Health care sharing ministry membership is also not minimum essential coverage, and ending it generally does not open a special enrollment period for marketplace coverage.
A worked example with round numbers
This is an illustration, not a quote. Say a household pays a $400 monthly share ($4,800 a year) and the program has a $1,000 initial unshared amount for each need. The household has a $10,000 hospital bill.
| Outcome | What happens | Household pays |
|---|---|---|
| Shared in full | The ministry approves the need; shares cover everything above $1,000 | $1,000 |
| Shared in part | The need is approved but a per-incident cap of $6,000 applies | $1,000 + $3,000 over the cap = $4,000 |
| Not eligible | The condition falls under a pre-existing waiting period | $10,000 |
The same bill can cost $1,000, $4,000 or $10,000, depending on guidelines the household accepted at joining. With insurance, the ACA caps the member's cost for covered in-network essential benefits at a set yearly limit regardless of what the diagnosis is.
Where regulators have acted
Because sharing programs are not insurers, state insurance departments have not supervised them in the way they do insurers. Several states have laws that exempt a ministry from insurance regulation when it meets certain conditions, such as being a nonprofit, requiring disclosures that it is not insurance, and having been in operation for a minimum time. In some states, regulators have issued cease-and-desist orders or other actions against particular sharing programs that they concluded were selling unlicensed insurance, and regulators and consumer groups have warned that some products marketed as sharing resemble insurance without being regulated as such. Whether a program is exempt where you live is a question for your state insurance department; see how to file a complaint with your state insurance department for how to reach it. Details change, so check the current position in your state rather than relying on a ministry's description of itself.
The case for and against
Supporters say a sharing program offers lower monthly costs, a community of shared values, and freedom from some insurance rules, and can suit a healthy household that is comfortable with the risk and the ministry's guidelines.
Critics say members can face large unpaid bills, the programs offer none of the ACA's guarantees, marketing may lead people to think they have insurance, and people with health conditions are the most exposed. Some regulators and consumer advocates have raised those concerns.
The program page for this type of coverage is Health care sharing ministry; short-term health insurance: what it covers and what it does not covers another product that sits outside the ACA rules.
Checking before you join
- Ask whether the program is insurance and where the disclosure appears in writing.
- Ask how the program handles pre-existing conditions, maternity, mental health and prescriptions.
- Ask for the per-need and annual limits, the initial unshared amount and how long reimbursement typically takes.
- Ask how many needs were not shared, or shared in part, in the past year.
- Check your state insurance department. fake health plans and discount cards: how they differ from insurance explains how products that resemble insurance differ from it, and how to compare health plans: premium, deductible, network and drugs shows the factors to compare with an ACA plan or a short-term plan.
Key takeaways
- A sharing ministry is not insurance: members' monthly shares help pay others' bills under the ministry's guidelines, with no legal promise of payment.
- ACA consumer protections, including coverage of pre-existing conditions and a yearly cap on your costs, do not apply.
- Pre-existing conditions, services and caps can leave a household paying much more than the headline cost suggests.
- Some states exempt ministries from insurance rules; some regulators have acted against particular programs. Ask your state insurance department.
- Compare a ministry with ACA and other plans on what is excluded and capped, not on the monthly share alone.