Compare
Medi-Share (Christian Care Ministry) vs Samaritan Ministries International
Two Christian health care sharing ministries. Neither is insurance, and sharing is not guaranteed. They differ in how members send money and in provider choice.
Medi-Share and Samaritan Ministries International are both Christian health care sharing ministries, not insurers. In each, members share one another's eligible medical bills under written guidelines, and neither ministry guarantees payment. A member remains responsible for any bill that is not shared. Neither provides ACA minimum essential coverage.
Verdict
The profiles describe two models with the same legal posture. Medi-Share routes sharing through a central ministry: the member shows a card, the provider bills Medi-Share, and the member pays a chosen yearly amount, the Annual Household Portion (AHP). Samaritan describes direct sharing, in which members send money to members with needs; a 2014 report said for large expenses members send checks directly. Medi-Share offers a discounted provider network, while Samaritan has no network and members choose any provider. Both require religious affirmations and lifestyle standards. Samaritan's profile rests on news reports, court coverage and a 2018 Commonwealth Fund brief because its website could not be read, so its current terms are less certain; check each ministry's own guidelines. Neither profile gives a current monthly cost. A state insurance department can say whether it has any role in your state, and the rules differ by state.
Choose Medi-Share if
- You want named AHP levels of $1,000, $1,750, $3,000, $6,000, $9,000 or $12,000, listed in its guidelines for Complete.
- You want a program for people 65 or older with Medicare Parts A and B, Medi-Share 65+.
- You want discounts on network care, dental, hearing and prescriptions, and telehealth.
- You can affirm its Statement of Faith and accept its lifestyle standards.
Choose Samaritan Ministries if
- You want member-to-member sharing, with no network and a free choice of providers.
- You hold the ministry's Christian beliefs and accept its conduct requirements, which a 2023 news report described as including church attendance and abstaining from illegal drugs.
- You understand that its current guidelines, not the 2018 figures in the profile, control what is shared.
Key differences
| Medi-Share | Samaritan Ministries | |
|---|---|---|
| Legal form | Nonprofit religious ministry (Christian Care Ministry, Inc.) | Nonprofit religious ministry |
| Headquarters | Melbourne, Florida | Peoria, Illinois |
| Members | 350,000+ (2025, its website) | About 270,000 (its figure in a December 2023 lawsuit) |
| How sharing works | Provider bills the ministry; members share through it | Members send money directly to members with needs |
| Provider network | Provider discount network | None; any provider |
| Programs | Medi-Share Complete; Medi-Share 65+ | Classic and Basic (2018 brief) |
| Pre-existing conditions | Eligible after 36 months of sharing, capped per year; drugs for them never eligible | Not stated in the profile |
| State issues | Disclosures for Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania, Wisconsin; Maryland members pay providers directly | A 2023 lawsuit over New Mexico; Tenth Circuit upheld its dismissal in October 2025 |
| Phone | 800-264-2562 (members); 800-772-5623 (joining) | Not listed |
See health care sharing ministry and health care sharing ministries explained: not insurance, so what are they? for the trade-offs.
Side by side
| Medi-Share (Christian Care Ministry) | Samaritan Ministries International | |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Health care sharing ministries (not insurance) | Health care sharing ministries (not insurance) |
| Member services | 800-264-2562 (member services) | — |
| New members and sales | 800-772-5623 (joining Medi-Share) | — |
| Website | medishare.com | samaritanministries.org |
| Headquarters | Melbourne, Florida | Peoria, Illinois |
| Founded | 1993 | — |
| Ownership | Nonprofit religious ministry | Nonprofit religious ministry |
| Parent company | Christian Care Ministry, Inc. | — |
| Where it sells | Offered nationally; the site carries state-specific disclosures for Kentucky, Maryland, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin, and Maryland members pay providers directly under a Maryland Insurance Administration determination | Offered nationally to members who accept its religious and lifestyle guidelines; in a 2023 lawsuit it said about 900 of its members live in New Mexico, where the state insurance regulator's view of sharing ministries is contested |
| Plan types | Health care sharing (Medi-Share Complete for individuals and families; Medi-Share 65+ for members 65 and older with Medicare Parts A and B) | Health care sharing (member-to-member sharing of eligible medical needs) |
| Network types | Provider discount network | No network; members choose their own providers |
| Members | 350,000+ members (Medi-Share's website, 2025) | About 270,000 members nationwide (Samaritan's figure in a December 2023 lawsuit, as reported by the Santa Fe New Mexican) |
| Best suited to | People who hold a Christian faith, accept the ministry's lifestyle and sharing guidelines, and understand that bill sharing is voluntary and not guaranteed. | People who hold the ministry's Christian beliefs, are comfortable with member-to-member sharing, and understand it is voluntary and not insurance. |
| Plans and products |
|
|
| Brands and plan names |
|
|
Facts come from each insurer's profile, where every figure carries its source and review date. Premiums are personal: compare quotes for the same coverage, not just companies.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026