Guides
Appeal and external review deadlines: how many days you have
Count from the date on the denial notice: most plans allow at least 180 days to appeal internally, and about four months to request external review.
Count your days from the date on the denial notice. Most private health plans must give you at least 180 days from that notice to file an internal appeal, and after the plan's final denial you generally have four months to ask for an independent external review. Plans must also decide appeals within set periods: 72 hours when the case is urgent, and longer for standard cases. These are the usual federal outer limits for non-grandfathered private plans; the notice you received states the dates that apply to you, and Medicare, Medicaid and some other coverage use different clocks.
Why the deadline starts on the notice date
The clock generally runs from when you receive the denial notice, and the safest practice is to count from the date printed on it. A missed deadline can end your right to appeal, so write the dates on a calendar the day the notice arrives. If a deadline falls on a weekend or holiday, do not rely on an extension; send the appeal earlier. The appeal and external review deadline calculator counts forward from your notice date for each stage.
The notice itself is called an adverse benefit determination in federal rules. It must say how to appeal and when, so check it for the exact language.
The stages and their usual limits
| Stage | Who acts | Typical limit |
|---|---|---|
| Internal appeal filed | You or your representative | At least 180 days after the denial notice |
| Urgent internal appeal decided | Plan | 72 hours |
| Standard appeal decided, care not yet received | Plan | 30 days |
| Standard appeal decided, care already received | Plan | 60 days |
| External review requested | You, after the final internal denial | Generally 4 months |
| Standard external review decided | Independent reviewer | Generally 45 days after the request is received |
| Expedited external review decided | Independent reviewer | 72 hours |
The decision times on the plan's side are limits on the plan, not on you. They tell you when to expect an answer. If a plan misses its own deadline, federal rules for many plans allow you to move on to external review, but how that works varies, so ask the state insurance department or the plan what happens in your case.
Urgent cases and expedited review
If a delay could seriously jeopardize your life, your health or your ability to regain maximum function, you can ask for an expedited internal appeal. The plan generally has 72 hours to decide. Your treating doctor can usually make the request for you, and many plans give that request extra weight. For an urgent situation, you can sometimes ask for expedited internal appeal and expedited external review at the same time, depending on the plan and state.
An expedited request is not a way to get extra days. If the plan decides the case does not qualify as urgent, it should move the request to the standard timeline and tell you so.
Who decides at each stage
- Internal appeal: the plan itself, with a reviewer who was not part of the first decision.
- External review: an independent review organization that has no stake in the outcome. Your state's insurance department or, for plans in federal-process states and many employer plans, a federally contracted organization assigns the case. Which route applies depends on your plan type and state.
external review explained: when an independent reviewer decides covers eligibility and how binding the result is.
What changes by type of coverage
- Individual and small-group plans (including marketplace plans): the federal rules above apply to most non-grandfathered plans, with the state's external review process where it meets federal standards.
- Employer plans that are fully insured: the same rules apply, and the state's process usually handles external review.
- Self-funded employer plans: these follow the federal rules for appeals, and external review generally goes through a federal process rather than the state's. See ERISA for why self-funded plans are different.
- Grandfathered plans: a plan that has kept certain pre-2010 features may not be subject to every ACA appeal rule. Ask the plan whether it is grandfathered.
- Medicare and Medicaid: each has its own appeal system, with its own limits. Original Medicare, Medicare Advantage and Medicaid managed care all use different timelines, and the denial notice or the plan's materials state them. Do not assume the 180-day rule applies.
- Prior authorization denials: some denials arrive before the care occurs. The appeal limits are the same as above for private plans. See how prior authorization works and what to do when it is denied.
A worked example with round numbers
This is an illustration. Say a notice is dated June 1. Counting from that date, 180 days ends on November 28. Say the patient files an internal appeal on July 1 (day 30), and the plan, deciding a standard pre-service appeal, has until July 31 (30 days after receipt, assuming it receives the appeal that day) to answer. If the plan sends a final denial on July 25, four months from receipt of that letter runs to about November 25. The patient could wait until the last day of each window, but filing early leaves room for a missing document, a lost envelope or a request for more information.
What to do if you are close to the deadline
File something in writing now, even if the packet is not complete. Say that you are appealing and that further records will follow, and ask the plan to confirm receipt. Ask in writing for an extension if you need one, and keep the reply. If you are unsure which clock applies, call your state insurance department (how to file a complaint with your state insurance department) or the plan's appeals unit before the deadline arrives. A lawyer or patient advocate can advise on a specific case.
Key takeaways
- Count from the date on the denial notice and calendar every stage.
- Most plans allow at least 180 days for the internal appeal and about four months to request external review.
- Urgent cases can be expedited: plans generally decide in 72 hours.
- The plan's notice is the authority on your dates, and Medicare, Medicaid and self-funded plans use different processes.
- File early and keep proof of delivery.