Guides

Why health claims get denied: the most common reasons

Common denial reasons: coding errors, missing authorization, out-of-network care, medical necessity, exclusions and eligibility. Some are fixed with paperwork.

Health claims are most often denied for a handful of reasons: a billing or coding error, missing prior authorization or referral, care from an out-of-network provider, a ruling that the service is not medically necessary, a plan exclusion, an eligibility or coverage-dates problem, or a question about whether another plan should pay first. Some of these are fixed with a corrected claim or a missing document. Others require a formal appeal that argues the plan's decision was wrong. Your denial notice and explanation of benefits state which reason applies to your claim.

How a claim becomes a denial

When a provider bills a plan, the plan runs the claim through a process called claims adjudication. It checks whether you were covered on the date of service, whether the service is a covered benefit, whether the provider is in the network, whether any needed approval was on file, and whether the codes on the claim fit one another. A claim can fail at any of these checks. A partial denial, where the plan pays some lines and rejects others, is common.

Two different things are called denials, and the difference matters for what to do next. A rejection usually means the claim was never processed because of a data error, such as a wrong ID number. A denial means the plan processed the claim and decided not to pay. A rejection often just needs a corrected resubmission, while a denial is the kind that starts appeal rights.

The common reasons and what each calls for

Reason What it usually means Often fixable with paperwork?
Coding or billing error Wrong procedure or diagnosis code, a missing modifier, a duplicate claim Often yes: the provider resubmits
Patient information error Wrong member ID, date of birth or spelling Yes
No prior authorization or referral The plan required approval before the service and has none on file Sometimes: a retroactive approval may be possible, depending on the plan
Out-of-network provider The provider has no contract with your plan Sometimes: a network gap exception or emergency rules may apply
Not medically necessary The plan's reviewer decided the service does not meet its criteria No: needs an appeal with clinical support
Not a covered benefit (exclusion) The plan document excludes this type of service Rarely: depends on the plan wording and law
Experimental or investigational The plan treats the treatment as unproven No: needs an appeal with clinical evidence
Coverage not active Premium unpaid, coverage ended or date of service falls outside the term Sometimes: depends on the facts
Other insurance The plan believes another plan pays first Often yes: update the coordination information
Timely filing The provider billed after the plan's filing deadline Hard: depends on the contract

Reasons that often turn out to be fixable

Coding mismatches. If the diagnosis on the claim does not support the service billed, the plan may deny it. The provider's billing office can submit a corrected claim.

Missing authorization. Many plans require prior authorization for certain services. If the provider failed to get it, ask the provider whether it will request a review after the fact, and ask the plan whether retroactive authorization exists. Rules vary by plan.

Other coverage. If you have two plans, the plan may deny a claim until it learns which one is primary. A phone call that updates the plan's records can unlock payment. See Two health plans? Coordination of benefits decides who pays first.

Network status. If you went to an in-network facility and were treated by an out-of-network clinician, protections such as the No Surprises Act may apply. Check out-of-network rules in your plan and the explanation in your notice.

Reasons that call for an appeal

When the plan decides a service is not medically necessary, experimental, or excluded, the disagreement is about the decision rather than the paperwork. These denials are the ones that benefit from a doctor's letter, medical records and a clear statement of what the plan got wrong. The steps are in how to appeal a denied health insurance claim, step by step. A denial can be overturned on appeal; that does not mean every one is, and the outcome depends on the facts, the plan terms and the evidence.

A worked example with round numbers

This is an illustration. Say a $900 lab claim is denied with the reason "diagnosis does not support the test." You check the claim against the lab order and find that the doctor's office entered the diagnosis code from the previous visit. The office submits a corrected claim with the right code. The plan reprocesses it and pays its share. No appeal was needed because nothing about the plan's decision was in dispute, only the data on the claim. Now say the same $900 test is denied with the reason "not medically necessary" even though the code was correct. That denial needs an appeal, because the plan is disputing whether the test was warranted.

How to find the reason on your documents

  1. Find the explanation of benefits and look at the denial or remark code for the line in question.
  2. Read the code's explanation, which is usually printed on the form or on the plan's website.
  3. Compare it with the formal denial letter, if one was sent. The letter must give the specific reason.
  4. Check the provider's bill to see whether the codes match what your doctor ordered.

How to read an explanation of benefits (EOB) line by line walks through the form, and Medical bill and EOB checker helps compare the pieces. Keep in mind that your deadline to appeal runs from the denial notice, so do not let a phone call about a billing fix use up the time.

Key takeaways

  • A rejection (data error) and a denial (a decision not to pay) lead to different next steps.
  • Coding errors, wrong patient data and missing coordination information are often fixed with paperwork.
  • Medical necessity and experimental denials usually need a formal appeal with clinical evidence.
  • Your notice and explanation of benefits state the specific reason for your claim.
  • The appeal clock runs from the notice date, even while you sort out billing issues.

Terms used in this guide

Related tools

Latest on this topic