Regional and provider-owned plans

Sutter Health Plus: plans, ratings and contacts

Nonprofit HMO from the Sutter Health system, selling individual and employer coverage in Northern California's Sacramento, Central Valley and Bay Area regions.

Also known as Sutter Health Plan, Sutter Health Plus HMO

Where it sellsNorthern California (Greater Sacramento, the Central Valley and the Bay Area)
Member services855-315-5800

Contact

Member services 855-315-5800
Website sutterhealthplan.org

Company

Ownership Nonprofit, owned by Sutter Health
Parent company Sutter Health

Where and what

Where it sells Northern California (Greater Sacramento, the Central Valley and the Bay Area)
Plan types Individual and family HMO plans, employer group HMO plans
Network types HMO
HSA-eligible plans Yes

Ratings

NCQA health plan rating 4 out of 5 stars for quality and service, measurement year 2023 (per the plan's website)

Fit

Best suited to Northern California residents and employers who want an HMO built around Sutter Health's hospitals and doctors and are comfortable choosing a primary care doctor.

Plans and products

  • Individual and family HMO plans
  • employer group HMO plans
  • HSA-compatible high-deductible plans

Brands and plan names

  • Sutter Health Plan

Sutter Health Plus is the health plan of Sutter Health, the Sacramento-based nonprofit hospital and medical group system. Its website now presents it as Sutter Health Plan, and the older sutterhealthplus.org address forwards there. It is an HMO, which means members choose a primary care doctor and use a defined network, and it is built around Sutter's own hospitals and physicians. That makes it a provider-owned plan (see provider-owned health plans: when the insurer and the hospital are one).

Overview

Sutter Health describes itself as a not-for-profit integrated health system headquartered in Sacramento with roughly two dozen acute care hospitals, according to Wikipedia. Its plan describes its mission as caring for patients first and says it is a nonprofit. The plan's site calls it "more than an HMO" because members reach a network that includes many Sutter Health hospitals and doctors and other contracted providers. I could not open a founding year for the plan or a membership count, so neither is given here.

Plans and products

The plan's website lists individual and family coverage and employer coverage. Its plans use a traditional cost structure or a high-deductible design, and the site says its high-deductible plans can be paired with a health savings account (see HDHP). All plans cover hospital stays, outpatient care, prescriptions and preventive services; the site says preventive services come with no cost share, which matches the ACA rule for most plans. Behavioral health, pharmacy, dental, vision, and acupuncture and chiropractic benefits are handled through partner companies, listed in the contact table below. I did not find Medicare or Medicaid products on the pages I opened.

Where it sells

The plan describes its service area as Northern California, with a network across Greater Sacramento, the Central Valley and the Bay Area. The exact county list is on its service-area page, which was not available when this profile was prepared, so confirm that an address is covered. Earlier research for this directory listed it as a Covered California insurer. The pages I opened did not confirm 2027 participation, so check Covered California's plan shopping tool before relying on that. Covered California is the state-run marketplace, with 12 insurers statewide for 2027 according to healthinsurance.org. See California.

Networks and how its plans work

As an HMO, the plan asks members to pick a primary care physician, who coordinates care and refers to specialists inside the network. Outside an emergency, HMOs usually pay only for in-network care; see HMO and HMO vs PPO vs EPO vs POS: how the four plan types differ for the trade-off against a PPO. Its network leans on Sutter Health facilities, so check that a favorite doctor and hospital are in the network for the specific plan.

Ratings and reputation

The plan says on its website that it is NCQA-accredited and received 4 out of 5 stars for quality and service for measurement year 2023. NCQA, the National Committee for Quality Assurance, rates commercial health plans on clinical quality, member experience and plan operations; the figure above is the plan's own statement, and NCQA's site has the current rating. I did not find an AM Best rating.

Costs and savings

I did not find Sutter Health Plus's 2027 rates in sources I could open. For context, healthinsurance.org reports that Covered California's statewide average proposed increase for 2027 is 9.9% before subsidies (9.7% in its quick-facts box), after an average increase of 10.1% for 2026. Subsidies reduce what many households pay, so a household's cost depends on income and the benchmark plan in its region. Premiums for an address come from Covered California or the plan.

Enrolling and member service

The plan has a member portal, enrollment information, and broker and employer sections on its website. Its customer service line is 855-315-5800, weekdays 8 a.m. to 7 p.m., and the site lists no separate enrollment number. HMO members can also complain to the California Department of Managed Health Care after going through the plan's grievance process.

Who it suits

  • Strengths: a nonprofit HMO tied to a large Northern California hospital system; both traditional and HSA-compatible designs; NCQA accreditation per its own site.
  • Limits: HMO rules limit care outside the network; the network is built on Sutter Health, so people who see other systems' doctors should check carefully.

How to contact

Service Number
Customer service 855-315-5800 (TTY 855-830-3500), weekdays 8 a.m. to 7 p.m.
Behavioral health (Carelon) 844-398-0314
Pharmacy (CVS Caremark) 844-740-0635
Acupuncture and chiropractic (ACN Group of California) 800-428-6337
Dental (Delta Dental) 800-422-4234
Vision (VSP) 800-877-7195
General correspondence P.O. Box 160307, Sacramento, CA 95816

Sources

  1. sutterhealthplan.org/
  2. sutterhealthplan.org/about-us
  3. sutterhealthplan.org/members
  4. sutterhealthplan.org/contact-us
  5. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sutter_Health
  6. healthinsurance.org/aca-marketplace/california/

Facts were checked against these sources on the review date below. Plans, footprints, ratings and phone numbers change every year: confirm with the company, the marketplace or your state insurance department before you rely on them.

Profile last reviewed November 16, 2026

Head to head

Compare with similar companies

Terms to know

Related guides

Related states