Guides

External review explained: when an independent reviewer decides

After a plan's final internal denial, many plans must let you ask an independent reviewer to decide; the plan generally must follow the decision.

External review is a process in which an independent reviewer, not employed by your health plan, decides whether the plan was right to deny a service or claim. Under federal rules, most private health plans must offer it after you have used the plan's internal appeal, and for many kinds of denial the plan must follow the reviewer's decision if it favors you. You generally have four months from the final internal denial to ask for it, and the request goes either to your state's insurance department or to a federally overseen process, depending on your plan.

When you can use it

External review is generally available when a plan denies a claim or request after an internal appeal and the denial involves a medical judgment. Common examples are decisions that a service is not medically necessary, that a treatment is experimental or investigational, or that care was not appropriate or effective for your condition. Some plans and states extend external review to other disputes, and federal rules also cover some rescissions (cancellations of coverage after the fact) and some surprise-billing disputes. A denial that turns purely on whether you were enrolled or whether a benefit exists in your plan may not qualify, because the reviewer decides questions of medical judgment and plan rules, not what the plan chose to cover. Your final denial letter must say whether external review is available and how to request it.

If your case is urgent, you can often ask for expedited external review, and in some situations you can request it while the internal appeal is still pending. The reviewer then decides in a matter of days, generally 72 hours.

Who the reviewer is

The case goes to an independent review organization, a company or group of clinicians with no financial stake in the outcome. The organization assigns reviewers with expertise in the condition at issue. The plan sends the claim file to the reviewer, you can submit additional information, and the reviewer decides based on the evidence. That evidence can include your doctor's opinion, medical records, the plan's criteria and published clinical guidelines.

Two routes: state process and federal process

Which route applies depends on the type of plan:

Plan type Typical external review route
Fully insured individual, small-group and large-group plans Usually the state's process, run through the state insurance department
Self-funded employer plans A federal process with a contracted reviewer
Plans in states without a qualifying process The federal process
Medicare, Medicaid Separate systems with their own appeal levels

The final denial letter should tell you which applies. If it does not, ask the plan, or contact the state insurance department or the employer's benefits office. how to file a complaint with your state insurance department explains how to reach the state regulator.

How to request it

  1. Read the final internal denial letter for the instructions and the deadline.
  2. Fill in the request form that the state or federal process requires. The letter or the insurance department's website should have it.
  3. Submit it within the window, generally four months from receiving the final denial.
  4. Include a signed consent allowing the plan to release your records to the reviewer.
  5. Attach your doctor's letter and any new evidence that was not in the internal appeal, such as a recent test or a published guideline.
  6. Keep proof of delivery and note the date.

Some states ask for a small fee, usually capped by law and often waived in hardship, and many charge nothing. The plan pays the reviewer's fees. A standard review is generally decided within 45 days of the reviewer receiving the request, and the decision is sent in writing with its reasoning.

How binding is the decision

For most plans covered by the federal and state external review rules, if the reviewer decides in your favor, the plan must accept the decision and provide the coverage or pay the claim. If the reviewer upholds the plan's denial, you generally cannot appeal the same issue through external review again, though you may have other options such as a state complaint or, in some cases, going to court. Whether you can sue and what you could recover depends on the plan type and state law, and a lawyer is the right person to advise on that.

A worked example with round numbers

This is an illustration. Say a plan denied a $40,000 treatment as experimental, and its internal appeal upheld the denial on March 1. The patient has four months, to about July 1. The patient asks for external review on March 20 with a letter from the specialist and two published studies the doctor cites. The reviewer, a specialist in the same field, reads the file. Say the reviewer finds the treatment appropriate for the patient's condition under accepted standards. The plan must then cover it. If the reviewer instead agrees with the plan, the patient can still file a complaint with the state and ask the doctor about alternatives, but the external review is over.

How it differs from an internal appeal

An internal appeal asks the plan to reconsider its own decision. External review takes the decision out of the plan's hands. Different decision-makers are why external review is often worth pursuing even after an unsuccessful internal appeal, but it does not guarantee a result. See how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step for the first stage and appeal and external review deadlines: how many days you have for the time limits. appeal and external review deadline calculator counts forward from your notice date.

Key takeaways

  • External review sends a medical or coverage dispute to a reviewer independent of the plan.
  • You generally have four months from the final internal denial to request it.
  • Fully insured plans usually use the state's process, and self-funded plans use a federal one.
  • If the reviewer rules in your favor, the plan must generally follow the decision.
  • The final denial letter should say how to request review: ask the plan or your state regulator if it does not.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic