Glossary
Supplemental insurance
Extra coverage that sits beside a main health plan, either paying cash for events like an accident or filling gaps Medicare leaves.
Also called: supplemental health insurance, accident insurance, critical illness insurance, hospital indemnity insurance
Supplemental insurance is an add-on that works alongside a primary health plan; it is not a substitute for one. The phrase covers two quite different products, so read what is actually being sold.
The first kind pays cash. Accident, critical illness and hospital policies pay a set amount when something specific happens, like a covered diagnosis or a hospital stay, and you can spend the money on anything, including deductibles, rent or time off work. They work like a fixed indemnity plan. As a labeled hypothetical, a critical illness policy that pays $10,000 on a covered diagnosis can soften a $3,000 deductible, but it will not stop a $100,000 hospital bill.
The second kind is Medicare supplement insurance, called medigap, which pays some costs Original Medicare leaves, such as coinsurance and deductibles. It is regulated and standardized by letter plan, which makes it unlike the cash products.
The common mistake is buying a cash policy believing it is real coverage. Check which diagnoses and events qualify, waiting periods, exclusions and whether the premium rises with age. A licensed broker, the insurer, or the state insurance department can answer questions about a specific policy.
Last reviewed November 16, 2026