Guides

Fake health plans and discount cards: how they differ from insurance

A medical discount card is a membership that lowers prices; it pays no claims. See how it and other look-alikes differ from real health insurance.

Health insurance pays part of your medical bills and limits what you can owe in a year. A medical discount card, which charges a monthly fee for lower prices at participating providers, does neither: it pays nothing and does not cap your costs. Some products are legal but narrow, such as fixed indemnity plans and short-term plans. Others are scams that use the word "plan" while delivering little. The test is simple: when you get sick, who pays the bill, and is there a limit on what you owe?

What real insurance does

Major medical coverage, such as an employer plan, a marketplace plan, Medicare or Medicaid, has a few features you can check:

  • It pays claims under a written contract, using a deductible, copays or coinsurance.
  • It has an out-of-pocket maximum, a yearly cap on what you pay for covered in-network care.
  • Ten categories of care, the essential health benefits, are covered in individual and small-group plans that follow the Affordable Care Act.
  • It cannot turn you down or charge more because of a pre-existing condition in the individual and small-group markets.
  • It counts as minimum essential coverage, which is the standard for meeting federal and state coverage rules.

If a product lacks these features, it may still be lawful, but it is not a substitute for major medical coverage.

Look-alikes and how they differ

Product What it is What it does not do
Medical discount card or "savings plan" A membership with negotiated discounts at some providers Pays no claims; no spending cap; discounts may be small or unavailable for your doctor
fixed indemnity plan Pays a set dollar amount per day or per service Payment does not follow your bill; large claims can exceed it by a wide margin
Short-term limited-duration insurance Temporary coverage with limited terms May exclude pre-existing conditions and essential benefits; federal and state rules limit length
Health care sharing ministry Members share each other's bills under guidelines Not insurance; sharing is not guaranteed
Supplemental insurance Extra cash for an event such as a hospital stay or injury Not designed to replace major medical coverage

Several of these are legitimate when sold honestly and used alongside real coverage. They become a problem when they are sold as a replacement. The related guides explain each in turn: short-term health insurance: what it covers and what it does not, health care sharing ministries explained: not insurance, so what are they? and accident, hospital indemnity and critical illness plans explained.

A worked comparison with labeled round numbers

Say a card costs $30 a month and advertises "up to 50% off." A person needs a procedure with a billed price of $2,000, and the participating provider applies a 20% discount (a hypothetical). The person pays $2,000 x 0.80 = $1,600 out of pocket. Now compare a plan with a $1,000 deductible and 20% coinsurance, where the plan's allowed amount for the same procedure is $2,000 (also a hypothetical). The person pays the $1,000 deductible plus 20% of the remaining $1,000, which is $200, for $1,200 in total.

The larger gap appears in a serious event. Say a hospital stay is billed at $60,000. A discount card may not apply to the hospital at all, and even a 20% discount leaves $48,000. A plan with a $5,000 out-of-pocket maximum caps what the person owes for covered in-network care at $5,000, plus premiums. The cap, not the discount, is what protects a household from a catastrophic bill.

How lead-generation calls fit in

Many marketing calls and online ads come from companies that sell contact information, not insurance. The caller may say "I'm calling about your health plan options" and then transfer you to whoever pays for a lead. That is not always a scam, but you cannot assume the caller is a licensed agent for the product being described. Ask:

  1. What is the full legal name of the company that issues the policy?
  2. Is the agent licensed in my state, and what is the license number?
  3. Is this health insurance, and does it cover the ten essential benefits?
  4. What is the deductible, the out-of-pocket maximum and the list of excluded conditions?
  5. Can you send me the written plan documents before I pay?

A vague answer to any of them is a reason to stop.

Red flags in the paperwork

  • The word "insurance" appears only in small print, or not at all.
  • The brochure says "not insurance," "discount program" or "membership" near the fee.
  • Benefits are described as "up to" a number per day or per service rather than as a share of your bill.
  • You pay an enrollment fee plus a monthly fee and are told that cancellations are not refundable.
  • The plan says it covers "pre-existing conditions" but has a waiting period or a list of exclusions you have to ask to see.
  • There is no member ID card, claims address or appeal process.

How to check

Your state insurance department can tell you whether a company is licensed to sell health insurance in your state and whether a product is regulated as insurance. If a product is described as coverage under the Affordable Care Act, you can compare it with the plans listed on HealthCare.gov or your state exchange. For help understanding a particular offer, a licensed broker or a marketplace navigator can review it. The Short-term plan vs ACA plan comparison shows how a limited-duration plan compares with an ACA plan on the features above.

If you have already paid for something that turns out not to be insurance, ask the seller for a refund in writing, dispute the charge with your card issuer, and report it to your state insurance department and the Federal Trade Commission. how to spot a health insurance scam and what to do about it covers reporting.

Key takeaways

  • Insurance pays claims and caps your yearly spending; a discount card does neither.
  • Fixed indemnity, short-term and sharing ministry products have their uses but are not substitutes for major medical coverage.
  • The out-of-pocket maximum, not a discount percentage, protects you from a very large bill.
  • Ask for the issuer's legal name, the agent's license and written plan documents before paying.
  • Your state insurance department can confirm whether a product is regulated insurance.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic