Guides

Two health plans? Coordination of benefits decides who pays first

With two plans, rules decide which is primary and which secondary; the primary pays first and the secondary may pay part of what remains.

When you are covered by two health plans, coordination of benefits (COB) rules decide which plan pays first. The first is the primary plan, which processes the claim as if it were your only coverage. The second is the secondary plan, which may pay some or all of what is left, up to its own limits. Having two plans does not mean you can collect more than the bill, and it does not guarantee you owe nothing. Plans exchange information to avoid paying twice, and an unanswered question about "other coverage" is a common reason claims stall.

Who is primary: the usual order

Most plans follow rules based on model standards from state insurance regulators. The common order is:

  1. Your own plan before a dependent plan. The plan that covers you as the employee or policyholder is primary for you. The plan that covers you as a spouse or dependent is secondary.
  2. The active-employee plan before COBRA or retiree coverage. If you have a plan through your current job and another through COBRA or a former employer, the current job's plan is generally primary. See How COBRA works: eligibility, cost and how long it lasts.
  3. Medicare and employer coverage. Which pays first depends on employer size, your reason for Medicare and whether you are working. See medicare and employer coverage: who pays first if you work past 65? and medicare secondary payer.
  4. Medicaid and similar programs are generally last. Medicaid is the payer of last resort and pays after other coverage.

Plans must use their own rules consistently, and some plans' documents carry special provisions. The "other coverage" or "coordination of benefits" section of your plan document states what applies.

The birthday rule for children

When a child is covered under both parents' plans, the "birthday rule" usually decides the primary plan. The plan of the parent whose birthday falls earlier in the calendar year is primary. It looks at month and day, not birth year. If both parents share a birthday, the plan that has covered a parent longer is typically primary.

If the parents are divorced or separated, the order often follows a court order first. Without one, a common sequence is the plan of the parent with custody, then the plan of the custodial parent's spouse, then the plan of the parent without custody. Rules can vary by state and plan, so check the plan documents. Do not confuse this with the Medigap "birthday rule" in some states, which is an unrelated rule about changing Medigap policies.

How claims are processed with two plans

  1. The provider bills the primary plan first, usually after the patient shares both cards.
  2. The primary plan applies its network, deductible and coinsurance and pays its share. The explanation of benefits shows what was paid and what remains.
  3. The claim, with the primary's explanation, goes to the secondary plan.
  4. The secondary plan calculates what it would pay under its own rules, taking into account what the primary already paid, and pays all or part of the remaining balance.

Secondary plans use different methods. Some pay up to what they would have paid as the only plan, minus what the primary paid. Others pay only until the provider's allowed amount is reached. Some secondary plans pay nothing if the primary's payment was already as large as the secondary would have paid. A secondary plan generally applies its own network rules, so using a provider outside the secondary plan's network may limit what it pays.

A worked example with round numbers

This is an illustration. Say a procedure's allowed amount under both plans is $1,000. The primary plan has a $500 deductible not yet met and then 20% coinsurance:

  • You pay the $500 deductible. The remaining $500 is shared: the primary pays 80%, which is $400, and your coinsurance is 20%, which is $100.
  • Primary plan payment: $400. Your balance after the primary: $600 ($500 + $100).

Now the secondary plan has a $200 deductible already met and 20% coinsurance. Under the "pay what it would have paid alone" method, it would pay 80% of $1,000 = $800 if it were the only plan. It has $600 left to cover, so it pays up to that, and you owe $0. Under a method that subtracts the primary's payment from what the secondary would have paid alone, it pays $800 - $400 = $400, and you owe $200. The only way to know is to ask the secondary plan how it coordinates.

Keeping your plans in sync

  • Tell both plans about the other coverage. Many plans send a questionnaire each year and deny claims until it is answered.
  • Give the provider's office both cards and say which you believe is primary.
  • Keep the primary plan's explanation of benefits to send to the secondary.
  • If a claim is denied for "other coverage," call the plan and confirm the order. This is often fixed with a phone call, as why health claims get denied: the most common reasons describes.
  • If two plans disagree about who is primary, ask both for the written rule they are applying, or ask your state insurance department.

Is a second plan worth it?

That depends on the cost of the second plan's premium, what it adds beyond the first and its network. Because the secondary plan's payment depends on the primary's, the benefit can be smaller than expected, and for some people it is little or none. A licensed broker, a benefits administrator or a SHIP counselor (for Medicare) can compare for your situation.

Key takeaways

  • COB rules set the primary and secondary plan so claims are paid in order and never more than once.
  • Your own employer plan is generally primary for you, and a dependent plan is secondary.
  • For children, the birthday rule usually makes the plan of the parent whose birthday comes first in the calendar year primary.
  • The secondary plan may pay part of what remains, and methods vary.
  • Report both plans to both insurers and providers to avoid stalled claims.

Terms used in this guide

Latest on this topic