Compare
Kaiser Permanente (Kaiser Foundation Health Plan) vs Sutter Health Plus
Kaiser Permanente's integrated model compared with Sutter Health Plus, an HMO built on Sutter Health's Northern California hospitals, from their profiles.
Verdict
Both are nonprofit plans tied to a care system, and both are built around a defined network of the parent's own doctors and hospitals. In Northern California, shoppers can weigh them directly.
The difference is scale and structure. Kaiser Permanente is an integrated system in which the insurer and the care provider are one organization, with health plans in California and eight other states plus D.C. Sutter Health Plus is the health plan of Sutter Health, a Sacramento-based hospital and medical group system. It is an HMO whose network also includes other contracted providers, and it sells individual and employer coverage in Northern California. Kaiser also sells Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and CHIP, which Sutter Health Plus does not list.
Neither profile supports a winner. The deciding factor is which doctors and hospitals a reader wants.
Choose Kaiser Permanente if
- You want coordinated care inside one system, with one record and, in most cases, one bill.
- You want Medicare Advantage, Medicaid or CHIP coverage from the same organization.
- You may live or move among Kaiser's other regions, such as Southern California, Colorado, Hawaii or Oregon.
- You are comfortable with limits on specialist choice and travel outside the system.
Choose Sutter Health Plus if
- You live in Greater Sacramento, the Central Valley or the Bay Area and want an HMO built around Sutter Health's hospitals and doctors.
- You want an HSA-compatible design, which the profile lists for the plan.
- You are comfortable choosing a primary care doctor who coordinates referrals inside the network.
- You are willing to confirm Covered California participation for 2027, which the profile could not verify.
Key differences
| Item | Kaiser Permanente | Sutter Health Plus |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership | Nonprofit integrated system | Nonprofit; owned by Sutter Health |
| Headquarters | Oakland, California | Not stated (Sutter Health is Sacramento-based) |
| Where it sells | California and nine other regions including Colorado, Georgia, Hawaii, Oregon and Washington | Northern California |
| Members | 12.8 million (September 30, 2026) | Not stated |
| Network | Integrated HMO using its own doctors and hospitals | HMO built on Sutter Health and other contracted providers |
| Individual and employer plans | Yes | Yes |
| Medicare and Medicaid | Medicare Advantage, Medicaid, CHIP | Not listed |
| HSA-compatible plans | Not stated | Yes |
| Quality rating in profile | Not stated | NCQA 4 of 5 stars, measurement year 2023 (per the plan) |
Where to check
Covered California's shopping tool shows which plans are sold at an address. The plan's provider directory shows whether a favorite doctor and hospital are in network.
Side by side
| Kaiser Permanente (Kaiser Foundation Health Plan) | Sutter Health Plus | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | National health insurers | Regional and provider-owned plans |
| Member services | — | 855-315-5800 |
| Website | healthy.kaiserpermanente.org | sutterhealthplan.org |
| Headquarters | Oakland, California | — |
| Founded | 1945 | — |
| Ownership | Nonprofit integrated system (Kaiser Foundation Health Plan) | Nonprofit, owned by Sutter Health |
| Parent company | — | Sutter Health |
| Where it sells | California, Colorado, Georgia, Hawaii, Maryland, Virginia, Washington, D.C., Oregon, southwest Washington and Nevada (new in 2026) | Northern California (Greater Sacramento, the Central Valley and the Bay Area) |
| Plan types | ACA marketplace plans, employer plans, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid managed care, CHIP | Individual and family HMO plans, employer group HMO plans |
| Network types | Integrated HMO (own doctors and hospitals) | HMO |
| HSA-eligible plans | — | Yes |
| Members | 12.8 million (September 30, 2026) | — |
| Revenue | $127.7 billion operating revenue (Kaiser Permanente and Risant Health, 2025) | — |
| NCQA health plan rating | — | 4 out of 5 stars for quality and service, measurement year 2023 (per the plan's website) |
| Best suited to | — | Northern California residents and employers who want an HMO built around Sutter Health's hospitals and doctors and are comfortable choosing a primary care doctor. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026