Glossary
Improper payment
A government payment that should not have been made or was the wrong amount, which includes honest errors and missing paperwork, not just fraud.
Also called: improper payments, payment error, erroneous payment, payment integrity
An improper payment is any payment that was made in the wrong amount, to the wrong party, for a service that was not eligible, or without enough documentation to show it was correct. It includes overpayments and underpayments. Federal agencies, including CMS for Medicare and Medicaid, must estimate and report their improper-payment rates each year under federal law.
The estimate comes from sampling. Say reviewers examine 1,000 sampled claims worth $1,000,000 and find that $80,000 was paid in error (a labeled hypothetical). The improper-payment rate for the sample is 8%, which is then projected to the whole program. A finding of "insufficient documentation" counts even if the care was real and appropriate.
This is why an improper-payment rate is not a fraud rate. Fraud, which requires intent to deceive, is a smaller part of the total, and many errors are administrative. Policy responses include prepayment review, audits such as RADV audit, and cases under the False Claims Act. Medicaid and medicare each report their own figures.
The common mistake is reading a headline percentage as money stolen. CMS publishes the current rates and what drives them each year.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026